What's a degree âby resolutionâ?
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
12
down vote
favorite
The screenshot beneath is from Prof. James Goudkamp's profile. See the red arrow.
What's meant "by resolution"?
Why was this MA obtained after all his other degrees?
I know that the Oxbridge MA "is an academic rank, and not a postgraduate qualification", as
Bachelors of Arts with Honours of these universities are promoted to the title of Master of Arts or Master in Arts (MA) on application after six or seven years' seniority as members of the university (including years as an undergraduate).
united-kingdom
add a comment |Â
up vote
12
down vote
favorite
The screenshot beneath is from Prof. James Goudkamp's profile. See the red arrow.
What's meant "by resolution"?
Why was this MA obtained after all his other degrees?
I know that the Oxbridge MA "is an academic rank, and not a postgraduate qualification", as
Bachelors of Arts with Honours of these universities are promoted to the title of Master of Arts or Master in Arts (MA) on application after six or seven years' seniority as members of the university (including years as an undergraduate).
united-kingdom
Not an answer, but in Oxford MAs take academic precedence of Doctors who do not have an MA.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:12
add a comment |Â
up vote
12
down vote
favorite
up vote
12
down vote
favorite
The screenshot beneath is from Prof. James Goudkamp's profile. See the red arrow.
What's meant "by resolution"?
Why was this MA obtained after all his other degrees?
I know that the Oxbridge MA "is an academic rank, and not a postgraduate qualification", as
Bachelors of Arts with Honours of these universities are promoted to the title of Master of Arts or Master in Arts (MA) on application after six or seven years' seniority as members of the university (including years as an undergraduate).
united-kingdom
The screenshot beneath is from Prof. James Goudkamp's profile. See the red arrow.
What's meant "by resolution"?
Why was this MA obtained after all his other degrees?
I know that the Oxbridge MA "is an academic rank, and not a postgraduate qualification", as
Bachelors of Arts with Honours of these universities are promoted to the title of Master of Arts or Master in Arts (MA) on application after six or seven years' seniority as members of the university (including years as an undergraduate).
united-kingdom
edited Aug 12 at 17:56
asked Aug 12 at 4:18
Greek - Area 51 Proposal
493311
493311
Not an answer, but in Oxford MAs take academic precedence of Doctors who do not have an MA.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:12
add a comment |Â
Not an answer, but in Oxford MAs take academic precedence of Doctors who do not have an MA.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:12
Not an answer, but in Oxford MAs take academic precedence of Doctors who do not have an MA.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:12
Not an answer, but in Oxford MAs take academic precedence of Doctors who do not have an MA.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:12
add a comment |Â
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
up vote
10
down vote
Basically, it's a "free masters degree" to members who otherwise don't qualify for the masters degree, for various reasons.
Here it is, direct from Oxford:
Conferment of Degrees
7.1. The procedures for the conferment, both at the Encaenia and on other occasions, of Degrees by Diploma, Honorary Degrees, Ordinary
Degrees, and Degrees by Incorporation shall be determined by
regulation, and the regulations concerned shall be published from time
to time in a Handbook for the Conduct of University Ceremonies.
7.2. (1) In the case of a person in any of the categories set out in paragraph (2) below who does not hold, and is not qualified for, any
of the Degrees (other than Honorary Degrees) of Doctor of Divinity,
Doctor of Civil Law, Doctor of Medicine, Master of Arts, Master of
Biochemistry, Master of Chemistry, Master of Earth Sciences, Master of
Engineering, Master of Mathematics, or Master of Physics of the
University, Council shall as soon as possible propose to Congregation
that a Degree of Master of Arts by Resolution be conferred upon that
person without fee, if (and only if) he or she holds both a bachelorâÂÂs
and a doctorâÂÂs degree (other than an honorary degree) of any
university or universities or of any such other institution or
institutions as Council may determine by regulation from time to time,
or that at least twenty terms have lapsed since he or she first became
a member of a university or such other institution, or, in the case of
a person who is not a member of any university, that he or she is at
least 25 years of age.
