Multidimensional level sets

Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
Consider a function $mathbf f : mathbb R^n to mathbb R$ as an element of $mathcal C^k(mathbb R^n)$ and a fixed real number $C in mathbb R$. Now define the multidimensional level set $mathcal A_C = displaystylemathbf x in mathbb R^n : mathbf f(mathbf x) = C .$
Does the constrains on $mathbf f$ imply anything for the set $mathcal A_C$?
As an example, consider the simple case of $begincases k=0 \ n=2 endcases$ and the question about the nature of the multidimensional level set $mathcal A_C$ as defined above.
This means that $mathbb f$ maps the plane continuously to the real line. Also assume that there's no ball $B(varepsilon, mathbf x_0) = displaystyle mathbf x - mathbf x_0$ such that $mathbf f$ is constant on $B(varepsilon, mathbf x_0)$. It seems likely that $mathcal A_C$ consists of a countable union â which I stress could be empty â of continuous curves $gamma in mathcal C(mathbb R)$, although a such conjecture obviously have to be proven.
In the more general form, where $k, n in mathbb N$ is chosen arbitrary, can we say something about the nature/topology of the set $mathcal A_C$? Does less restrictive requirements on the function $mathbf f$ enable us to say more, for example if we only required $mathbf f$ to be locally Lipschitz?
(In the more general form, where $mathbf f in mathcal C^k(mathbb R^n)$, it seems like a probable guess that $mathcal A_C$ has to consist of an countable union of sets which are path-connected by $C^k$-curves. Also note that points are, in this sense, curves.)
real-analysis multivariable-calculus
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
Consider a function $mathbf f : mathbb R^n to mathbb R$ as an element of $mathcal C^k(mathbb R^n)$ and a fixed real number $C in mathbb R$. Now define the multidimensional level set $mathcal A_C = displaystylemathbf x in mathbb R^n : mathbf f(mathbf x) = C .$
Does the constrains on $mathbf f$ imply anything for the set $mathcal A_C$?
As an example, consider the simple case of $begincases k=0 \ n=2 endcases$ and the question about the nature of the multidimensional level set $mathcal A_C$ as defined above.
This means that $mathbb f$ maps the plane continuously to the real line. Also assume that there's no ball $B(varepsilon, mathbf x_0) = displaystyle mathbf x - mathbf x_0$ such that $mathbf f$ is constant on $B(varepsilon, mathbf x_0)$. It seems likely that $mathcal A_C$ consists of a countable union â which I stress could be empty â of continuous curves $gamma in mathcal C(mathbb R)$, although a such conjecture obviously have to be proven.
In the more general form, where $k, n in mathbb N$ is chosen arbitrary, can we say something about the nature/topology of the set $mathcal A_C$? Does less restrictive requirements on the function $mathbf f$ enable us to say more, for example if we only required $mathbf f$ to be locally Lipschitz?
(In the more general form, where $mathbf f in mathcal C^k(mathbb R^n)$, it seems like a probable guess that $mathcal A_C$ has to consist of an countable union of sets which are path-connected by $C^k$-curves. Also note that points are, in this sense, curves.)
real-analysis multivariable-calculus
Well, since $mathbf f$ is continuous then $mathcal A_C$ is closed. I'm not sure how much more you can say without knowing more about $mathbf f$.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:20
@TheoreticalEconomist Is this true, though? Consider a constant function $mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$ and $mathcal A_alpha = displaystyle mathbf x : mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$.. This set is all of $mathbb R^n$ and hence not closed.
â Markus Klyver
Aug 17 at 23:31
You are mistaken. $mathbb R^n$ is closed.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:34
Saying $A_C$ is a union of curves, where points are also curves, isn't saying much. Any set is a union of points.
â Rahul
Aug 17 at 23:45
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
Consider a function $mathbf f : mathbb R^n to mathbb R$ as an element of $mathcal C^k(mathbb R^n)$ and a fixed real number $C in mathbb R$. Now define the multidimensional level set $mathcal A_C = displaystylemathbf x in mathbb R^n : mathbf f(mathbf x) = C .$
Does the constrains on $mathbf f$ imply anything for the set $mathcal A_C$?
As an example, consider the simple case of $begincases k=0 \ n=2 endcases$ and the question about the nature of the multidimensional level set $mathcal A_C$ as defined above.
This means that $mathbb f$ maps the plane continuously to the real line. Also assume that there's no ball $B(varepsilon, mathbf x_0) = displaystyle mathbf x - mathbf x_0$ such that $mathbf f$ is constant on $B(varepsilon, mathbf x_0)$. It seems likely that $mathcal A_C$ consists of a countable union â which I stress could be empty â of continuous curves $gamma in mathcal C(mathbb R)$, although a such conjecture obviously have to be proven.
In the more general form, where $k, n in mathbb N$ is chosen arbitrary, can we say something about the nature/topology of the set $mathcal A_C$? Does less restrictive requirements on the function $mathbf f$ enable us to say more, for example if we only required $mathbf f$ to be locally Lipschitz?
