Prove that $3^16 -33$ and $3^15 +5$ is divisible by 4 by means of binomial theorem
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
This is a question that I found in a textbook:
Given that $p=q+1$, $p$ and $q$ are integers, then show that
$p^2n - 2nq-1$ is divisible by $q^2$ given that $n$ is a positive integer.
By taking a suitable value of $n$, $p$ and $q$, show that $3^16-33$ and $3^15+5$ are divisible by 4.
My proof:
$$p^2n-2nq-1=(1+q)^2n-2nq-1$$
$$=[1+2nq+frac(2n)(2n-1)2! q^2+frac2n(2n-1)(2n-2)3!q^3+...]-2nq-1$$
$$=n(2n-1)q^2+frac23 n(2n-1)(n-1)q^3+...$$
$$=q^2[n(2n-1)+frac23 n(2n-1)(n-1)q+...]$$
Hence the expansion has a common factor $q^2$
Taking $n=8$ and $p=3$, and given that $p=q+1, q=2$, by substitution,
$$3^16 -33=4[120+1120+...]$$
By factoring a 3:
$$3(3^15-11)=4[120+1120+...]$$
Dividing both sides by 3 and adding 15 to both sides:
$$3^15 +5=4[frac13(120+1120+...)+4]$$
Then it is proven that it is also divisible by 4.
The only problem I have with the proof is that how do I know that each term in the brackets $(120+1120+...)$ are divisible by 3?
proof-verification binomial-theorem
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
This is a question that I found in a textbook:
Given that $p=q+1$, $p$ and $q$ are integers, then show that
$p^2n - 2nq-1$ is divisible by $q^2$ given that $n$ is a positive integer.
By taking a suitable value of $n$, $p$ and $q$, show that $3^16-33$ and $3^15+5$ are divisible by 4.
My proof:
$$p^2n-2nq-1=(1+q)^2n-2nq-1$$
$$=[1+2nq+frac(2n)(2n-1)2! q^2+frac2n(2n-1)(2n-2)3!q^3+...]-2nq-1$$
$$=n(2n-1)q^2+frac23 n(2n-1)(n-1)q^3+...$$
$$=q^2[n(2n-1)+frac23 n(2n-1)(n-1)q+...]$$
Hence the expansion has a common factor $q^2$
Taking $n=8$ and $p=3$, and given that $p=q+1, q=2$, by substitution,
$$3^16 -33=4[120+1120+...]$$
By factoring a 3:
$$3(3^15-11)=4[120+1120+...]$$
Dividing both sides by 3 and adding 15 to both sides:
$$3^15 +5=4[frac13(120+1120+...)+4]$$
Then it is proven that it is also divisible by 4.
The only problem I have with the proof is that how do I know that each term in the brackets $(120+1120+...)$ are divisible by 3?
proof-verification binomial-theorem
1
This all seems like the long way round. $3=4-1implies 3^16=(4-1)^16$ and, expanding the latter, we see that every term is divisible by $4$ except $1^16=1$ and $1-33$ is also divisible by $4$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:13
I know, but it's a textbook question and I think that my proof isn't rigorous enough, especially at the last part, where I tried to prove that $3^15 +5$ is divisible by 4.
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:16
If you expand $(q+1)^2n$ you get $1+2nq$ plus terms divisible by $q^2$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:24
Just use what you proved in the first part.
â TonyK
Sep 2 at 11:27
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
This is a question that I found in a textbook:
Given that $p=q+1$, $p$ and $q$ are integers, then show that
$p^2n - 2nq-1$ is divisible by $q^2$ given that $n$ is a positive integer.
By taking a suitable value of $n$, $p$ and $q$, show that $3^16-33$ and $3^15+5$ are divisible by 4.
My proof:
$$p^2n-2nq-1=(1+q)^2n-2nq-1$$
$$=[1+2nq+frac(2n)(2n-1)2! q^2+frac2n(2n-1)(2n-2)3!q^3+...]-2nq-1$$
$$=n(2n-1)q^2+frac23 n(2n-1)(n-1)q^3+...$$
$$=q^2[n(2n-1)+frac23 n(2n-1)(n-1)q+...]$$
Hence the expansion has a common factor $q^2$
Taking $n=8$ and $p=3$, and given that $p=q+1, q=2$, by substitution,
$$3^16 -33=4[120+1120+...]$$
By factoring a 3:
$$3(3^15-11)=4[120+1120+...]$$
Dividing both sides by 3 and adding 15 to both sides:
$$3^15 +5=4[frac13(120+1120+...)+4]$$
Then it is proven that it is also divisible by 4.
The only problem I have with the proof is that how do I know that each term in the brackets $(120+1120+...)$ are divisible by 3?
proof-verification binomial-theorem
This is a question that I found in a textbook:
Given that $p=q+1$, $p$ and $q$ are integers, then show that
$p^2n - 2nq-1$ is divisible by $q^2$ given that $n$ is a positive integer.