(2) The categories referred to in paragraph (1) above are:
(a) the Chancellor;
(b) the High Steward;
(c) the Vice-Chancellor;
(d) the Proctors;
(e) the heads of all the colleges, societies, and Permanent Private
Halls included in Statute V;
(f) the members of the governing bodies of all the colleges and
societies included in Statute V (but not of the Permanent Private
Halls);
(g) the principal bursar or treasurer of each of the colleges and
societies included in Statute V (but not of the Permanent Private
Halls), if he or she is not a member of its governing body.
(3) In the case of a person excluded because none of the conditions in
paragraphs (1) and (2) above is met, Council shall proceed as soon as
possible after one of them has been met.
(4) Nothing in this regulation shall restrict the power of Council to
propose to Congregation that a Degree by Resolution be conferred
without fee upon any person it considers appropriate.
7.3. A Degree by Resolution shall be deemed to have been conferred with effect from the approval of the resolution by Congregation.
1
The quoted regulations quite specifically apply to a relatively small number of extremely senior posts, and there's no evidence that the person in question held any of those posts. The relevant regulations would be those for the conferring of the MA on an Oxford PhD holder 21 terms after matriculation.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:18
None of 2(a) to 2(g) mentions "mere" professors. I should perhaps have emphasised extremely in my first comment.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:33
Feel free to expand your answer by explaining which of those categories applies.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:38
3
Clause 2(f) covers almost everyone who holds a potentially permanent faculty post in the University. Been there, done that: "this will involve you in no expense, and you need not attend the ceremony" as the letter said.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:06
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
It's ecactly as described in the wikipedia-article you were linking: He had to spend 6-7 years at Oxford to recieve the title. Since he was faster than this time span with his doctorate, he recieved the Master by Resolution after his Doctor.
The degree "Master of Arts by Resolution" indicates, that no further studies or exams were necessary, but is is given "by resolution".
3
This is just not true. Such a degree can be (and is) given within weeks of taking up a post.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:08
add a comment |Â
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
10
down vote
Basically, it's a "free masters degree" to members who otherwise don't qualify for the masters degree, for various reasons.
Here it is, direct from Oxford:
Conferment of Degrees
7.1. The procedures for the conferment, both at the Encaenia and on other occasions, of Degrees by Diploma, Honorary Degrees, Ordinary
Degrees, and Degrees by Incorporation shall be determined by
regulation, and the regulations concerned shall be published from time
to time in a Handbook for the Conduct of University Ceremonies.
7.2. (1) In the case of a person in any of the categories set out in paragraph (2) below who does not hold, and is not qualified for, any
of the Degrees (other than Honorary Degrees) of Doctor of Divinity,
Doctor of Civil Law, Doctor of Medicine, Master of Arts, Master of
Biochemistry, Master of Chemistry, Master of Earth Sciences, Master of
Engineering, Master of Mathematics, or Master of Physics of the
University, Council shall as soon as possible propose to Congregation
that a Degree of Master of Arts by Resolution be conferred upon that
person without fee, if (and only if) he or she holds both a bachelorâÂÂs
and a doctorâÂÂs degree (other than an honorary degree) of any
university or universities or of any such other institution or
institutions as Council may determine by regulation from time to time,
or that at least twenty terms have lapsed since he or she first became
a member of a university or such other institution, or, in the case of
a person who is not a member of any university, that he or she is at
least 25 years of age.
(2) The categories referred to in paragraph (1) above are:
(a) the Chancellor;
(b) the High Steward;
(c) the Vice-Chancellor;
(d) the Proctors;
(e) the heads of all the colleges, societies, and Permanent Private
Halls included in Statute V;
(f) the members of the governing bodies of all the colleges and
societies included in Statute V (but not of the Permanent Private
Halls);
(g) the principal bursar or treasurer of each of the colleges and
societies included in Statute V (but not of the Permanent Private
Halls), if he or she is not a member of its governing body.
(3) In the case of a person excluded because none of the conditions in
paragraphs (1) and (2) above is met, Council shall proceed as soon as
possible after one of them has been met.
(4) Nothing in this regulation shall restrict the power of Council to
propose to Congregation that a Degree by Resolution be conferred
without fee upon any person it considers appropriate.
7.3. A Degree by Resolution shall be deemed to have been conferred with effect from the approval of the resolution by Congregation.