(In the more general form, where $mathbf f in mathcal C^k(mathbb R^n)$, it seems like a probable guess that $mathcal A_C$ has to consist of an countable union of sets which are path-connected by $C^k$-curves. Also note that points are, in this sense, curves.)
real-analysis multivariable-calculus
Consider a function $mathbf f : mathbb R^n to mathbb R$ as an element of $mathcal C^k(mathbb R^n)$ and a fixed real number $C in mathbb R$. Now define the multidimensional level set $mathcal A_C = displaystylemathbf x in mathbb R^n : mathbf f(mathbf x) = C .$
Does the constrains on $mathbf f$ imply anything for the set $mathcal A_C$?
As an example, consider the simple case of $begincases k=0 \ n=2 endcases$ and the question about the nature of the multidimensional level set $mathcal A_C$ as defined above.
This means that $mathbb f$ maps the plane continuously to the real line. Also assume that there's no ball $B(varepsilon, mathbf x_0) = displaystyle mathbf x - mathbf x_0$ such that $mathbf f$ is constant on $B(varepsilon, mathbf x_0)$. It seems likely that $mathcal A_C$ consists of a countable union â which I stress could be empty â of continuous curves $gamma in mathcal C(mathbb R)$, although a such conjecture obviously have to be proven.
In the more general form, where $k, n in mathbb N$ is chosen arbitrary, can we say something about the nature/topology of the set $mathcal A_C$? Does less restrictive requirements on the function $mathbf f$ enable us to say more, for example if we only required $mathbf f$ to be locally Lipschitz?
(In the more general form, where $mathbf f in mathcal C^k(mathbb R^n)$, it seems like a probable guess that $mathcal A_C$ has to consist of an countable union of sets which are path-connected by $C^k$-curves. Also note that points are, in this sense, curves.)
real-analysis multivariable-calculus
edited Aug 17 at 23:54
asked Aug 17 at 23:05
Markus Klyver
375314
375314
Well, since $mathbf f$ is continuous then $mathcal A_C$ is closed. I'm not sure how much more you can say without knowing more about $mathbf f$.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:20
@TheoreticalEconomist Is this true, though? Consider a constant function $mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$ and $mathcal A_alpha = displaystyle mathbf x : mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$.. This set is all of $mathbb R^n$ and hence not closed.
â Markus Klyver
Aug 17 at 23:31
You are mistaken. $mathbb R^n$ is closed.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:34
Saying $A_C$ is a union of curves, where points are also curves, isn't saying much. Any set is a union of points.
â Rahul
Aug 17 at 23:45
add a comment |Â
Well, since $mathbf f$ is continuous then $mathcal A_C$ is closed. I'm not sure how much more you can say without knowing more about $mathbf f$.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:20
@TheoreticalEconomist Is this true, though? Consider a constant function $mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$ and $mathcal A_alpha = displaystyle mathbf x : mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$.. This set is all of $mathbb R^n$ and hence not closed.
â Markus Klyver
Aug 17 at 23:31
You are mistaken. $mathbb R^n$ is closed.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:34
Saying $A_C$ is a union of curves, where points are also curves, isn't saying much. Any set is a union of points.
â Rahul
Aug 17 at 23:45
Well, since $mathbf f$ is continuous then $mathcal A_C$ is closed. I'm not sure how much more you can say without knowing more about $mathbf f$.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:20
Well, since $mathbf f$ is continuous then $mathcal A_C$ is closed. I'm not sure how much more you can say without knowing more about $mathbf f$.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:20
@TheoreticalEconomist Is this true, though? Consider a constant function $mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$ and $mathcal A_alpha = displaystyle mathbf x : mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$.. This set is all of $mathbb R^n$ and hence not closed.
â Markus Klyver
Aug 17 at 23:31
@TheoreticalEconomist Is this true, though? Consider a constant function $mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$ and $mathcal A_alpha = displaystyle mathbf x : mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$.. This set is all of $mathbb R^n$ and hence not closed.
â Markus Klyver
Aug 17 at 23:31
You are mistaken. $mathbb R^n$ is closed.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:34
You are mistaken. $mathbb R^n$ is closed.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:34
Saying $A_C$ is a union of curves, where points are also curves, isn't saying much. Any set is a union of points.
â Rahul
Aug 17 at 23:45
Saying $A_C$ is a union of curves, where points are also curves, isn't saying much. Any set is a union of points.
â Rahul
Aug 17 at 23:45
add a comment |Â
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2886275%2fmultidimensional-level-sets%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Well, since $mathbf f$ is continuous then $mathcal A_C$ is closed. I'm not sure how much more you can say without knowing more about $mathbf f$.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:20
@TheoreticalEconomist Is this true, though? Consider a constant function $mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$ and $mathcal A_alpha = displaystyle mathbf x : mathbf f(mathbf x) = alpha$.. This set is all of $mathbb R^n$ and hence not closed.
â Markus Klyver
Aug 17 at 23:31
You are mistaken. $mathbb R^n$ is closed.
â Theoretical Economist
Aug 17 at 23:34
Saying $A_C$ is a union of curves, where points are also curves, isn't saying much. Any set is a union of points.
â Rahul
Aug 17 at 23:45