Calculating the first zero of Riemann Zeta Function by hand
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
There are lots of pages on MSE and other websites regarding few first zeros of The Riemann Zeta Function. On MSE [this] is by far the closest (or the only one I've found) explanation for finding the first zero, but again it doesn't explain how to calculate $t approx 14.134725$ numerically in details. And, I don't think solving $zeta(z)=frac 11-2^1-zsum_n=1^infty frac (-1)^n-1n^z=0$ would be a plausible approach(?)
I have heard that Riemann computed the first three zeros himself and I suppose he didn't have an access a computer so what are the numerical methods/formulas/algorithms to arrive at $t approx 14.134725$ through calculation by hands?
numerical-methods roots special-functions riemann-zeta
asked Aug 18 at 0:19
Edi
1,114829
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
There are lots of pages on MSE and other websites regarding few first zeros of The Riemann Zeta Function. On MSE [this] is by far the closest (or the only one I've found) explanation for finding the first zero, but again it doesn't explain how to calculate $t approx 14.134725$ numerically in details. And, I don't think solving $zeta(z)=frac 11-2^1-zsum_n=1^infty frac (-1)^n-1n^z=0$ would be a plausible approach(?)
I have heard that Riemann computed the first three zeros himself and I suppose he didn't have an access a computer so what are the numerical methods/formulas/algorithms to arrive at $t approx 14.134725$ through calculation by hands?
numerical-methods roots special-functions riemann-zeta
asked Aug 18 at 0:19
Edi
1,114829
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
There are lots of pages on MSE and other websites regarding few first zeros of The Riemann Zeta Function. On MSE [this] is by far the closest (or the only one I've found) explanation for finding the first zero, but again it doesn't explain how to calculate $t approx 14.134725$ numerically in details. And, I don't think solving $zeta(z)=frac 11-2^1-zsum_n=1^infty frac (-1)^n-1n^z=0$ would be a plausible approach(?)
I have heard that Riemann computed the first three zeros himself and I suppose he didn't have an access a computer so what are the numerical methods/formulas/algorithms to arrive at $t approx 14.134725$ through calculation by hands?
numerical-methods roots special-functions riemann-zeta
asked Aug 18 at 0:19
Edi
1,114829
There are lots of pages on MSE and other websites regarding few first zeros of The Riemann Zeta Function. On MSE [this] is by far the closest (or the only one I've found) explanation for finding the first zero, but again it doesn't explain how to calculate $t approx 14.134725$ numerically in details. And, I don't think solving $zeta(z)=frac 11-2^1-zsum_n=1^infty frac (-1)^n-1n^z=0$ would be a plausible approach(?)
I have heard that Riemann computed the first three zeros himself and I suppose he didn't have an access a computer so what are the numerical methods/formulas/algorithms to arrive at $t approx 14.134725$ through calculation by hands?
numerical-methods roots special-functions riemann-zeta
asked Aug 18 at 0:19
Edi
1,114829
edited Aug 18 at 7:02
asked Aug 18 at 0:19
Edi
1,114829
asked Aug 18 at 0:19
Edi
1,114829
asked Aug 18 at 0:19
Edi
1,114829
1,114829
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
A formula Riemann derived, now called the Riemann Siegel Formula, gives a way to compute the zeta function on the critical line with extreme accuracy. He used the contour integral representation of the Zeta function that was slightly modified (more similar to the hurwitz zeta function but it doesn't really matter) and expanded the contour to give some easily computable terms, then redrew another contour to "concentrate" the value of the rest of the integral and was able to give some asymptotic remainder terms, all of which give a surprisingly accurate (and fairly simple) way to calculate the value of the zeta function on the critical strip. You can see the formula on Wikipedia
(Specifically for the critical strip) and the generalized formula here Using Desmos I was able to insert the formula and I tested out the accuracy and was surprised-- the first few zeroes of the zeta function on the critical strip lie around:
t=14.134725...
t=21.02203...
t=25.0108...
And here is a picture of a graph of the formula:
https://i.stack.imgur.com/3kQNz.jpg
And it's accuracy maintains for large values as well--two zeroes that lie incredibly close to each other and describe "Lehmer's Phenomenon"
, both lying at around t=7005 are shown with the formula aswell:
https://i.stack.imgur.com/yGxSg.jpg
If you're interested in a thourough derivation of the formula here is a pretty good explanation--there's several versions of the formula that are far more complex and have a much more complex derivation but this one is still suitable.
I cant upload photos on here yet and I'm on mobile so I'm sorry if this is messy--hope this helps.
edited Aug 18 at 3:21
Michael Hardy
205k23187463
answered Aug 18 at 2:55
uhhhhidk
211
add a comment |Â
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
A formula Riemann derived, now called the Riemann Siegel Formula, gives a way to compute the zeta function on the critical line with extreme accuracy. He used the contour integral representation of the Zeta function that was slightly modified (more similar to the hurwitz zeta function but it doesn't really matter) and expanded the contour to give some easily computable terms, then redrew another contour to "concentrate" the value of the rest of the integral and was able to give some asymptotic remainder terms, all of which give a surprisingly accurate (and fairly simple) way to calculate the value of the zeta function on the critical strip. You can see the formula on Wikipedia
(Specifically for the critical strip) and the generalized formula here Using Desmos I was able to insert the formula and I tested out the accuracy and was surprised-- the first few zeroes of the zeta function on the critical strip lie around:
t=14.134725...
t=21.02203...
t=25.0108...