1
The quoted regulations quite specifically apply to a relatively small number of extremely senior posts, and there's no evidence that the person in question held any of those posts. The relevant regulations would be those for the conferring of the MA on an Oxford PhD holder 21 terms after matriculation.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:18
None of 2(a) to 2(g) mentions "mere" professors. I should perhaps have emphasised extremely in my first comment.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:33
Feel free to expand your answer by explaining which of those categories applies.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:38
3
Clause 2(f) covers almost everyone who holds a potentially permanent faculty post in the University. Been there, done that: "this will involve you in no expense, and you need not attend the ceremony" as the letter said.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:06
add a comment |Â
up vote
10
down vote
Basically, it's a "free masters degree" to members who otherwise don't qualify for the masters degree, for various reasons.
Here it is, direct from Oxford:
Conferment of Degrees
7.1. The procedures for the conferment, both at the Encaenia and on other occasions, of Degrees by Diploma, Honorary Degrees, Ordinary
Degrees, and Degrees by Incorporation shall be determined by
regulation, and the regulations concerned shall be published from time
to time in a Handbook for the Conduct of University Ceremonies.
7.2. (1) In the case of a person in any of the categories set out in paragraph (2) below who does not hold, and is not qualified for, any
of the Degrees (other than Honorary Degrees) of Doctor of Divinity,
Doctor of Civil Law, Doctor of Medicine, Master of Arts, Master of
Biochemistry, Master of Chemistry, Master of Earth Sciences, Master of
Engineering, Master of Mathematics, or Master of Physics of the
University, Council shall as soon as possible propose to Congregation
that a Degree of Master of Arts by Resolution be conferred upon that
person without fee, if (and only if) he or she holds both a bachelorâÂÂs
and a doctorâÂÂs degree (other than an honorary degree) of any
university or universities or of any such other institution or
institutions as Council may determine by regulation from time to time,
or that at least twenty terms have lapsed since he or she first became
a member of a university or such other institution, or, in the case of
a person who is not a member of any university, that he or she is at
least 25 years of age.
(2) The categories referred to in paragraph (1) above are:
(a) the Chancellor;
(b) the High Steward;
(c) the Vice-Chancellor;
(d) the Proctors;
(e) the heads of all the colleges, societies, and Permanent Private
Halls included in Statute V;
(f) the members of the governing bodies of all the colleges and
societies included in Statute V (but not of the Permanent Private
Halls);
(g) the principal bursar or treasurer of each of the colleges and
societies included in Statute V (but not of the Permanent Private
Halls), if he or she is not a member of its governing body.
(3) In the case of a person excluded because none of the conditions in
paragraphs (1) and (2) above is met, Council shall proceed as soon as
possible after one of them has been met.
(4) Nothing in this regulation shall restrict the power of Council to
propose to Congregation that a Degree by Resolution be conferred
without fee upon any person it considers appropriate.
7.3. A Degree by Resolution shall be deemed to have been conferred with effect from the approval of the resolution by Congregation.
1
The quoted regulations quite specifically apply to a relatively small number of extremely senior posts, and there's no evidence that the person in question held any of those posts. The relevant regulations would be those for the conferring of the MA on an Oxford PhD holder 21 terms after matriculation.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:18
None of 2(a) to 2(g) mentions "mere" professors. I should perhaps have emphasised extremely in my first comment.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:33
Feel free to expand your answer by explaining which of those categories applies.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:38
3
Clause 2(f) covers almost everyone who holds a potentially permanent faculty post in the University. Been there, done that: "this will involve you in no expense, and you need not attend the ceremony" as the letter said.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:06
add a comment |Â
up vote
10
down vote
up vote
10
down vote
Basically, it's a "free masters degree" to members who otherwise don't qualify for the masters degree, for various reasons.
Here it is, direct from Oxford:
Conferment of Degrees
7.1. The procedures for the conferment, both at the Encaenia and on other occasions, of Degrees by Diploma, Honorary Degrees, Ordinary
Degrees, and Degrees by Incorporation shall be determined by
regulation, and the regulations concerned shall be published from time
to time in a Handbook for the Conduct of University Ceremonies.
