Find a sequence converging to $1/k^infty_k=1$ in $l^2$
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
Let $s=1/k^infty_k=1$. Find a sequence $s_n^infty_n=1$ of points in $l^2$ such that each $s_n$ is distinct from $s$ and such that $s_n^infty_n=1$ converges to $s$ in $l^2$.
This is a problem from Goldberg. Exercise 4.3, 3. I don't understand the question. How can I find a sequence that converges to another sequence? Is $s$ the limit of $1/k$ or it is the variable assigned to the sequence itself? If it is the limit then it can be worked out
real-analysis sequences-and-series metric-spaces
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
Let $s=1/k^infty_k=1$. Find a sequence $s_n^infty_n=1$ of points in $l^2$ such that each $s_n$ is distinct from $s$ and such that $s_n^infty_n=1$ converges to $s$ in $l^2$.
This is a problem from Goldberg. Exercise 4.3, 3. I don't understand the question. How can I find a sequence that converges to another sequence? Is $s$ the limit of $1/k$ or it is the variable assigned to the sequence itself? If it is the limit then it can be worked out
real-analysis sequences-and-series metric-spaces
2
Recall that $l^2$ is the space of all square summable sequences, i.e. the elements of $l^2$ are sequences, so you need to find a sequence of sequences that converges to the sequence $1/k_k=1^infty$.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 7:20
@sobi Thanks! now I understood
â Who cares
Sep 2 at 7:23
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
Let $s=1/k^infty_k=1$. Find a sequence $s_n^infty_n=1$ of points in $l^2$ such that each $s_n$ is distinct from $s$ and such that $s_n^infty_n=1$ converges to $s$ in $l^2$.
This is a problem from Goldberg. Exercise 4.3, 3. I don't understand the question. How can I find a sequence that converges to another sequence? Is $s$ the limit of $1/k$ or it is the variable assigned to the sequence itself? If it is the limit then it can be worked out
real-analysis sequences-and-series metric-spaces
Let $s=1/k^infty_k=1$. Find a sequence $s_n^infty_n=1$ of points in $l^2$ such that each $s_n$ is distinct from $s$ and such that $s_n^infty_n=1$ converges to $s$ in $l^2$.
This is a problem from Goldberg. Exercise 4.3, 3. I don't understand the question. How can I find a sequence that converges to another sequence? Is $s$ the limit of $1/k$ or it is the variable assigned to the sequence itself? If it is the limit then it can be worked out
real-analysis sequences-and-series metric-spaces
real-analysis sequences-and-series metric-spaces
asked Sep 2 at 7:15
Who cares
14111
14111
2
Recall that $l^2$ is the space of all square summable sequences, i.e. the elements of $l^2$ are sequences, so you need to find a sequence of sequences that converges to the sequence $1/k_k=1^infty$.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 7:20
@sobi Thanks! now I understood
â Who cares
Sep 2 at 7:23
add a comment |Â
2
Recall that $l^2$ is the space of all square summable sequences, i.e. the elements of $l^2$ are sequences, so you need to find a sequence of sequences that converges to the sequence $1/k_k=1^infty$.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 7:20
@sobi Thanks! now I understood
â Who cares
Sep 2 at 7:23
2
2
Recall that $l^2$ is the space of all square summable sequences, i.e. the elements of $l^2$ are sequences, so you need to find a sequence of sequences that converges to the sequence $1/k_k=1^infty$.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 7:20
Recall that $l^2$ is the space of all square summable sequences, i.e. the elements of $l^2$ are sequences, so you need to find a sequence of sequences that converges to the sequence $1/k_k=1^infty$.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 7:20
@sobi Thanks! now I understood
â Who cares
Sep 2 at 7:23
@sobi Thanks! now I understood
â Who cares
Sep 2 at 7:23
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
Hint. Recall that $l^2$ is the normed space of all square summable sequences $s$, such that
$$|s|^2_2=sum_k=1^inftys(k)^2<+infty.$$
Let $s_n(k):=frac1k+frac1nk$ (also $s_n(k):=fraca_nk$ with $a_nto 1$ will work), then $s_n(k)_kgeq1in l^2$ for each $ngeq 1$. Now consider the limit of
$$lim_nto infty|s_n-s|^2_2=lim_nto inftysum_k=1^inftyleft(s_n(k)-frac1kright)^2$$
and show that it is zero.
