Does a closed form solution to this nonlinear ODE exist?
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
$fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$, where $y=y(x)$
EDIT, Will Jagy: $a,b,c,d,e,f$ are real constants.
I have never solved a nonlinear ODE before, although I'm familiar with many of the techniques applied for solving linear ODEs. There is one special case of the equation above that I managed to solve, but that is the easy case where $f$ is equal to zero. For $f$ not being equal to zero I have the first derivative inside, which then makes it a linear ODE. I read that there does not have to be a closed form solution. Is there any way how I can check whether or not such a solution exists for the equation above?
differential-equations
 |Â
show 2 more comments
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
$fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$, where $y=y(x)$
EDIT, Will Jagy: $a,b,c,d,e,f$ are real constants.
I have never solved a nonlinear ODE before, although I'm familiar with many of the techniques applied for solving linear ODEs. There is one special case of the equation above that I managed to solve, but that is the easy case where $f$ is equal to zero. For $f$ not being equal to zero I have the first derivative inside, which then makes it a linear ODE. I read that there does not have to be a closed form solution. Is there any way how I can check whether or not such a solution exists for the equation above?
differential-equations
2
It's nonlinear because of the square root, it's not even an ODE because of that $y(e+fx)$. I think it's what's called a "differential-delay equation". By the way, I admire what you did on that bus in 1955. Welcome to m.se
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 11:33
@Gerry Merson: why Differential delay equation? I understand $f$ is a constant.
â Riccardo.Alestra
Feb 21 '12 at 12:03
Riccardo Alestra is right, $f$ is not a function, but a constant. I ran out of unbiased letters there. I'm sorry for that! With $f$ being a constant, this is a nonlinear ODE again, isn't it?
â user25425
Feb 21 '12 at 20:00
1
I have edited the equation so as to make it less likely that I will misread it in the future.
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 22:18
2
I appreciate your help and thank you a lot, guys! Figuring out whether there exists a closed form solution at all seemed like an impossible task to me... now I know that a general closed form solution is out of reach. The general form of the nonlinear differential equation above stems from the following special case, where there is more structure imposed on the constants... $$(lambda_1-lambda_0)x(1-x)y'+(lambda_0+ (lambda_1-lambda_0)x)y+sqrt2ay-2b_0 =a^-1(lambda_1b_1-lambda_0b_0)x+a^-1lambda_0b_0$$ Is there a solution to that special case of the differential equation above?
â user25506
Feb 22 '12 at 18:37
 |Â
show 2 more comments
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
$fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$, where $y=y(x)$
EDIT, Will Jagy: $a,b,c,d,e,f$ are real constants.
I have never solved a nonlinear ODE before, although I'm familiar with many of the techniques applied for solving linear ODEs. There is one special case of the equation above that I managed to solve, but that is the easy case where $f$ is equal to zero. For $f$ not being equal to zero I have the first derivative inside, which then makes it a linear ODE. I read that there does not have to be a closed form solution. Is there any way how I can check whether or not such a solution exists for the equation above?
differential-equations
$fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$, where $y=y(x)$
EDIT, Will Jagy: $a,b,c,d,e,f$ are real constants.
I have never solved a nonlinear ODE before, although I'm familiar with many of the techniques applied for solving linear ODEs. There is one special case of the equation above that I managed to solve, but that is the easy case where $f$ is equal to zero. For $f$ not being equal to zero I have the first derivative inside, which then makes it a linear ODE. I read that there does not have to be a closed form solution. Is there any way how I can check whether or not such a solution exists for the equation above?
differential-equations
edited Feb 21 '12 at 23:17
Will Jagy
97.4k595196
97.4k595196
asked Feb 21 '12 at 10:30
Rosa Parks
61
61
2
It's nonlinear because of the square root, it's not even an ODE because of that $y(e+fx)$. I think it's what's called a "differential-delay equation". By the way, I admire what you did on that bus in 1955. Welcome to m.se
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 11:33
@Gerry Merson: why Differential delay equation? I understand $f$ is a constant.
