Show that $mathrmGal(E/F)$ is cyclic
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
For $E=mathbbQ(i,2^1/8)$ and $F=mathbbQ(i)$, show that $mathrmGal(E/F)$ is cyclic.
I know is that $mathrmGal(E/F)$ is of order 8, since $x^8-2$ is the minimal polynomial of $2^1/8$. I can see that the roots of the minimal polynomial are $2^1/8$,$2^1/8xi$, $2^1/8xi^2$, $2^1/8xi^3$, $2^1/8xi^4...$ where $xi$ is the 8th root of unity. From there, how can I proceed?
Thanks
abstract-algebra field-theory galois-theory
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
For $E=mathbbQ(i,2^1/8)$ and $F=mathbbQ(i)$, show that $mathrmGal(E/F)$ is cyclic.
I know is that $mathrmGal(E/F)$ is of order 8, since $x^8-2$ is the minimal polynomial of $2^1/8$. I can see that the roots of the minimal polynomial are $2^1/8$,$2^1/8xi$, $2^1/8xi^2$, $2^1/8xi^3$, $2^1/8xi^4...$ where $xi$ is the 8th root of unity. From there, how can I proceed?
Thanks
abstract-algebra field-theory galois-theory
So you have a vector space basis of $E/F$, which you get from the roots. Try multiplying this basis by $zeta$.
â Sheel Stueber
Aug 12 at 1:49
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
For $E=mathbbQ(i,2^1/8)$ and $F=mathbbQ(i)$, show that $mathrmGal(E/F)$ is cyclic.
I know is that $mathrmGal(E/F)$ is of order 8, since $x^8-2$ is the minimal polynomial of $2^1/8$. I can see that the roots of the minimal polynomial are $2^1/8$,$2^1/8xi$, $2^1/8xi^2$, $2^1/8xi^3$, $2^1/8xi^4...$ where $xi$ is the 8th root of unity. From there, how can I proceed?
Thanks
abstract-algebra field-theory galois-theory
For $E=mathbbQ(i,2^1/8)$ and $F=mathbbQ(i)$, show that $mathrmGal(E/F)$ is cyclic.
I know is that $mathrmGal(E/F)$ is of order 8, since $x^8-2$ is the minimal polynomial of $2^1/8$. I can see that the roots of the minimal polynomial are $2^1/8$,$2^1/8xi$, $2^1/8xi^2$, $2^1/8xi^3$, $2^1/8xi^4...$ where $xi$ is the 8th root of unity. From there, how can I proceed?
Thanks
abstract-algebra field-theory galois-theory
edited Aug 12 at 5:55
Alex Wertheim
15.7k22748
15.7k22748
asked Aug 12 at 1:25
TheGeometer
889517
889517
So you have a vector space basis of $E/F$, which you get from the roots. Try multiplying this basis by $zeta$.
â Sheel Stueber
Aug 12 at 1:49
add a comment |Â
So you have a vector space basis of $E/F$, which you get from the roots. Try multiplying this basis by $zeta$.
â Sheel Stueber
Aug 12 at 1:49
So you have a vector space basis of $E/F$, which you get from the roots. Try multiplying this basis by $zeta$.
â Sheel Stueber
Aug 12 at 1:49
So you have a vector space basis of $E/F$, which you get from the roots. Try multiplying this basis by $zeta$.
â Sheel Stueber
Aug 12 at 1:49
add a comment |Â
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
First, choose a distinguished primitive $8$th root of unity by setting $xi = fracsqrt22(1+i)$. (This choice won't affect our computation of $G := mathrmGal(E/F)$, but rather how we label the roots of $X^8-2$.)
We can be very explicit in computing the $G$ by using the following facts/observations:
(1) $E = F(sqrt[8]2)$; hence, any field automorphism of $E$ which fixes $F$ is determined by where it sends $sqrt[8]2$.
(2) $G$ acts transitively on the roots of $X^8-2$; hence, for each $i = 0, 1, ldots, 7$, there is an element $sigma_i in G$ which sends $sqrt[8]2$ to $xi^isqrt[8]2$. Moreover, each $sigma_i$ is a distinct element of $G$, since $sigma_i(sqrt[8]2) neq sigma_j(sqrt[8]2)$ for distinct $i, j in 0, 1, ldots, 7$.
(3) $|G| = [E:F] = 8$, so in fact, $G = sigma_0, sigma_1, ldots, sigma_7$ by observation (2).
Hence, we have computed the elements of $G$. Now we need to show that $G$ is cyclic. Indeed, it suffices to show that $G$ contains an element of order $8$. I claim that $sigma_1$ has order $8$. The key thing to do is to determine what $sigma_1$ does to $xi$, so let's do that and see how it helps.
Since $sigma_1$ fixes $F$, all we need to do is check what $sigma_1(sqrt2)$ is. This is easy enough: we have
$$sigma_1(sqrt2) = sigma_1((sqrt[8]2)^4) = sigma_1(sqrt[8]2)^4 = (xi sqrt[8]2)^4 = xi^4sqrt2 = -sqrt2.$$
Hence, $sigma_1(xi) = -xi$. You can then check that
$$sigma_1^2(sqrt[8]2) = sigma_1(xisqrt[8]2) = sigma_1(xi)sigma_1(sqrt[8]2) = -xi^2sqrt[8]2$$
I leave the computation that $sigma_1^4(sqrt[8]2) = -sqrt[8]2$ to you; it is similar.
