Improper Integration $int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x),dxx$ converges or not.

The name of the pictureThe name of the pictureThe name of the pictureClash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP











up vote
4
down vote

favorite
1












I was trying to find whether the $int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x),dxx$ converges or not. And after integrating I got



$lim_xtoinfty(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi)-lim_xto0(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi)$. (Which I will define as A)



and I was lost there. Because I got $infty$-$infty$. Does that mean the integral diverges to something that is indeterminable.(not $infty$ and -$infty$)



Also I asked a question concerning the expression above here
L'hospital for inf-inf



And found that according to a fellow name gimusi, $$lim_xtoinftyleft[ left(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpiright) - left(frac12ln^2(1/x)+(1/x)lnpiright)right]$$ (which I will define as B)



is, however calculable. And I calculated it to be approaching infinity. Does that mean the integral diverges (to infinity)? I am lost now.



Questions Summary:



  1. Does A=B (doesn't seem so)

  2. Does the integral converges or diverges? (And how to figure that out)









share|cite|improve this question



























    up vote
    4
    down vote

    favorite
    1












    I was trying to find whether the $int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x),dxx$ converges or not. And after integrating I got



    $lim_xtoinfty(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi)-lim_xto0(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi)$. (Which I will define as A)



    and I was lost there. Because I got $infty$-$infty$. Does that mean the integral diverges to something that is indeterminable.(not $infty$ and -$infty$)



    Also I asked a question concerning the expression above here
    L'hospital for inf-inf



    And found that according to a fellow name gimusi, $$lim_xtoinftyleft[ left(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpiright) - left(frac12ln^2(1/x)+(1/x)lnpiright)right]$$ (which I will define as B)



    is, however calculable. And I calculated it to be approaching infinity. Does that mean the integral diverges (to infinity)? I am lost now.



    Questions Summary:



    1. Does A=B (doesn't seem so)

    2. Does the integral converges or diverges? (And how to figure that out)









    share|cite|improve this question

























      up vote
      4
      down vote

      favorite
      1









      up vote
      4
      down vote

      favorite
      1






      1





      I was trying to find whether the $int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x),dxx$ converges or not. And after integrating I got



      $lim_xtoinfty(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi)-lim_xto0(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi)$. (Which I will define as A)



      and I was lost there. Because I got $infty$-$infty$. Does that mean the integral diverges to something that is indeterminable.(not $infty$ and -$infty$)



      Also I asked a question concerning the expression above here
      L'hospital for inf-inf



      And found that according to a fellow name gimusi, $$lim_xtoinftyleft[ left(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpiright) - left(frac12ln^2(1/x)+(1/x)lnpiright)right]$$ (which I will define as B)



      is, however calculable. And I calculated it to be approaching infinity. Does that mean the integral diverges (to infinity)? I am lost now.



      Questions Summary:



      1. Does A=B (doesn't seem so)

      2. Does the integral converges or diverges? (And how to figure that out)









      share|cite|improve this question















      I was trying to find whether the $int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x),dxx$ converges or not. And after integrating I got



      $lim_xtoinfty(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi)-lim_xto0(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi)$. (Which I will define as A)



      and I was lost there. Because I got $infty$-$infty$. Does that mean the integral diverges to something that is indeterminable.(not $infty$ and -$infty$)



      Also I asked a question concerning the expression above here
      L'hospital for inf-inf



      And found that according to a fellow name gimusi, $$lim_xtoinftyleft[ left(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpiright) - left(frac12ln^2(1/x)+(1/x)lnpiright)right]$$ (which I will define as B)



      is, however calculable. And I calculated it to be approaching infinity. Does that mean the integral diverges (to infinity)? I am lost now.



      Questions Summary:



      1. Does A=B (doesn't seem so)

      2. Does the integral converges or diverges? (And how to figure that out)






      calculus improper-integrals






      share|cite|improve this question















      share|cite|improve this question













      share|cite|improve this question




      share|cite|improve this question








      edited Sep 9 at 9:02









      Bernard

      112k636105




      112k636105










      asked Sep 9 at 8:48









      JoisBack

      1355




      1355




















          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes

















          up vote
          6
          down vote



          accepted










          We have that



          $$int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx
          =int_0^inftyfracln x +xln pi xdx
          =int_0^inftyfracln xxdx+int_0^inftyln pi ,dx$$



          and we can conclude here since both integrals diverge.