â Riccardo.Alestra
Feb 21 '12 at 12:03
Riccardo Alestra is right, $f$ is not a function, but a constant. I ran out of unbiased letters there. I'm sorry for that! With $f$ being a constant, this is a nonlinear ODE again, isn't it?
â user25425
Feb 21 '12 at 20:00
1
I have edited the equation so as to make it less likely that I will misread it in the future.
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 22:18
2
I appreciate your help and thank you a lot, guys! Figuring out whether there exists a closed form solution at all seemed like an impossible task to me... now I know that a general closed form solution is out of reach. The general form of the nonlinear differential equation above stems from the following special case, where there is more structure imposed on the constants... $$(lambda_1-lambda_0)x(1-x)y'+(lambda_0+ (lambda_1-lambda_0)x)y+sqrt2ay-2b_0 =a^-1(lambda_1b_1-lambda_0b_0)x+a^-1lambda_0b_0$$ Is there a solution to that special case of the differential equation above?
â user25506
Feb 22 '12 at 18:37
 |Â
show 2 more comments
2
It's nonlinear because of the square root, it's not even an ODE because of that $y(e+fx)$. I think it's what's called a "differential-delay equation". By the way, I admire what you did on that bus in 1955. Welcome to m.se
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 11:33
@Gerry Merson: why Differential delay equation? I understand $f$ is a constant.
â Riccardo.Alestra
Feb 21 '12 at 12:03
Riccardo Alestra is right, $f$ is not a function, but a constant. I ran out of unbiased letters there. I'm sorry for that! With $f$ being a constant, this is a nonlinear ODE again, isn't it?
â user25425
Feb 21 '12 at 20:00
1
I have edited the equation so as to make it less likely that I will misread it in the future.
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 22:18
2
I appreciate your help and thank you a lot, guys! Figuring out whether there exists a closed form solution at all seemed like an impossible task to me... now I know that a general closed form solution is out of reach. The general form of the nonlinear differential equation above stems from the following special case, where there is more structure imposed on the constants... $$(lambda_1-lambda_0)x(1-x)y'+(lambda_0+ (lambda_1-lambda_0)x)y+sqrt2ay-2b_0 =a^-1(lambda_1b_1-lambda_0b_0)x+a^-1lambda_0b_0$$ Is there a solution to that special case of the differential equation above?
â user25506
Feb 22 '12 at 18:37
2
2
It's nonlinear because of the square root, it's not even an ODE because of that $y(e+fx)$. I think it's what's called a "differential-delay equation". By the way, I admire what you did on that bus in 1955. Welcome to m.se
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 11:33
It's nonlinear because of the square root, it's not even an ODE because of that $y(e+fx)$. I think it's what's called a "differential-delay equation". By the way, I admire what you did on that bus in 1955. Welcome to m.se
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 11:33
@Gerry Merson: why Differential delay equation? I understand $f$ is a constant.
â Riccardo.Alestra
Feb 21 '12 at 12:03
@Gerry Merson: why Differential delay equation? I understand $f$ is a constant.
â Riccardo.Alestra
Feb 21 '12 at 12:03
Riccardo Alestra is right, $f$ is not a function, but a constant. I ran out of unbiased letters there. I'm sorry for that! With $f$ being a constant, this is a nonlinear ODE again, isn't it?
â user25425
Feb 21 '12 at 20:00
Riccardo Alestra is right, $f$ is not a function, but a constant. I ran out of unbiased letters there. I'm sorry for that! With $f$ being a constant, this is a nonlinear ODE again, isn't it?
â user25425
Feb 21 '12 at 20:00
1
1
I have edited the equation so as to make it less likely that I will misread it in the future.
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 22:18
I have edited the equation so as to make it less likely that I will misread it in the future.
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 22:18
2
2
I appreciate your help and thank you a lot, guys! Figuring out whether there exists a closed form solution at all seemed like an impossible task to me... now I know that a general closed form solution is out of reach. The general form of the nonlinear differential equation above stems from the following special case, where there is more structure imposed on the constants... $$(lambda_1-lambda_0)x(1-x)y'+(lambda_0+ (lambda_1-lambda_0)x)y+sqrt2ay-2b_0 =a^-1(lambda_1b_1-lambda_0b_0)x+a^-1lambda_0b_0$$ Is there a solution to that special case of the differential equation above?