By Lagrange, $sigma_1$ has order $1, 2, 4$ or $8$. Since we see that $sigma_1$ cannot have order $1, 2, $ or $4$, it must have order $8$ as desired. (You can explicitly compute the powers of $sigma_1$ if you like, too.)
add a comment |Â
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
First, choose a distinguished primitive $8$th root of unity by setting $xi = fracsqrt22(1+i)$. (This choice won't affect our computation of $G := mathrmGal(E/F)$, but rather how we label the roots of $X^8-2$.)
We can be very explicit in computing the $G$ by using the following facts/observations:
(1) $E = F(sqrt[8]2)$; hence, any field automorphism of $E$ which fixes $F$ is determined by where it sends $sqrt[8]2$.
(2) $G$ acts transitively on the roots of $X^8-2$; hence, for each $i = 0, 1, ldots, 7$, there is an element $sigma_i in G$ which sends $sqrt[8]2$ to $xi^isqrt[8]2$. Moreover, each $sigma_i$ is a distinct element of $G$, since $sigma_i(sqrt[8]2) neq sigma_j(sqrt[8]2)$ for distinct $i, j in 0, 1, ldots, 7$.
(3) $|G| = [E:F] = 8$, so in fact, $G = sigma_0, sigma_1, ldots, sigma_7$ by observation (2).
Hence, we have computed the elements of $G$. Now we need to show that $G$ is cyclic. Indeed, it suffices to show that $G$ contains an element of order $8$. I claim that $sigma_1$ has order $8$. The key thing to do is to determine what $sigma_1$ does to $xi$, so let's do that and see how it helps.
Since $sigma_1$ fixes $F$, all we need to do is check what $sigma_1(sqrt2)$ is. This is easy enough: we have
$$sigma_1(sqrt2) = sigma_1((sqrt[8]2)^4) = sigma_1(sqrt[8]2)^4 = (xi sqrt[8]2)^4 = xi^4sqrt2 = -sqrt2.$$
Hence, $sigma_1(xi) = -xi$. You can then check that
$$sigma_1^2(sqrt[8]2) = sigma_1(xisqrt[8]2) = sigma_1(xi)sigma_1(sqrt[8]2) = -xi^2sqrt[8]2$$
I leave the computation that $sigma_1^4(sqrt[8]2) = -sqrt[8]2$ to you; it is similar.
By Lagrange, $sigma_1$ has order $1, 2, 4$ or $8$. Since we see that $sigma_1$ cannot have order $1, 2, $ or $4$, it must have order $8$ as desired. (You can explicitly compute the powers of $sigma_1$ if you like, too.)
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
First, choose a distinguished primitive $8$th root of unity by setting $xi = fracsqrt22(1+i)$. (This choice won't affect our computation of $G := mathrmGal(E/F)$, but rather how we label the roots of $X^8-2$.)
We can be very explicit in computing the $G$ by using the following facts/observations:
(1) $E = F(sqrt[8]2)$; hence, any field automorphism of $E$ which fixes $F$ is determined by where it sends $sqrt[8]2$.
(2) $G$ acts transitively on the roots of $X^8-2$; hence, for each $i = 0, 1, ldots, 7$, there is an element $sigma_i in G$ which sends $sqrt[8]2$ to $xi^isqrt[8]2$. Moreover, each $sigma_i$ is a distinct element of $G$, since $sigma_i(sqrt[8]2) neq sigma_j(sqrt[8]2)$ for distinct $i, j in 0, 1, ldots, 7$.
(3) $|G| = [E:F] = 8$, so in fact, $G = sigma_0, sigma_1, ldots, sigma_7$ by observation (2).
Hence, we have computed the elements of $G$. Now we need to show that $G$ is cyclic. Indeed, it suffices to show that $G$ contains an element of order $8$. I claim that $sigma_1$ has order $8$. The key thing to do is to determine what $sigma_1$ does to $xi$, so let's do that and see how it helps.
Since $sigma_1$ fixes $F$, all we need to do is check what $sigma_1(sqrt2)$ is. This is easy enough: we have
$$sigma_1(sqrt2) = sigma_1((sqrt[8]2)^4) = sigma_1(sqrt[8]2)^4 = (xi sqrt[8]2)^4 = xi^4sqrt2 = -sqrt2.$$
Hence, $sigma_1(xi) = -xi$. You can then check that
$$sigma_1^2(sqrt[8]2) = sigma_1(xisqrt[8]2) = sigma_1(xi)sigma_1(sqrt[8]2) = -xi^2sqrt[8]2$$
I leave the computation that $sigma_1^4(sqrt[8]2) = -sqrt[8]2$ to you; it is similar.
By Lagrange, $sigma_1$ has order $1, 2, 4$ or $8$. Since we see that $sigma_1$ cannot have order $1, 2, $ or $4$, it must have order $8$ as desired. (You can explicitly compute the powers of $sigma_1$ if you like, too.)