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
Consider $s_n = left(1, frac12, ldots, frac1n, 0, 0, ldotsright) in ell^2$. We have
$$|s - s_n|_2^2 = left|left(0, , ldots, 0, frac1n+1, frac1n+2, ldotsright)right|_2^2 = sum_k=n+1^infty frac1k^2 xrightarrowntoinfty 0$$
because $sum frac1k^2$ is a convergent series. Therefore $(s_n)_n=1^infty$ converges to $s$ in $ell^2$.
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
@RobertZ was much quicker than me, but here is another example in case you need it. Put
$$ s_n = leftfrac1k+frac1nright_k=1^infty. $$
Then $s_n in l^2$ for each $n geq 1$ by comparison with $sum 1/k^2,$ i.e.
$$ sum_k=1^infty left(frac1k+frac1nright)^2 leq sum_k=1^infty frac1k^2 < infty, $$
and $s_n to s$ in $l^2$ since
$$ sum_k=1^infty left( frac1k+frac1n-frac1k right)^2
= frac1n^2sum_k=1^infty left(frac1left(k+frac1nright)kright)^2
leq frac1n^2sum_k=1^infty frac1k^4 to 0, text as nto infty, $$
since the last sum is bounded.
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
Hint. Recall that $l^2$ is the normed space of all square summable sequences $s$, such that
$$|s|^2_2=sum_k=1^inftys(k)^2<+infty.$$
Let $s_n(k):=frac1k+frac1nk$ (also $s_n(k):=fraca_nk$ with $a_nto 1$ will work), then $s_n(k)_kgeq1in l^2$ for each $ngeq 1$. Now consider the limit of
$$lim_nto infty|s_n-s|^2_2=lim_nto inftysum_k=1^inftyleft(s_n(k)-frac1kright)^2$$
and show that it is zero.
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
Hint. Recall that $l^2$ is the normed space of all square summable sequences $s$, such that
$$|s|^2_2=sum_k=1^inftys(k)^2<+infty.$$
Let $s_n(k):=frac1k+frac1nk$ (also $s_n(k):=fraca_nk$ with $a_nto 1$ will work), then $s_n(k)_kgeq1in l^2$ for each $ngeq 1$. Now consider the limit of
$$lim_nto infty|s_n-s|^2_2=lim_nto inftysum_k=1^inftyleft(s_n(k)-frac1kright)^2$$
and show that it is zero.
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
Hint. Recall that $l^2$ is the normed space of all square summable sequences $s$, such that
$$|s|^2_2=sum_k=1^inftys(k)^2<+infty.$$
Let $s_n(k):=frac1k+frac1nk$ (also $s_n(k):=fraca_nk$ with $a_nto 1$ will work), then $s_n(k)_kgeq1in l^2$ for each $ngeq 1$. Now consider the limit of
$$lim_nto infty|s_n-s|^2_2=lim_nto inftysum_k=1^inftyleft(s_n(k)-frac1kright)^2$$
and show that it is zero.
Hint. Recall that $l^2$ is the normed space of all square summable sequences $s$, such that
$$|s|^2_2=sum_k=1^inftys(k)^2<+infty.$$
Let $s_n(k):=frac1k+frac1nk$ (also $s_n(k):=fraca_nk$ with $a_nto 1$ will work), then $s_n(k)_kgeq1in l^2$ for each $ngeq 1$. Now consider the limit of
$$lim_nto infty|s_n-s|^2_2=lim_nto inftysum_k=1^inftyleft(s_n(k)-frac1kright)^2$$
and show that it is zero.
edited Sep 2 at 7:38
answered Sep 2 at 7:23
Robert Z
85.6k1055123
85.6k1055123
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
Consider $s_n = left(1, frac12, ldots, frac1n, 0, 0, ldotsright) in ell^2$. We have
$$|s - s_n|_2^2 = left|left(0, , ldots, 0, frac1n+1, frac1n+2, ldotsright)right|_2^2 = sum_k=n+1^infty frac1k^2 xrightarrowntoinfty 0$$
because $sum frac1k^2$ is a convergent series. Therefore $(s_n)_n=1^infty$ converges to $s$ in $ell^2$.
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
Consider $s_n = left(1, frac12, ldots, frac1n, 0, 0, ldotsright) in ell^2$. We have
$$|s - s_n|_2^2 = left|left(0, , ldots, 0, frac1n+1, frac1n+2, ldotsright)right|_2^2 = sum_k=n+1^infty frac1k^2 xrightarrowntoinfty 0$$
because $sum frac1k^2$ is a convergent series. Therefore $(s_n)_n=1^infty$ converges to $s$ in $ell^2$.