â user25506
Feb 22 '12 at 18:37
I appreciate your help and thank you a lot, guys! Figuring out whether there exists a closed form solution at all seemed like an impossible task to me... now I know that a general closed form solution is out of reach. The general form of the nonlinear differential equation above stems from the following special case, where there is more structure imposed on the constants... $$(lambda_1-lambda_0)x(1-x)y'+(lambda_0+ (lambda_1-lambda_0)x)y+sqrt2ay-2b_0 =a^-1(lambda_1b_1-lambda_0b_0)x+a^-1lambda_0b_0$$ Is there a solution to that special case of the differential equation above?
â user25506
Feb 22 '12 at 18:37
 |Â
show 2 more comments
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
For $fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$ , where $a,fneq0$ :
Approach $1$:
Let $u=sqrtay-b$ ,
Then $y=dfracu^2+ba$
$dfracdydx=dfrac2uadfracdudx$
$therefore fx(1-x)dfrac2uadfracdudx+(e+fx)dfracu^2+ba+u=dx+c$
$dfrac2fx(1-x)uadfracdudx+dfrac(e+fx)u^2a+dfracbe+bfxa+u=dx+c$
$dfrac2fx(x-1)uadfracdudx=dfrac(e+fx)u^2a+u+dfrac(bf-ad)x+be-aca$
$udfracdudx=dfrac(e+fx)u^22fx(x-1)+dfracau2fx(x-1)+dfrac(bf-ad)x+be-ac2fx(x-1)$
This mostly belongs to an Abel equation of the second kind, unless when $bf=ad$ and $be=ac$ this ODE can reduce to a bernoulli equation.
Approach $2$:
$fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$
$(fy-d)x+ey-c+sqrtay-b=fx(x-1)dfracdydx$
$((fy-d)x+ey-c+sqrtay-b)dfracdxdy=fx^2-fx$
This also belongs to an Abel equation of the second kind.
Let $u=x+dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-d$ ,
Then $x=u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$dfracdxdy=dfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-b$
$therefore(fy-d)ubiggl(dfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-bbiggr)=fbiggl(u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-dbiggr)^2-fbiggl(u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-dbiggr)$
$(fy-d)udfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bu=fu^2-dfracf(f+2e)y-(2c+d)f+2fsqrtay-bfy-du+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^2+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$(fy-d)udfracdudy=fu^2-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bu+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^2+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$udfracdudy=dfracfu^2fy-d-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-bu+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
Let $u=(fy-d)v$ ,
Then $dfracdudy=(fy-d)dfracdvdy+fv$
$therefore(fy-d)vleft((fy-d)dfracdvdy+fvright)=dfracf(fy-d)^2v^2fy-d-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-b(fy-d)v+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$(fy-d)^2vdfracdvdy+f(fy-d)v^2=f(fy-d)v^2-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$(fy-d)^2vdfracdvdy=-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$vdfracdvdy=-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^3sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^5+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^4$
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
I doubt that there are closed-form solutions in general. Maple doesn't come up with one. Of course if $a=0$ you have a linear equation, and that one does have a (rather complicated) closed-form solution. If $b=c=d=e=0$ there is a closed-form solution
$arctan left( sqrt -1+x right) +frac 1sqrt -1+x+frac
y left( x right) fsqrt -1+xsqrt ay left( x right) +C=0
$
for arbitrary constant $C$.
add a comment |Â
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
For $fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$ , where $a,fneq0$ :
Approach $1$:
Let $u=sqrtay-b$ ,
Then $y=dfracu^2+ba$
$dfracdydx=dfrac2uadfracdudx$
$therefore fx(1-x)dfrac2uadfracdudx+(e+fx)dfracu^2+ba+u=dx+c$
$dfrac2fx(1-x)uadfracdudx+dfrac(e+fx)u^2a+dfracbe+bfxa+u=dx+c$
$dfrac2fx(x-1)uadfracdudx=dfrac(e+fx)u^2a+u+dfrac(bf-ad)x+be-aca$
$udfracdudx=dfrac(e+fx)u^22fx(x-1)+dfracau2fx(x-1)+dfrac(bf-ad)x+be-ac2fx(x-1)$
This mostly belongs to an Abel equation of the second kind, unless when $bf=ad$ and $be=ac$ this ODE can reduce to a bernoulli equation.