7.2. (1) In the case of a person in any of the categories set out in paragraph (2) below who does not hold, and is not qualified for, any
of the Degrees (other than Honorary Degrees) of Doctor of Divinity,
Doctor of Civil Law, Doctor of Medicine, Master of Arts, Master of
Biochemistry, Master of Chemistry, Master of Earth Sciences, Master of
Engineering, Master of Mathematics, or Master of Physics of the
University, Council shall as soon as possible propose to Congregation
that a Degree of Master of Arts by Resolution be conferred upon that
person without fee, if (and only if) he or she holds both a bachelorâÂÂs
and a doctorâÂÂs degree (other than an honorary degree) of any
university or universities or of any such other institution or
institutions as Council may determine by regulation from time to time,
or that at least twenty terms have lapsed since he or she first became
a member of a university or such other institution, or, in the case of
a person who is not a member of any university, that he or she is at
least 25 years of age.
(2) The categories referred to in paragraph (1) above are:
(a) the Chancellor;
(b) the High Steward;
(c) the Vice-Chancellor;
(d) the Proctors;
(e) the heads of all the colleges, societies, and Permanent Private
Halls included in Statute V;
(f) the members of the governing bodies of all the colleges and
societies included in Statute V (but not of the Permanent Private
Halls);
(g) the principal bursar or treasurer of each of the colleges and
societies included in Statute V (but not of the Permanent Private
Halls), if he or she is not a member of its governing body.
(3) In the case of a person excluded because none of the conditions in
paragraphs (1) and (2) above is met, Council shall proceed as soon as
possible after one of them has been met.
(4) Nothing in this regulation shall restrict the power of Council to
propose to Congregation that a Degree by Resolution be conferred
without fee upon any person it considers appropriate.
7.3. A Degree by Resolution shall be deemed to have been conferred with effect from the approval of the resolution by Congregation.
Basically, it's a "free masters degree" to members who otherwise don't qualify for the masters degree, for various reasons.
Here it is, direct from Oxford:
Conferment of Degrees
7.1. The procedures for the conferment, both at the Encaenia and on other occasions, of Degrees by Diploma, Honorary Degrees, Ordinary
Degrees, and Degrees by Incorporation shall be determined by
regulation, and the regulations concerned shall be published from time
to time in a Handbook for the Conduct of University Ceremonies.
7.2. (1) In the case of a person in any of the categories set out in paragraph (2) below who does not hold, and is not qualified for, any
of the Degrees (other than Honorary Degrees) of Doctor of Divinity,
Doctor of Civil Law, Doctor of Medicine, Master of Arts, Master of
Biochemistry, Master of Chemistry, Master of Earth Sciences, Master of
Engineering, Master of Mathematics, or Master of Physics of the
University, Council shall as soon as possible propose to Congregation
that a Degree of Master of Arts by Resolution be conferred upon that
person without fee, if (and only if) he or she holds both a bachelorâÂÂs
and a doctorâÂÂs degree (other than an honorary degree) of any
university or universities or of any such other institution or
institutions as Council may determine by regulation from time to time,
or that at least twenty terms have lapsed since he or she first became
a member of a university or such other institution, or, in the case of
a person who is not a member of any university, that he or she is at
least 25 years of age.
(2) The categories referred to in paragraph (1) above are:
(a) the Chancellor;
(b) the High Steward;
(c) the Vice-Chancellor;
(d) the Proctors;
(e) the heads of all the colleges, societies, and Permanent Private
Halls included in Statute V;
(f) the members of the governing bodies of all the colleges and
societies included in Statute V (but not of the Permanent Private
Halls);
(g) the principal bursar or treasurer of each of the colleges and
societies included in Statute V (but not of the Permanent Private
Halls), if he or she is not a member of its governing body.
(3) In the case of a person excluded because none of the conditions in
paragraphs (1) and (2) above is met, Council shall proceed as soon as
possible after one of them has been met.
(4) Nothing in this regulation shall restrict the power of Council to
propose to Congregation that a Degree by Resolution be conferred
without fee upon any person it considers appropriate.