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
Consider $s_n = left(1, frac12, ldots, frac1n, 0, 0, ldotsright) in ell^2$. We have
$$|s - s_n|_2^2 = left|left(0, , ldots, 0, frac1n+1, frac1n+2, ldotsright)right|_2^2 = sum_k=n+1^infty frac1k^2 xrightarrowntoinfty 0$$
because $sum frac1k^2$ is a convergent series. Therefore $(s_n)_n=1^infty$ converges to $s$ in $ell^2$.
Consider $s_n = left(1, frac12, ldots, frac1n, 0, 0, ldotsright) in ell^2$. We have
$$|s - s_n|_2^2 = left|left(0, , ldots, 0, frac1n+1, frac1n+2, ldotsright)right|_2^2 = sum_k=n+1^infty frac1k^2 xrightarrowntoinfty 0$$
because $sum frac1k^2$ is a convergent series. Therefore $(s_n)_n=1^infty$ converges to $s$ in $ell^2$.
answered Sep 2 at 12:25
mechanodroid
24.1k52244
24.1k52244
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
@RobertZ was much quicker than me, but here is another example in case you need it. Put
$$ s_n = leftfrac1k+frac1nright_k=1^infty. $$
Then $s_n in l^2$ for each $n geq 1$ by comparison with $sum 1/k^2,$ i.e.
$$ sum_k=1^infty left(frac1k+frac1nright)^2 leq sum_k=1^infty frac1k^2 < infty, $$
and $s_n to s$ in $l^2$ since
$$ sum_k=1^infty left( frac1k+frac1n-frac1k right)^2
= frac1n^2sum_k=1^infty left(frac1left(k+frac1nright)kright)^2
leq frac1n^2sum_k=1^infty frac1k^4 to 0, text as nto infty, $$
since the last sum is bounded.
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
@RobertZ was much quicker than me, but here is another example in case you need it. Put
$$ s_n = leftfrac1k+frac1nright_k=1^infty. $$
Then $s_n in l^2$ for each $n geq 1$ by comparison with $sum 1/k^2,$ i.e.
$$ sum_k=1^infty left(frac1k+frac1nright)^2 leq sum_k=1^infty frac1k^2 < infty, $$
and $s_n to s$ in $l^2$ since
$$ sum_k=1^infty left( frac1k+frac1n-frac1k right)^2
= frac1n^2sum_k=1^infty left(frac1left(k+frac1nright)kright)^2
leq frac1n^2sum_k=1^infty frac1k^4 to 0, text as nto infty, $$
since the last sum is bounded.
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
@RobertZ was much quicker than me, but here is another example in case you need it. Put
$$ s_n = leftfrac1k+frac1nright_k=1^infty. $$
Then $s_n in l^2$ for each $n geq 1$ by comparison with $sum 1/k^2,$ i.e.
$$ sum_k=1^infty left(frac1k+frac1nright)^2 leq sum_k=1^infty frac1k^2 < infty, $$
and $s_n to s$ in $l^2$ since
$$ sum_k=1^infty left( frac1k+frac1n-frac1k right)^2
= frac1n^2sum_k=1^infty left(frac1left(k+frac1nright)kright)^2
leq frac1n^2sum_k=1^infty frac1k^4 to 0, text as nto infty, $$
since the last sum is bounded.
@RobertZ was much quicker than me, but here is another example in case you need it. Put
$$ s_n = leftfrac1k+frac1nright_k=1^infty. $$
Then $s_n in l^2$ for each $n geq 1$ by comparison with $sum 1/k^2,$ i.e.
$$ sum_k=1^infty left(frac1k+frac1nright)^2 leq sum_k=1^infty frac1k^2 < infty, $$
and $s_n to s$ in $l^2$ since
$$ sum_k=1^infty left( frac1k+frac1n-frac1k right)^2
= frac1n^2sum_k=1^infty left(frac1left(k+frac1nright)kright)^2
leq frac1n^2sum_k=1^infty frac1k^4 to 0, text as nto infty, $$
since the last sum is bounded.
answered Sep 2 at 7:36
Sobi
2,843417
2,843417
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2902426%2ffind-a-sequence-converging-to-1-k-infty-k-1-in-l2%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
2
Recall that $l^2$ is the space of all square summable sequences, i.e. the elements of $l^2$ are sequences, so you need to find a sequence of sequences that converges to the sequence $1/k_k=1^infty$.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 7:20
@sobi Thanks! now I understood
â Who cares
Sep 2 at 7:23