By taking a suitable value of $n$, $p$ and $q$, show that $3^16-33$ and $3^15+5$ are divisible by 4.
My proof:
$$p^2n-2nq-1=(1+q)^2n-2nq-1$$
$$=[1+2nq+frac(2n)(2n-1)2! q^2+frac2n(2n-1)(2n-2)3!q^3+...]-2nq-1$$
$$=n(2n-1)q^2+frac23 n(2n-1)(n-1)q^3+...$$
$$=q^2[n(2n-1)+frac23 n(2n-1)(n-1)q+...]$$
Hence the expansion has a common factor $q^2$
Taking $n=8$ and $p=3$, and given that $p=q+1, q=2$, by substitution,
$$3^16 -33=4[120+1120+...]$$
By factoring a 3:
$$3(3^15-11)=4[120+1120+...]$$
Dividing both sides by 3 and adding 15 to both sides:
$$3^15 +5=4[frac13(120+1120+...)+4]$$
Then it is proven that it is also divisible by 4.
The only problem I have with the proof is that how do I know that each term in the brackets $(120+1120+...)$ are divisible by 3?
proof-verification binomial-theorem
proof-verification binomial-theorem
edited Sep 2 at 11:20
asked Sep 2 at 11:10
Loo Soo Yong
1355
1355
1
This all seems like the long way round. $3=4-1implies 3^16=(4-1)^16$ and, expanding the latter, we see that every term is divisible by $4$ except $1^16=1$ and $1-33$ is also divisible by $4$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:13
I know, but it's a textbook question and I think that my proof isn't rigorous enough, especially at the last part, where I tried to prove that $3^15 +5$ is divisible by 4.
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:16
If you expand $(q+1)^2n$ you get $1+2nq$ plus terms divisible by $q^2$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:24
Just use what you proved in the first part.
â TonyK
Sep 2 at 11:27
add a comment |Â
1
This all seems like the long way round. $3=4-1implies 3^16=(4-1)^16$ and, expanding the latter, we see that every term is divisible by $4$ except $1^16=1$ and $1-33$ is also divisible by $4$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:13
I know, but it's a textbook question and I think that my proof isn't rigorous enough, especially at the last part, where I tried to prove that $3^15 +5$ is divisible by 4.
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:16
If you expand $(q+1)^2n$ you get $1+2nq$ plus terms divisible by $q^2$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:24
Just use what you proved in the first part.
â TonyK
Sep 2 at 11:27
1
1
This all seems like the long way round. $3=4-1implies 3^16=(4-1)^16$ and, expanding the latter, we see that every term is divisible by $4$ except $1^16=1$ and $1-33$ is also divisible by $4$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:13
This all seems like the long way round. $3=4-1implies 3^16=(4-1)^16$ and, expanding the latter, we see that every term is divisible by $4$ except $1^16=1$ and $1-33$ is also divisible by $4$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:13
I know, but it's a textbook question and I think that my proof isn't rigorous enough, especially at the last part, where I tried to prove that $3^15 +5$ is divisible by 4.
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:16
I know, but it's a textbook question and I think that my proof isn't rigorous enough, especially at the last part, where I tried to prove that $3^15 +5$ is divisible by 4.
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:16
If you expand $(q+1)^2n$ you get $1+2nq$ plus terms divisible by $q^2$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:24
If you expand $(q+1)^2n$ you get $1+2nq$ plus terms divisible by $q^2$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:24
Just use what you proved in the first part.
â TonyK
Sep 2 at 11:27
Just use what you proved in the first part.
â TonyK
Sep 2 at 11:27
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
It's better if you use
$$
(1+q)^2n=1+2nq+sum_k=2^2nbinom2nkq^k
$$
so
$$
p^2n-2nq-1=q^2sum_k=2^2nbinom2nkq^k-2
$$
is divisible by $q^2$.
With $q=2$ and $n=8$ you have $p=3$ and $p^2n-2nq-1=3^16-33$.
For the second case, consider
$$
3^15+5=3(3^14-29)+3cdot29+5
$$
and set $q=2$, $n=7$, noting that $3cdot 29+5=92$, which is divisible by $4$.
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
Use the Euclid lemma in last implication:
$$begineqnarray
3(3^15-11)=4[120+1120+...]&implies &3mid 4[120+1120+...] \
&implies & 3mid 120+1120+...
endeqnarray$$
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
By the Euclid's lemma: $3(3^15-11)=4cdot [120+1120+...]$ implies that $3$ must divide either $4$ or the sum. It does not divide $4$, hence the conclusion.