And here is a picture of a graph of the formula:
https://i.stack.imgur.com/3kQNz.jpg
And it's accuracy maintains for large values as well--two zeroes that lie incredibly close to each other and describe "Lehmer's Phenomenon"
, both lying at around t=7005 are shown with the formula aswell:
https://i.stack.imgur.com/yGxSg.jpg
If you're interested in a thourough derivation of the formula here is a pretty good explanation--there's several versions of the formula that are far more complex and have a much more complex derivation but this one is still suitable.
I cant upload photos on here yet and I'm on mobile so I'm sorry if this is messy--hope this helps.
edited Aug 18 at 3:21
Michael Hardy
205k23187463
answered Aug 18 at 2:55
uhhhhidk
211
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
A formula Riemann derived, now called the Riemann Siegel Formula, gives a way to compute the zeta function on the critical line with extreme accuracy. He used the contour integral representation of the Zeta function that was slightly modified (more similar to the hurwitz zeta function but it doesn't really matter) and expanded the contour to give some easily computable terms, then redrew another contour to "concentrate" the value of the rest of the integral and was able to give some asymptotic remainder terms, all of which give a surprisingly accurate (and fairly simple) way to calculate the value of the zeta function on the critical strip. You can see the formula on Wikipedia
(Specifically for the critical strip) and the generalized formula here Using Desmos I was able to insert the formula and I tested out the accuracy and was surprised-- the first few zeroes of the zeta function on the critical strip lie around:
t=14.134725...
t=21.02203...
t=25.0108...
And here is a picture of a graph of the formula:
https://i.stack.imgur.com/3kQNz.jpg
And it's accuracy maintains for large values as well--two zeroes that lie incredibly close to each other and describe "Lehmer's Phenomenon"
, both lying at around t=7005 are shown with the formula aswell:
https://i.stack.imgur.com/yGxSg.jpg
If you're interested in a thourough derivation of the formula here is a pretty good explanation--there's several versions of the formula that are far more complex and have a much more complex derivation but this one is still suitable.
I cant upload photos on here yet and I'm on mobile so I'm sorry if this is messy--hope this helps.
edited Aug 18 at 3:21
Michael Hardy
205k23187463
answered Aug 18 at 2:55
uhhhhidk
211
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
A formula Riemann derived, now called the Riemann Siegel Formula, gives a way to compute the zeta function on the critical line with extreme accuracy. He used the contour integral representation of the Zeta function that was slightly modified (more similar to the hurwitz zeta function but it doesn't really matter) and expanded the contour to give some easily computable terms, then redrew another contour to "concentrate" the value of the rest of the integral and was able to give some asymptotic remainder terms, all of which give a surprisingly accurate (and fairly simple) way to calculate the value of the zeta function on the critical strip. You can see the formula on Wikipedia
(Specifically for the critical strip) and the generalized formula here Using Desmos I was able to insert the formula and I tested out the accuracy and was surprised-- the first few zeroes of the zeta function on the critical strip lie around:
t=14.134725...
t=21.02203...
t=25.0108...
And here is a picture of a graph of the formula:
https://i.stack.imgur.com/3kQNz.jpg
And it's accuracy maintains for large values as well--two zeroes that lie incredibly close to each other and describe "Lehmer's Phenomenon"
, both lying at around t=7005 are shown with the formula aswell:
https://i.stack.imgur.com/yGxSg.jpg
If you're interested in a thourough derivation of the formula here is a pretty good explanation--there's several versions of the formula that are far more complex and have a much more complex derivation but this one is still suitable.
I cant upload photos on here yet and I'm on mobile so I'm sorry if this is messy--hope this helps.
edited Aug 18 at 3:21
Michael Hardy
205k23187463
answered Aug 18 at 2:55
uhhhhidk
211
A formula Riemann derived, now called the Riemann Siegel Formula, gives a way to compute the zeta function on the critical line with extreme accuracy. He used the contour integral representation of the Zeta function that was slightly modified (more similar to the hurwitz zeta function but it doesn't really matter) and expanded the contour to give some easily computable terms, then redrew another contour to "concentrate" the value of the rest of the integral and was able to give some asymptotic remainder terms, all of which give a surprisingly accurate (and fairly simple) way to calculate the value of the zeta function on the critical strip. You can see the formula on Wikipedia
(Specifically for the critical strip) and the generalized formula here Using Desmos I was able to insert the formula and I tested out the accuracy and was surprised-- the first few zeroes of the zeta function on the critical strip lie around:
t=14.134725...
t=21.02203...
t=25.0108...
And here is a picture of a graph of the formula:
https://i.stack.imgur.com/3kQNz.jpg
And it's accuracy maintains for large values as well--two zeroes that lie incredibly close to each other and describe "Lehmer's Phenomenon"
, both lying at around t=7005 are shown with the formula aswell:
https://i.stack.imgur.com/yGxSg.jpg
If you're interested in a thourough derivation of the formula here is a pretty good explanation--there's several versions of the formula that are far more complex and have a much more complex derivation but this one is still suitable.
I cant upload photos on here yet and I'm on mobile so I'm sorry if this is messy--hope this helps.
edited Aug 18 at 3:21
Michael Hardy
205k23187463
answered Aug 18 at 2:55
uhhhhidk
211
edited Aug 18 at 3:21
Michael Hardy
205k23187463
edited Aug 18 at 3:21
Michael Hardy
205k23187463
edited Aug 18 at 3:21
Michael Hardy
205k23187463
205k23187463
answered Aug 18 at 2:55
uhhhhidk
211
answered Aug 18 at 2:55
uhhhhidk
211
answered Aug 18 at 2:55
uhhhhidk
211
211
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2886306%2fcalculating-the-first-zero-of-riemann-zeta-function-by-hand%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