Approach $2$:
$fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$
$(fy-d)x+ey-c+sqrtay-b=fx(x-1)dfracdydx$
$((fy-d)x+ey-c+sqrtay-b)dfracdxdy=fx^2-fx$
This also belongs to an Abel equation of the second kind.
Let $u=x+dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-d$ ,
Then $x=u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$dfracdxdy=dfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-b$
$therefore(fy-d)ubiggl(dfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-bbiggr)=fbiggl(u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-dbiggr)^2-fbiggl(u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-dbiggr)$
$(fy-d)udfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bu=fu^2-dfracf(f+2e)y-(2c+d)f+2fsqrtay-bfy-du+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^2+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$(fy-d)udfracdudy=fu^2-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bu+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^2+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$udfracdudy=dfracfu^2fy-d-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-bu+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
Let $u=(fy-d)v$ ,
Then $dfracdudy=(fy-d)dfracdvdy+fv$
$therefore(fy-d)vleft((fy-d)dfracdvdy+fvright)=dfracf(fy-d)^2v^2fy-d-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-b(fy-d)v+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$(fy-d)^2vdfracdvdy+f(fy-d)v^2=f(fy-d)v^2-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$(fy-d)^2vdfracdvdy=-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$vdfracdvdy=-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^3sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^5+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^4$
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
For $fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$ , where $a,fneq0$ :
Approach $1$:
Let $u=sqrtay-b$ ,
Then $y=dfracu^2+ba$
$dfracdydx=dfrac2uadfracdudx$
$therefore fx(1-x)dfrac2uadfracdudx+(e+fx)dfracu^2+ba+u=dx+c$
$dfrac2fx(1-x)uadfracdudx+dfrac(e+fx)u^2a+dfracbe+bfxa+u=dx+c$
$dfrac2fx(x-1)uadfracdudx=dfrac(e+fx)u^2a+u+dfrac(bf-ad)x+be-aca$
$udfracdudx=dfrac(e+fx)u^22fx(x-1)+dfracau2fx(x-1)+dfrac(bf-ad)x+be-ac2fx(x-1)$
This mostly belongs to an Abel equation of the second kind, unless when $bf=ad$ and $be=ac$ this ODE can reduce to a bernoulli equation.
Approach $2$:
$fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$
$(fy-d)x+ey-c+sqrtay-b=fx(x-1)dfracdydx$
$((fy-d)x+ey-c+sqrtay-b)dfracdxdy=fx^2-fx$
This also belongs to an Abel equation of the second kind.
Let $u=x+dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-d$ ,
Then $x=u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$dfracdxdy=dfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-b$
$therefore(fy-d)ubiggl(dfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-bbiggr)=fbiggl(u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-dbiggr)^2-fbiggl(u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-dbiggr)$
$(fy-d)udfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bu=fu^2-dfracf(f+2e)y-(2c+d)f+2fsqrtay-bfy-du+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^2+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$(fy-d)udfracdudy=fu^2-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bu+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^2+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$udfracdudy=dfracfu^2fy-d-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-bu+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
Let $u=(fy-d)v$ ,
Then $dfracdudy=(fy-d)dfracdvdy+fv$
$therefore(fy-d)vleft((fy-d)dfracdvdy+fvright)=dfracf(fy-d)^2v^2fy-d-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-b(fy-d)v+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$(fy-d)^2vdfracdvdy+f(fy-d)v^2=f(fy-d)v^2-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$(fy-d)^2vdfracdvdy=-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$vdfracdvdy=-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^3sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^5+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^4$
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
up vote
3
down vote
For $fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$ , where $a,fneq0$ :
Approach $1$:
Let $u=sqrtay-b$ ,
Then $y=dfracu^2+ba$
$dfracdydx=dfrac2uadfracdudx$
$therefore fx(1-x)dfrac2uadfracdudx+(e+fx)dfracu^2+ba+u=dx+c$
$dfrac2fx(1-x)uadfracdudx+dfrac(e+fx)u^2a+dfracbe+bfxa+u=dx+c$
$dfrac2fx(x-1)uadfracdudx=dfrac(e+fx)u^2a+u+dfrac(bf-ad)x+be-aca$
$udfracdudx=dfrac(e+fx)u^22fx(x-1)+dfracau2fx(x-1)+dfrac(bf-ad)x+be-ac2fx(x-1)$
This mostly belongs to an Abel equation of the second kind, unless when $bf=ad$ and $be=ac$ this ODE can reduce to a bernoulli equation.