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
First, choose a distinguished primitive $8$th root of unity by setting $xi = fracsqrt22(1+i)$. (This choice won't affect our computation of $G := mathrmGal(E/F)$, but rather how we label the roots of $X^8-2$.)
We can be very explicit in computing the $G$ by using the following facts/observations:
(1) $E = F(sqrt[8]2)$; hence, any field automorphism of $E$ which fixes $F$ is determined by where it sends $sqrt[8]2$.
(2) $G$ acts transitively on the roots of $X^8-2$; hence, for each $i = 0, 1, ldots, 7$, there is an element $sigma_i in G$ which sends $sqrt[8]2$ to $xi^isqrt[8]2$. Moreover, each $sigma_i$ is a distinct element of $G$, since $sigma_i(sqrt[8]2) neq sigma_j(sqrt[8]2)$ for distinct $i, j in 0, 1, ldots, 7$.
(3) $|G| = [E:F] = 8$, so in fact, $G = sigma_0, sigma_1, ldots, sigma_7$ by observation (2).
Hence, we have computed the elements of $G$. Now we need to show that $G$ is cyclic. Indeed, it suffices to show that $G$ contains an element of order $8$. I claim that $sigma_1$ has order $8$. The key thing to do is to determine what $sigma_1$ does to $xi$, so let's do that and see how it helps.
Since $sigma_1$ fixes $F$, all we need to do is check what $sigma_1(sqrt2)$ is. This is easy enough: we have
$$sigma_1(sqrt2) = sigma_1((sqrt[8]2)^4) = sigma_1(sqrt[8]2)^4 = (xi sqrt[8]2)^4 = xi^4sqrt2 = -sqrt2.$$
Hence, $sigma_1(xi) = -xi$. You can then check that
$$sigma_1^2(sqrt[8]2) = sigma_1(xisqrt[8]2) = sigma_1(xi)sigma_1(sqrt[8]2) = -xi^2sqrt[8]2$$
I leave the computation that $sigma_1^4(sqrt[8]2) = -sqrt[8]2$ to you; it is similar.
By Lagrange, $sigma_1$ has order $1, 2, 4$ or $8$. Since we see that $sigma_1$ cannot have order $1, 2, $ or $4$, it must have order $8$ as desired. (You can explicitly compute the powers of $sigma_1$ if you like, too.)
First, choose a distinguished primitive $8$th root of unity by setting $xi = fracsqrt22(1+i)$. (This choice won't affect our computation of $G := mathrmGal(E/F)$, but rather how we label the roots of $X^8-2$.)
We can be very explicit in computing the $G$ by using the following facts/observations:
(1) $E = F(sqrt[8]2)$; hence, any field automorphism of $E$ which fixes $F$ is determined by where it sends $sqrt[8]2$.
(2) $G$ acts transitively on the roots of $X^8-2$; hence, for each $i = 0, 1, ldots, 7$, there is an element $sigma_i in G$ which sends $sqrt[8]2$ to $xi^isqrt[8]2$. Moreover, each $sigma_i$ is a distinct element of $G$, since $sigma_i(sqrt[8]2) neq sigma_j(sqrt[8]2)$ for distinct $i, j in 0, 1, ldots, 7$.
(3) $|G| = [E:F] = 8$, so in fact, $G = sigma_0, sigma_1, ldots, sigma_7$ by observation (2).
Hence, we have computed the elements of $G$. Now we need to show that $G$ is cyclic. Indeed, it suffices to show that $G$ contains an element of order $8$. I claim that $sigma_1$ has order $8$. The key thing to do is to determine what $sigma_1$ does to $xi$, so let's do that and see how it helps.
Since $sigma_1$ fixes $F$, all we need to do is check what $sigma_1(sqrt2)$ is. This is easy enough: we have
$$sigma_1(sqrt2) = sigma_1((sqrt[8]2)^4) = sigma_1(sqrt[8]2)^4 = (xi sqrt[8]2)^4 = xi^4sqrt2 = -sqrt2.$$
Hence, $sigma_1(xi) = -xi$. You can then check that
$$sigma_1^2(sqrt[8]2) = sigma_1(xisqrt[8]2) = sigma_1(xi)sigma_1(sqrt[8]2) = -xi^2sqrt[8]2$$
I leave the computation that $sigma_1^4(sqrt[8]2) = -sqrt[8]2$ to you; it is similar.
By Lagrange, $sigma_1$ has order $1, 2, 4$ or $8$. Since we see that $sigma_1$ cannot have order $1, 2, $ or $4$, it must have order $8$ as desired. (You can explicitly compute the powers of $sigma_1$ if you like, too.)
edited Aug 12 at 4:07
answered Aug 12 at 1:58
Alex Wertheim
15.7k22748
15.7k22748
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2879896%2fshow-that-mathrmgale-f-is-cyclic%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
So you have a vector space basis of $E/F$, which you get from the roots. Try multiplying this basis by $zeta$.
â Sheel Stueber
Aug 12 at 1:49