          Note that for the limit we have



          $$left(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpiright) - left(frac12ln^2(1/x)+(1/x)lnpiright)$$



          $$frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi - frac12ln^2(1/x)-(1/x)lnpi$$



          $$frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi - frac12ln^2(x)-(1/x)lnpi$$



          $$xlnpi -(1/x)lnpi to infty$$



          but it can't be used to evaluate the integral indeed for the improper integral we need to consider for $a>0$ the two integrals



          $$int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx=int_0^a fracln(xpi^x)xdx+int_a^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx$$



          and the two limits at $0$ and $infty$ for the two integrals are independent and must be evaluated separetely.






          share|cite|improve this answer






















          • Big thanks to your effort for explaining. However, can you pls explain why integral of lnx/x from x =0 to x=inf diverges? I mean I can understand that from x=1 to inf, it diverges. But here there are both plus and minus infinity at . Visually, I plotted the graph of lnx/x on desmos and found that at 0<x<1 the area is approaching minus infinity whereas when x>1 the area is approaching infinity? I know that it's coming back to the same question of infinity minus infinity, but I still don't understand why. Also the transition from the expression in line 3 to line 4 seems incorrect to me.
            – JoisBack
            Sep 9 at 9:24











          • It suffices note that $int_1^inftyfraclog xx$ diverges to conclude that the whole integral diverges. Thiems topic was discussed many times here on MSE, I try to find some link to those discussions.
            – gimusi
            Sep 9 at 16:06







          • 1




            For the second issue I’ve used that $$log frac1x=-log ximplies log^2 frac1x=(-log x)^2=log^2 x$$
            – gimusi
            Sep 9 at 16:08










          Your Answer




          StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function ()
          return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function ()
          StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix)
          StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
          );
          );
          , "mathjax-editing");

          StackExchange.ready(function()
          var channelOptions =
          tags: "".split(" "),
          id: "69"
          ;
          initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

          StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
          // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
          if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
          StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
          createEditor();
          );

          else
          createEditor();

          );

          function createEditor()
          StackExchange.prepareEditor(
          heartbeatType: 'answer',
          convertImagesToLinks: true,
          noModals: false,
          showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
          reputationToPostImages: 10,
          bindNavPrevention: true,
          postfix: "",
          noCode: true, onDemand: true,
          discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
          ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
          );



          );













           

          draft saved


          draft discarded


















          StackExchange.ready(
          function ()
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2910557%2fimproper-integration-int-0-infty-frac-lnx-pix-dxx-converges-or-not%23new-answer', 'question_page');

          );

          Post as a guest






























          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes








          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes









          active

          oldest

          votes






          active

          oldest

          votes








          up vote
          6
          down vote



          accepted










          We have that



          $$int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx
          =int_0^inftyfracln x +xln pi xdx
          =int_0^inftyfracln xxdx+int_0^inftyln pi ,dx$$



          and we can conclude here since both integrals diverge.



          Note that for the limit we have



          $$left(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpiright) - left(frac12ln^2(1/x)+(1/x)lnpiright)$$



          $$frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi - frac12ln^2(1/x)-(1/x)lnpi$$



          $$frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi - frac12ln^2(x)-(1/x)lnpi$$



          $$xlnpi -(1/x)lnpi to infty$$



          but it can't be used to evaluate the integral indeed for the improper integral we need to consider for $a>0$ the two integrals



          $$int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx=int_0^a fracln(xpi^x)xdx+int_a^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx$$



          and the two limits at $0$ and $infty$ for the two integrals are independent and must be evaluated separetely.






          share|cite|improve this answer






















          • Big thanks to your effort for explaining. However, can you pls explain why integral of lnx/x from x =0 to x=inf diverges? I mean I can understand that from x=1 to inf, it diverges. But here there are both plus and minus infinity at . Visually, I plotted the graph of lnx/x on desmos and found that at 0<x<1 the area is approaching minus infinity whereas when x>1 the area is approaching infinity? I know that it's coming back to the same question of infinity minus infinity, but I still don't understand why. Also the transition from the expression in line 3 to line 4 seems incorrect to me.
            – JoisBack
            Sep 9 at 9:24











          • It suffices note that $int_1^inftyfraclog xx$ diverges to conclude that the whole integral diverges. Thiems topic was discussed many times here on MSE, I try to find some link to those discussions.
            – gimusi
            Sep 9 at 16:06







          • 1




            For the second issue I’ve used that $$log frac1x=-log ximplies log^2 frac1x=(-log x)^2=log^2 x$$
            – gimusi
            Sep 9 at 16:08














          up vote
          6
          down vote



          accepted










          We have that



          $$int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx
          =int_0^inftyfracln x +xln pi xdx
          =int_0^inftyfracln xxdx+int_0^inftyln pi ,dx$$



          and we can conclude here since both integrals diverge.