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
It's better if you use
$$
(1+q)^2n=1+2nq+sum_k=2^2nbinom2nkq^k
$$
so
$$
p^2n-2nq-1=q^2sum_k=2^2nbinom2nkq^k-2
$$
is divisible by $q^2$.
With $q=2$ and $n=8$ you have $p=3$ and $p^2n-2nq-1=3^16-33$.
For the second case, consider
$$
3^15+5=3(3^14-29)+3cdot29+5
$$
and set $q=2$, $n=7$, noting that $3cdot 29+5=92$, which is divisible by $4$.
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
It's better if you use
$$
(1+q)^2n=1+2nq+sum_k=2^2nbinom2nkq^k
$$
so
$$
p^2n-2nq-1=q^2sum_k=2^2nbinom2nkq^k-2
$$
is divisible by $q^2$.
With $q=2$ and $n=8$ you have $p=3$ and $p^2n-2nq-1=3^16-33$.
For the second case, consider
$$
3^15+5=3(3^14-29)+3cdot29+5
$$
and set $q=2$, $n=7$, noting that $3cdot 29+5=92$, which is divisible by $4$.
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
It's better if you use
$$
(1+q)^2n=1+2nq+sum_k=2^2nbinom2nkq^k
$$
so
$$
p^2n-2nq-1=q^2sum_k=2^2nbinom2nkq^k-2
$$
is divisible by $q^2$.
With $q=2$ and $n=8$ you have $p=3$ and $p^2n-2nq-1=3^16-33$.
For the second case, consider
$$
3^15+5=3(3^14-29)+3cdot29+5
$$
and set $q=2$, $n=7$, noting that $3cdot 29+5=92$, which is divisible by $4$.
It's better if you use
$$
(1+q)^2n=1+2nq+sum_k=2^2nbinom2nkq^k
$$
so
$$
p^2n-2nq-1=q^2sum_k=2^2nbinom2nkq^k-2
$$
is divisible by $q^2$.
With $q=2$ and $n=8$ you have $p=3$ and $p^2n-2nq-1=3^16-33$.
For the second case, consider
$$
3^15+5=3(3^14-29)+3cdot29+5
$$
and set $q=2$, $n=7$, noting that $3cdot 29+5=92$, which is divisible by $4$.
answered Sep 2 at 12:55
egreg
167k1180189
167k1180189
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
Use the Euclid lemma in last implication:
$$begineqnarray
3(3^15-11)=4[120+1120+...]&implies &3mid 4[120+1120+...] \
&implies & 3mid 120+1120+...
endeqnarray$$
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
Use the Euclid lemma in last implication:
$$begineqnarray
3(3^15-11)=4[120+1120+...]&implies &3mid 4[120+1120+...] \
&implies & 3mid 120+1120+...
endeqnarray$$
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
Use the Euclid lemma in last implication:
$$begineqnarray
3(3^15-11)=4[120+1120+...]&implies &3mid 4[120+1120+...] \
&implies & 3mid 120+1120+...
endeqnarray$$
Use the Euclid lemma in last implication:
$$begineqnarray
3(3^15-11)=4[120+1120+...]&implies &3mid 4[120+1120+...] \
&implies & 3mid 120+1120+...
endeqnarray$$
edited Sep 2 at 12:32
answered Sep 2 at 11:49
greedoid
28.1k93776
28.1k93776
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
By the Euclid's lemma: $3(3^15-11)=4cdot [120+1120+...]$ implies that $3$ must divide either $4$ or the sum. It does not divide $4$, hence the conclusion.
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
By the Euclid's lemma: $3(3^15-11)=4cdot [120+1120+...]$ implies that $3$ must divide either $4$ or the sum. It does not divide $4$, hence the conclusion.
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
By the Euclid's lemma: $3(3^15-11)=4cdot [120+1120+...]$ implies that $3$ must divide either $4$ or the sum. It does not divide $4$, hence the conclusion.
By the Euclid's lemma: $3(3^15-11)=4cdot [120+1120+...]$ implies that $3$ must divide either $4$ or the sum. It does not divide $4$, hence the conclusion.
answered Sep 2 at 12:24
farruhota
15.3k2734
15.3k2734
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2902603%2fprove-that-316-33-and-315-5-is-divisible-by-4-by-means-of-binomial-t%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
1
This all seems like the long way round. $3=4-1implies 3^16=(4-1)^16$ and, expanding the latter, we see that every term is divisible by $4$ except $1^16=1$ and $1-33$ is also divisible by $4$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:13
I know, but it's a textbook question and I think that my proof isn't rigorous enough, especially at the last part, where I tried to prove that $3^15 +5$ is divisible by 4.
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:16
If you expand $(q+1)^2n$ you get $1+2nq$ plus terms divisible by $q^2$.
â lulu
Sep 2 at 11:24
Just use what you proved in the first part.
â TonyK
Sep 2 at 11:27