7.3. A Degree by Resolution shall be deemed to have been conferred with effect from the approval of the resolution by Congregation.
edited Aug 12 at 9:30
answered Aug 12 at 4:38
Jalapeno Nachos
5951314
5951314
1
The quoted regulations quite specifically apply to a relatively small number of extremely senior posts, and there's no evidence that the person in question held any of those posts. The relevant regulations would be those for the conferring of the MA on an Oxford PhD holder 21 terms after matriculation.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:18
None of 2(a) to 2(g) mentions "mere" professors. I should perhaps have emphasised extremely in my first comment.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:33
Feel free to expand your answer by explaining which of those categories applies.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:38
3
Clause 2(f) covers almost everyone who holds a potentially permanent faculty post in the University. Been there, done that: "this will involve you in no expense, and you need not attend the ceremony" as the letter said.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:06
add a comment |Â
1
The quoted regulations quite specifically apply to a relatively small number of extremely senior posts, and there's no evidence that the person in question held any of those posts. The relevant regulations would be those for the conferring of the MA on an Oxford PhD holder 21 terms after matriculation.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:18
None of 2(a) to 2(g) mentions "mere" professors. I should perhaps have emphasised extremely in my first comment.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:33
Feel free to expand your answer by explaining which of those categories applies.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:38
3
Clause 2(f) covers almost everyone who holds a potentially permanent faculty post in the University. Been there, done that: "this will involve you in no expense, and you need not attend the ceremony" as the letter said.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:06
1
1
The quoted regulations quite specifically apply to a relatively small number of extremely senior posts, and there's no evidence that the person in question held any of those posts. The relevant regulations would be those for the conferring of the MA on an Oxford PhD holder 21 terms after matriculation.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:18
The quoted regulations quite specifically apply to a relatively small number of extremely senior posts, and there's no evidence that the person in question held any of those posts. The relevant regulations would be those for the conferring of the MA on an Oxford PhD holder 21 terms after matriculation.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:18
None of 2(a) to 2(g) mentions "mere" professors. I should perhaps have emphasised extremely in my first comment.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:33
None of 2(a) to 2(g) mentions "mere" professors. I should perhaps have emphasised extremely in my first comment.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:33
Feel free to expand your answer by explaining which of those categories applies.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:38
Feel free to expand your answer by explaining which of those categories applies.
â Peter Taylor
Aug 12 at 7:38
3
3
Clause 2(f) covers almost everyone who holds a potentially permanent faculty post in the University. Been there, done that: "this will involve you in no expense, and you need not attend the ceremony" as the letter said.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:06
Clause 2(f) covers almost everyone who holds a potentially permanent faculty post in the University. Been there, done that: "this will involve you in no expense, and you need not attend the ceremony" as the letter said.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:06
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
It's ecactly as described in the wikipedia-article you were linking: He had to spend 6-7 years at Oxford to recieve the title. Since he was faster than this time span with his doctorate, he recieved the Master by Resolution after his Doctor.
The degree "Master of Arts by Resolution" indicates, that no further studies or exams were necessary, but is is given "by resolution".
3
This is just not true. Such a degree can be (and is) given within weeks of taking up a post.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:08
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
It's ecactly as described in the wikipedia-article you were linking: He had to spend 6-7 years at Oxford to recieve the title. Since he was faster than this time span with his doctorate, he recieved the Master by Resolution after his Doctor.
The degree "Master of Arts by Resolution" indicates, that no further studies or exams were necessary, but is is given "by resolution".
3
This is just not true. Such a degree can be (and is) given within weeks of taking up a post.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:08
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
It's ecactly as described in the wikipedia-article you were linking: He had to spend 6-7 years at Oxford to recieve the title. Since he was faster than this time span with his doctorate, he recieved the Master by Resolution after his Doctor.
The degree "Master of Arts by Resolution" indicates, that no further studies or exams were necessary, but is is given "by resolution".
It's ecactly as described in the wikipedia-article you were linking: He had to spend 6-7 years at Oxford to recieve the title. Since he was faster than this time span with his doctorate, he recieved the Master by Resolution after his Doctor.
The degree "Master of Arts by Resolution" indicates, that no further studies or exams were necessary, but is is given "by resolution".
answered Aug 12 at 4:46
OBu
6,48311638
6,48311638
3
This is just not true. Such a degree can be (and is) given within weeks of taking up a post.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:08
add a comment |Â
3
This is just not true. Such a degree can be (and is) given within weeks of taking up a post.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:08
3
3
This is just not true. Such a degree can be (and is) given within weeks of taking up a post.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:08
This is just not true. Such a degree can be (and is) given within weeks of taking up a post.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:08
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2facademia.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f115186%2fwhats-a-degree-by-resolution%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Not an answer, but in Oxford MAs take academic precedence of Doctors who do not have an MA.
â erstwhile editor
Aug 12 at 8:12