          Note that for the limit we have



          $$left(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpiright) - left(frac12ln^2(1/x)+(1/x)lnpiright)$$



          $$frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi - frac12ln^2(1/x)-(1/x)lnpi$$



          $$frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi - frac12ln^2(x)-(1/x)lnpi$$



          $$xlnpi -(1/x)lnpi to infty$$



          but it can't be used to evaluate the integral indeed for the improper integral we need to consider for $a>0$ the two integrals



          $$int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx=int_0^a fracln(xpi^x)xdx+int_a^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx$$



          and the two limits at $0$ and $infty$ for the two integrals are independent and must be evaluated separetely.






          share|cite|improve this answer






















          • Big thanks to your effort for explaining. However, can you pls explain why integral of lnx/x from x =0 to x=inf diverges? I mean I can understand that from x=1 to inf, it diverges. But here there are both plus and minus infinity at . Visually, I plotted the graph of lnx/x on desmos and found that at 0<x<1 the area is approaching minus infinity whereas when x>1 the area is approaching infinity? I know that it's coming back to the same question of infinity minus infinity, but I still don't understand why. Also the transition from the expression in line 3 to line 4 seems incorrect to me.
            – JoisBack
            Sep 9 at 9:24











          • It suffices note that $int_1^inftyfraclog xx$ diverges to conclude that the whole integral diverges. Thiems topic was discussed many times here on MSE, I try to find some link to those discussions.
            – gimusi
            Sep 9 at 16:06







          • 1




            For the second issue I’ve used that $$log frac1x=-log ximplies log^2 frac1x=(-log x)^2=log^2 x$$
            – gimusi
            Sep 9 at 16:08












          up vote
          6
          down vote



          accepted







          up vote
          6
          down vote



          accepted






          We have that



          $$int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx
          =int_0^inftyfracln x +xln pi xdx
          =int_0^inftyfracln xxdx+int_0^inftyln pi ,dx$$



          and we can conclude here since both integrals diverge.



          Note that for the limit we have



          $$left(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpiright) - left(frac12ln^2(1/x)+(1/x)lnpiright)$$



          $$frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi - frac12ln^2(1/x)-(1/x)lnpi$$



          $$frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi - frac12ln^2(x)-(1/x)lnpi$$



          $$xlnpi -(1/x)lnpi to infty$$



          but it can't be used to evaluate the integral indeed for the improper integral we need to consider for $a>0$ the two integrals



          $$int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx=int_0^a fracln(xpi^x)xdx+int_a^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx$$



          and the two limits at $0$ and $infty$ for the two integrals are independent and must be evaluated separetely.






          share|cite|improve this answer














          We have that



          $$int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx
          =int_0^inftyfracln x +xln pi xdx
          =int_0^inftyfracln xxdx+int_0^inftyln pi ,dx$$



          and we can conclude here since both integrals diverge.



          Note that for the limit we have



          $$left(frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpiright) - left(frac12ln^2(1/x)+(1/x)lnpiright)$$



          $$frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi - frac12ln^2(1/x)-(1/x)lnpi$$



          $$frac12ln^2(x)+xlnpi - frac12ln^2(x)-(1/x)lnpi$$



          $$xlnpi -(1/x)lnpi to infty$$



          but it can't be used to evaluate the integral indeed for the improper integral we need to consider for $a>0$ the two integrals



          $$int_0^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx=int_0^a fracln(xpi^x)xdx+int_a^inftyfracln(xpi^x)xdx$$



          and the two limits at $0$ and $infty$ for the two integrals are independent and must be evaluated separetely.







