Evaluating the limit of $x^2 (1-cosfrac1x)$ when $x$ approaches infinity
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
I wanted to evaluate the limit
$$lim_xtoinftyx^2(1-cosfrac1x)$$
Since we know that
$-1leq cos xleq1$ and that $-1leq cosfrac1x leq 1$, so by algebraic manipulation,
$0leq x^2(1-cosfrac1x)leq2x^2 $.
Why does squeeze theorem fails to obtain a numerical limit here since the actual limit is $frac12$? I know the whole limit would be 0 when $x$ approaches 0.
limits-without-lhopital
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
I wanted to evaluate the limit
$$lim_xtoinftyx^2(1-cosfrac1x)$$
Since we know that
$-1leq cos xleq1$ and that $-1leq cosfrac1x leq 1$, so by algebraic manipulation,
$0leq x^2(1-cosfrac1x)leq2x^2 $.
Why does squeeze theorem fails to obtain a numerical limit here since the actual limit is $frac12$? I know the whole limit would be 0 when $x$ approaches 0.
limits-without-lhopital
2
The squeeze theorem does not fail. Note that when $xto infty$, we have $2x^2 to infty,$ so you can only conclude that $$ 0 leq lim_x to infty x^2(1-cos(1/x)) < infty. $$
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:57
So the only way to evaluate this is via a series expansion?
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:58
1
That is probably the simplest way to do it, but it is surely not the only way to do it.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:59
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
I wanted to evaluate the limit
$$lim_xtoinftyx^2(1-cosfrac1x)$$
Since we know that
$-1leq cos xleq1$ and that $-1leq cosfrac1x leq 1$, so by algebraic manipulation,
$0leq x^2(1-cosfrac1x)leq2x^2 $.
Why does squeeze theorem fails to obtain a numerical limit here since the actual limit is $frac12$? I know the whole limit would be 0 when $x$ approaches 0.
limits-without-lhopital
I wanted to evaluate the limit
$$lim_xtoinftyx^2(1-cosfrac1x)$$
Since we know that
$-1leq cos xleq1$ and that $-1leq cosfrac1x leq 1$, so by algebraic manipulation,
$0leq x^2(1-cosfrac1x)leq2x^2 $.
Why does squeeze theorem fails to obtain a numerical limit here since the actual limit is $frac12$? I know the whole limit would be 0 when $x$ approaches 0.
limits-without-lhopital
limits-without-lhopital
edited Sep 2 at 12:00
asked Sep 2 at 11:56
Loo Soo Yong
1355
1355
2
The squeeze theorem does not fail. Note that when $xto infty$, we have $2x^2 to infty,$ so you can only conclude that $$ 0 leq lim_x to infty x^2(1-cos(1/x)) < infty. $$
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:57
So the only way to evaluate this is via a series expansion?
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:58
1
That is probably the simplest way to do it, but it is surely not the only way to do it.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:59
add a comment |Â
2
The squeeze theorem does not fail. Note that when $xto infty$, we have $2x^2 to infty,$ so you can only conclude that $$ 0 leq lim_x to infty x^2(1-cos(1/x)) < infty. $$
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:57
So the only way to evaluate this is via a series expansion?
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:58
1
That is probably the simplest way to do it, but it is surely not the only way to do it.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:59
2
2
The squeeze theorem does not fail. Note that when $xto infty$, we have $2x^2 to infty,$ so you can only conclude that $$ 0 leq lim_x to infty x^2(1-cos(1/x)) < infty. $$
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:57
The squeeze theorem does not fail. Note that when $xto infty$, we have $2x^2 to infty,$ so you can only conclude that $$ 0 leq lim_x to infty x^2(1-cos(1/x)) < infty. $$
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:57
So the only way to evaluate this is via a series expansion?
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:58
So the only way to evaluate this is via a series expansion?