Approach $2$:
$fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$
$(fy-d)x+ey-c+sqrtay-b=fx(x-1)dfracdydx$
$((fy-d)x+ey-c+sqrtay-b)dfracdxdy=fx^2-fx$
This also belongs to an Abel equation of the second kind.
Let $u=x+dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-d$ ,
Then $x=u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$dfracdxdy=dfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-b$
$therefore(fy-d)ubiggl(dfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-bbiggr)=fbiggl(u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-dbiggr)^2-fbiggl(u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-dbiggr)$
$(fy-d)udfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bu=fu^2-dfracf(f+2e)y-(2c+d)f+2fsqrtay-bfy-du+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^2+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$(fy-d)udfracdudy=fu^2-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bu+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^2+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$udfracdudy=dfracfu^2fy-d-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-bu+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
Let $u=(fy-d)v$ ,
Then $dfracdudy=(fy-d)dfracdvdy+fv$
$therefore(fy-d)vleft((fy-d)dfracdvdy+fvright)=dfracf(fy-d)^2v^2fy-d-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-b(fy-d)v+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$(fy-d)^2vdfracdvdy+f(fy-d)v^2=f(fy-d)v^2-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$(fy-d)^2vdfracdvdy=-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$vdfracdvdy=-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^3sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^5+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^4$
For $fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$ , where $a,fneq0$ :
Approach $1$:
Let $u=sqrtay-b$ ,
Then $y=dfracu^2+ba$
$dfracdydx=dfrac2uadfracdudx$
$therefore fx(1-x)dfrac2uadfracdudx+(e+fx)dfracu^2+ba+u=dx+c$
$dfrac2fx(1-x)uadfracdudx+dfrac(e+fx)u^2a+dfracbe+bfxa+u=dx+c$
$dfrac2fx(x-1)uadfracdudx=dfrac(e+fx)u^2a+u+dfrac(bf-ad)x+be-aca$
$udfracdudx=dfrac(e+fx)u^22fx(x-1)+dfracau2fx(x-1)+dfrac(bf-ad)x+be-ac2fx(x-1)$
This mostly belongs to an Abel equation of the second kind, unless when $bf=ad$ and $be=ac$ this ODE can reduce to a bernoulli equation.
Approach $2$:
$fx(1-x)y'+(e+fx)y+sqrtay-b=dx+c$
$(fy-d)x+ey-c+sqrtay-b=fx(x-1)dfracdydx$
$((fy-d)x+ey-c+sqrtay-b)dfracdxdy=fx^2-fx$
This also belongs to an Abel equation of the second kind.