          share|cite|improve this answer














          share|cite|improve this answer



          share|cite|improve this answer








          edited Sep 9 at 9:11

























          answered Sep 9 at 8:52









          gimusi

          74.3k73889




          74.3k73889











          • Big thanks to your effort for explaining. However, can you pls explain why integral of lnx/x from x =0 to x=inf diverges? I mean I can understand that from x=1 to inf, it diverges. But here there are both plus and minus infinity at . Visually, I plotted the graph of lnx/x on desmos and found that at 0<x<1 the area is approaching minus infinity whereas when x>1 the area is approaching infinity? I know that it's coming back to the same question of infinity minus infinity, but I still don't understand why. Also the transition from the expression in line 3 to line 4 seems incorrect to me.
            – JoisBack
            Sep 9 at 9:24











          • It suffices note that $int_1^inftyfraclog xx$ diverges to conclude that the whole integral diverges. Thiems topic was discussed many times here on MSE, I try to find some link to those discussions.
            – gimusi
            Sep 9 at 16:06







          • 1




            For the second issue I’ve used that $$log frac1x=-log ximplies log^2 frac1x=(-log x)^2=log^2 x$$
            – gimusi
            Sep 9 at 16:08
















          • Big thanks to your effort for explaining. However, can you pls explain why integral of lnx/x from x =0 to x=inf diverges? I mean I can understand that from x=1 to inf, it diverges. But here there are both plus and minus infinity at . Visually, I plotted the graph of lnx/x on desmos and found that at 0<x<1 the area is approaching minus infinity whereas when x>1 the area is approaching infinity? I know that it's coming back to the same question of infinity minus infinity, but I still don't understand why. Also the transition from the expression in line 3 to line 4 seems incorrect to me.
            – JoisBack
            Sep 9 at 9:24











          • It suffices note that $int_1^inftyfraclog xx$ diverges to conclude that the whole integral diverges. Thiems topic was discussed many times here on MSE, I try to find some link to those discussions.
            – gimusi
            Sep 9 at 16:06







          • 1




            For the second issue I’ve used that $$log frac1x=-log ximplies log^2 frac1x=(-log x)^2=log^2 x$$
            – gimusi
            Sep 9 at 16:08















          Big thanks to your effort for explaining. However, can you pls explain why integral of lnx/x from x =0 to x=inf diverges? I mean I can understand that from x=1 to inf, it diverges. But here there are both plus and minus infinity at . Visually, I plotted the graph of lnx/x on desmos and found that at 0<x<1 the area is approaching minus infinity whereas when x>1 the area is approaching infinity? I know that it's coming back to the same question of infinity minus infinity, but I still don't understand why. Also the transition from the expression in line 3 to line 4 seems incorrect to me.
          – JoisBack
          Sep 9 at 9:24





          Big thanks to your effort for explaining. However, can you pls explain why integral of lnx/x from x =0 to x=inf diverges? I mean I can understand that from x=1 to inf, it diverges. But here there are both plus and minus infinity at . Visually, I plotted the graph of lnx/x on desmos and found that at 0<x<1 the area is approaching minus infinity whereas when x>1 the area is approaching infinity? I know that it's coming back to the same question of infinity minus infinity, but I still don't understand why. Also the transition from the expression in line 3 to line 4 seems incorrect to me.
          – JoisBack
          Sep 9 at 9:24













          It suffices note that $int_1^inftyfraclog xx$ diverges to conclude that the whole integral diverges. Thiems topic was discussed many times here on MSE, I try to find some link to those discussions.
          – gimusi
          Sep 9 at 16:06





          It suffices note that $int_1^inftyfraclog xx$ diverges to conclude that the whole integral diverges. Thiems topic was discussed many times here on MSE, I try to find some link to those discussions.
          – gimusi
          Sep 9 at 16:06





          1




          1




          For the second issue I’ve used that $$log frac1x=-log ximplies log^2 frac1x=(-log x)^2=log^2 x$$
          – gimusi
          Sep 9 at 16:08




          For the second issue I’ve used that $$log frac1x=-log ximplies log^2 frac1x=(-log x)^2=log^2 x$$
          – gimusi
          Sep 9 at 16:08

















           

          draft saved


          draft discarded















































           


          draft saved


          draft discarded














          StackExchange.ready(
          function ()
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2910557%2fimproper-integration-int-0-infty-frac-lnx-pix-dxx-converges-or-not%23new-answer', 'question_page');

          );

          Post as a guest













































































          這個網誌中的熱門文章

          How to combine Bézier curves to a surface?

          Why am i infinitely getting the same tweet with the Twitter Search API?

          Carbon dioxide