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:58
1
1
That is probably the simplest way to do it, but it is surely not the only way to do it.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:59
That is probably the simplest way to do it, but it is surely not the only way to do it.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:59
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
Following up on my comment, one way to do it without Taylor expansions is so to note that
$$ cos 2y = 1-2sin^2 y quad Leftrightarrow quad 2sin^2 fracu2 = 1-cos u,$$
so
beginalign
lim_xto infty x^2left(1-cosfrac1xright) &=[u = 1/x] = lim_u to 0^+ frac1-cos uu^2\
&= lim_uto 0 ^+ frac2sin^2 fracu2u^2 = frac12lim_u to 0^+ fracsin^2 (u/2)(u/2)^2\
&= frac12 left(lim_u to 0^+ fracsin(u/2)u/2right)^2
= frac12cdot 1^2 = frac12.
endalign
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
This limit is fairly standard in high school: $;limlimits_uto 0dfrac1-cos uu^2=dfrac12$, so
$$x^2Bigl(1-cosfrac1xBigr)=frac1-coscfrac1xcfrac1x^2tofrac12 ;text as ;frac1xto 0.$$
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
$cos(t) = 1 - frac12 t^2 + O(t^4)$ for $t$ close to $0$ and, so when $|x|$ is large also for $cos(frac1x)$.
So substituting $t = frac1x$ we have that we consider the limit $frac1t^2(1 - cos(t))$ for $t downarrow 0$. Using the above estimate for $cos(t)$, the $1$'s cancel and we are left with $frac1t^2(frac12t^2 + O(t^4)) = frac12 + O(t^2)$ So indeed the limit is $frac12$ and series expansion is the easiest (IMHO) way to see it.
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
Following up on my comment, one way to do it without Taylor expansions is so to note that
$$ cos 2y = 1-2sin^2 y quad Leftrightarrow quad 2sin^2 fracu2 = 1-cos u,$$
so
beginalign
lim_xto infty x^2left(1-cosfrac1xright) &=[u = 1/x] = lim_u to 0^+ frac1-cos uu^2\
&= lim_uto 0 ^+ frac2sin^2 fracu2u^2 = frac12lim_u to 0^+ fracsin^2 (u/2)(u/2)^2\
&= frac12 left(lim_u to 0^+ fracsin(u/2)u/2right)^2
= frac12cdot 1^2 = frac12.
endalign
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
Following up on my comment, one way to do it without Taylor expansions is so to note that
$$ cos 2y = 1-2sin^2 y quad Leftrightarrow quad 2sin^2 fracu2 = 1-cos u,$$
so
beginalign
lim_xto infty x^2left(1-cosfrac1xright) &=[u = 1/x] = lim_u to 0^+ frac1-cos uu^2\
&= lim_uto 0 ^+ frac2sin^2 fracu2u^2 = frac12lim_u to 0^+ fracsin^2 (u/2)(u/2)^2\
&= frac12 left(lim_u to 0^+ fracsin(u/2)u/2right)^2
= frac12cdot 1^2 = frac12.
endalign
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
Following up on my comment, one way to do it without Taylor expansions is so to note that
$$ cos 2y = 1-2sin^2 y quad Leftrightarrow quad 2sin^2 fracu2 = 1-cos u,$$
so
beginalign
lim_xto infty x^2left(1-cosfrac1xright) &=[u = 1/x] = lim_u to 0^+ frac1-cos uu^2\
&= lim_uto 0 ^+ frac2sin^2 fracu2u^2 = frac12lim_u to 0^+ fracsin^2 (u/2)(u/2)^2\
&= frac12 left(lim_u to 0^+ fracsin(u/2)u/2right)^2
= frac12cdot 1^2 = frac12.
endalign
Following up on my comment, one way to do it without Taylor expansions is so to note that
$$ cos 2y = 1-2sin^2 y quad Leftrightarrow quad 2sin^2 fracu2 = 1-cos u,$$
so
beginalign
lim_xto infty x^2left(1-cosfrac1xright) &=[u = 1/x] = lim_u to 0^+ frac1-cos uu^2\
&= lim_uto 0 ^+ frac2sin^2 fracu2u^2 = frac12lim_u to 0^+ fracsin^2 (u/2)(u/2)^2\
&= frac12 left(lim_u to 0^+ fracsin(u/2)u/2right)^2
= frac12cdot 1^2 = frac12.