Let $u=x+dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-d$ ,
Then $x=u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$dfracdxdy=dfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-b$
$therefore(fy-d)ubiggl(dfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-bbiggr)=fbiggl(u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-dbiggr)^2-fbiggl(u-dfracey-c+sqrtay-bfy-dbiggr)$
$(fy-d)udfracdudy+dfraca(fy+d)-2bf-2(cf-de)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bu=fu^2-dfracf(f+2e)y-(2c+d)f+2fsqrtay-bfy-du+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^2+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$(fy-d)udfracdudy=fu^2-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bu+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^2+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-bfy-d$
$udfracdudy=dfracfu^2fy-d-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-bu+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
Let $u=(fy-d)v$ ,
Then $dfracdudy=(fy-d)dfracdvdy+fv$
$therefore(fy-d)vleft((fy-d)dfracdvdy+fvright)=dfracf(fy-d)^2v^2fy-d-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^2sqrtay-b(fy-d)v+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$(fy-d)^2vdfracdvdy+f(fy-d)v^2=f(fy-d)v^2-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$(fy-d)^2vdfracdvdy=-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^3+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^2$
$vdfracdvdy=-dfrac5afy+ad-6bf+2(f(f+2e)y+de-(3c+d)f)sqrtay-b2(fy-d)^3sqrtay-bv+dfracf(ey-c+sqrtay-b)^2(fy-d)^5+dfracefy-cf+sqrtay-b(fy-d)^4$
edited Aug 12 at 8:01
answered Mar 9 '13 at 19:09
doraemonpaul
12.1k31660
12.1k31660
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
I doubt that there are closed-form solutions in general. Maple doesn't come up with one. Of course if $a=0$ you have a linear equation, and that one does have a (rather complicated) closed-form solution. If $b=c=d=e=0$ there is a closed-form solution
$arctan left( sqrt -1+x right) +frac 1sqrt -1+x+frac
y left( x right) fsqrt -1+xsqrt ay left( x right) +C=0
$
for arbitrary constant $C$.
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
I doubt that there are closed-form solutions in general. Maple doesn't come up with one. Of course if $a=0$ you have a linear equation, and that one does have a (rather complicated) closed-form solution. If $b=c=d=e=0$ there is a closed-form solution
$arctan left( sqrt -1+x right) +frac 1sqrt -1+x+frac
y left( x right) fsqrt -1+xsqrt ay left( x right) +C=0
$
for arbitrary constant $C$.
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
I doubt that there are closed-form solutions in general. Maple doesn't come up with one. Of course if $a=0$ you have a linear equation, and that one does have a (rather complicated) closed-form solution. If $b=c=d=e=0$ there is a closed-form solution
$arctan left( sqrt -1+x right) +frac 1sqrt -1+x+frac
y left( x right) fsqrt -1+xsqrt ay left( x right) +C=0
$
for arbitrary constant $C$.
I doubt that there are closed-form solutions in general. Maple doesn't come up with one. Of course if $a=0$ you have a linear equation, and that one does have a (rather complicated) closed-form solution. If $b=c=d=e=0$ there is a closed-form solution
$arctan left( sqrt -1+x right) +frac 1sqrt -1+x+frac
y left( x right) fsqrt -1+xsqrt ay left( x right) +C=0
$
for arbitrary constant $C$.
answered Feb 21 '12 at 20:46
Robert Israel
305k22201443
305k22201443
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f111627%2fdoes-a-closed-form-solution-to-this-nonlinear-ode-exist%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
2
It's nonlinear because of the square root, it's not even an ODE because of that $y(e+fx)$. I think it's what's called a "differential-delay equation". By the way, I admire what you did on that bus in 1955. Welcome to m.se
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 11:33
@Gerry Merson: why Differential delay equation? I understand $f$ is a constant.
â Riccardo.Alestra
Feb 21 '12 at 12:03
Riccardo Alestra is right, $f$ is not a function, but a constant. I ran out of unbiased letters there. I'm sorry for that! With $f$ being a constant, this is a nonlinear ODE again, isn't it?
â user25425
Feb 21 '12 at 20:00
1
I have edited the equation so as to make it less likely that I will misread it in the future.
â Gerry Myerson
Feb 21 '12 at 22:18
2
I appreciate your help and thank you a lot, guys! Figuring out whether there exists a closed form solution at all seemed like an impossible task to me... now I know that a general closed form solution is out of reach. The general form of the nonlinear differential equation above stems from the following special case, where there is more structure imposed on the constants... $$(lambda_1-lambda_0)x(1-x)y'+(lambda_0+ (lambda_1-lambda_0)x)y+sqrt2ay-2b_0 =a^-1(lambda_1b_1-lambda_0b_0)x+a^-1lambda_0b_0$$ Is there a solution to that special case of the differential equation above?
â user25506
Feb 22 '12 at 18:37