endalign
answered Sep 2 at 12:05
Sobi
2,845417
2,845417
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
This limit is fairly standard in high school: $;limlimits_uto 0dfrac1-cos uu^2=dfrac12$, so
$$x^2Bigl(1-cosfrac1xBigr)=frac1-coscfrac1xcfrac1x^2tofrac12 ;text as ;frac1xto 0.$$
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
This limit is fairly standard in high school: $;limlimits_uto 0dfrac1-cos uu^2=dfrac12$, so
$$x^2Bigl(1-cosfrac1xBigr)=frac1-coscfrac1xcfrac1x^2tofrac12 ;text as ;frac1xto 0.$$
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
This limit is fairly standard in high school: $;limlimits_uto 0dfrac1-cos uu^2=dfrac12$, so
$$x^2Bigl(1-cosfrac1xBigr)=frac1-coscfrac1xcfrac1x^2tofrac12 ;text as ;frac1xto 0.$$
This limit is fairly standard in high school: $;limlimits_uto 0dfrac1-cos uu^2=dfrac12$, so
$$x^2Bigl(1-cosfrac1xBigr)=frac1-coscfrac1xcfrac1x^2tofrac12 ;text as ;frac1xto 0.$$
answered Sep 2 at 12:10
Bernard
112k635104
112k635104
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
$cos(t) = 1 - frac12 t^2 + O(t^4)$ for $t$ close to $0$ and, so when $|x|$ is large also for $cos(frac1x)$.
So substituting $t = frac1x$ we have that we consider the limit $frac1t^2(1 - cos(t))$ for $t downarrow 0$. Using the above estimate for $cos(t)$, the $1$'s cancel and we are left with $frac1t^2(frac12t^2 + O(t^4)) = frac12 + O(t^2)$ So indeed the limit is $frac12$ and series expansion is the easiest (IMHO) way to see it.
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
$cos(t) = 1 - frac12 t^2 + O(t^4)$ for $t$ close to $0$ and, so when $|x|$ is large also for $cos(frac1x)$.
So substituting $t = frac1x$ we have that we consider the limit $frac1t^2(1 - cos(t))$ for $t downarrow 0$. Using the above estimate for $cos(t)$, the $1$'s cancel and we are left with $frac1t^2(frac12t^2 + O(t^4)) = frac12 + O(t^2)$ So indeed the limit is $frac12$ and series expansion is the easiest (IMHO) way to see it.
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
$cos(t) = 1 - frac12 t^2 + O(t^4)$ for $t$ close to $0$ and, so when $|x|$ is large also for $cos(frac1x)$.
So substituting $t = frac1x$ we have that we consider the limit $frac1t^2(1 - cos(t))$ for $t downarrow 0$. Using the above estimate for $cos(t)$, the $1$'s cancel and we are left with $frac1t^2(frac12t^2 + O(t^4)) = frac12 + O(t^2)$ So indeed the limit is $frac12$ and series expansion is the easiest (IMHO) way to see it.
$cos(t) = 1 - frac12 t^2 + O(t^4)$ for $t$ close to $0$ and, so when $|x|$ is large also for $cos(frac1x)$.
So substituting $t = frac1x$ we have that we consider the limit $frac1t^2(1 - cos(t))$ for $t downarrow 0$. Using the above estimate for $cos(t)$, the $1$'s cancel and we are left with $frac1t^2(frac12t^2 + O(t^4)) = frac12 + O(t^2)$ So indeed the limit is $frac12$ and series expansion is the easiest (IMHO) way to see it.
answered Sep 2 at 12:05
Henno Brandsma
93.4k342101
93.4k342101
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2902642%2fevaluating-the-limit-of-x2-1-cos-frac1x-when-x-approaches-infinity%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
2
The squeeze theorem does not fail. Note that when $xto infty$, we have $2x^2 to infty,$ so you can only conclude that $$ 0 leq lim_x to infty x^2(1-cos(1/x)) < infty. $$
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:57
So the only way to evaluate this is via a series expansion?
â Loo Soo Yong
Sep 2 at 11:58
1
That is probably the simplest way to do it, but it is surely not the only way to do it.
â Sobi
Sep 2 at 11:59