Improper integral $int_0^inftyleft(frac1sqrtx^2+4-frackx+2right)dx$
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
Given improper integral $$int limits_0^inftyleft(frac1sqrtx^2+4-frackx+2right)dx , ,$$
there exists $k$ that makes this integral convergent.
Find its integration value.
Choices are $ln 2$, $ln 3$, $ln 4$, and $ln 5$.
I've written every information from the problem.
Yet I'm not sure whether I should find the integration value from the given integral or $k$.
What I've tried so far is,
$int_0^infty frac1sqrtx^2+4 , dx= left[sinh^-1fracx2right]_0^infty$
How should I proceed?
integration improper-integrals
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
Given improper integral $$int limits_0^inftyleft(frac1sqrtx^2+4-frackx+2right)dx , ,$$
there exists $k$ that makes this integral convergent.
Find its integration value.
Choices are $ln 2$, $ln 3$, $ln 4$, and $ln 5$.
I've written every information from the problem.
Yet I'm not sure whether I should find the integration value from the given integral or $k$.
What I've tried so far is,
$int_0^infty frac1sqrtx^2+4 , dx= left[sinh^-1fracx2right]_0^infty$
How should I proceed?
integration improper-integrals
They don't let you say "none of the above"?
â Lord Shark the Unknown
Aug 24 at 8:34
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
Given improper integral $$int limits_0^inftyleft(frac1sqrtx^2+4-frackx+2right)dx , ,$$
there exists $k$ that makes this integral convergent.
Find its integration value.
Choices are $ln 2$, $ln 3$, $ln 4$, and $ln 5$.
I've written every information from the problem.
Yet I'm not sure whether I should find the integration value from the given integral or $k$.
What I've tried so far is,
$int_0^infty frac1sqrtx^2+4 , dx= left[sinh^-1fracx2right]_0^infty$
How should I proceed?
integration improper-integrals
Given improper integral $$int limits_0^inftyleft(frac1sqrtx^2+4-frackx+2right)dx , ,$$
there exists $k$ that makes this integral convergent.
Find its integration value.
Choices are $ln 2$, $ln 3$, $ln 4$, and $ln 5$.
I've written every information from the problem.
Yet I'm not sure whether I should find the integration value from the given integral or $k$.
What I've tried so far is,
$int_0^infty frac1sqrtx^2+4 , dx= left[sinh^-1fracx2right]_0^infty$
How should I proceed?
integration improper-integrals
edited Aug 24 at 8:54
ComplexYetTrivial
3,027626
3,027626
asked Aug 24 at 8:32
nik
925
925
They don't let you say "none of the above"?
â Lord Shark the Unknown
Aug 24 at 8:34
add a comment |Â
They don't let you say "none of the above"?
â Lord Shark the Unknown
Aug 24 at 8:34
They don't let you say "none of the above"?
â Lord Shark the Unknown
Aug 24 at 8:34
They don't let you say "none of the above"?
â Lord Shark the Unknown
Aug 24 at 8:34
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
0
down vote
accepted
We have that for $xto infty$
$$frac1sqrtx^2+4=frac1x(1+4/x^2)^-1/2sim frac1x-frac2x^3$$
and
$$frac k x+2sim frac k x$$
therefore in order to have convergence we need $k=1$ in such way that the $frac1x$ term cancels out.
Then we need to solve and evaluate
$$int_0^inftyleft (frac1sqrtx^2+4-frac1x+2right)dx=left[sinh^-1frac x 2 -log (x+2)right]_0^infty$$
and to evaluate the value at $infty$ recall that
$$sinh^-1frac x 2=log left(frac x 2 + sqrtfracx^24+1right) sim log x$$
Thanks! the last calculation part still bothers me. I'll give it a try.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:53
You're still writing it. Awsome.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:54
@nik If you use the log expression for arcsinh it becomes trivial
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 8:54
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
As shown in gimusi's answer, you do not need to compute the integral.
However, if you want to integrate, consider
$$I=int_0^pleft(frac1sqrtx^2+4-frackx+2right),dx=sinh ^-1left(fracp2right)-k log (p+2)+k log (2)$$ and use series expansion for large $p$. This should give
$$I=(1-k) log left(pright)+k log (2)-frac2 kp+frac2
k+1p^2+Oleft(frac1p^3right)$$ and look at the limit when $pto infty$.
ThatâÂÂs really a very nice way!
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 9:03
Still there is another great answer. Thank you.
â nik
Aug 24 at 9:06
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
There are no integration issue in a right neighbourhood of the origin, but when $xto +infty$ we have that the integrand function behaves like $frac1-kx+Oleft(frac1x^2right)$, so a necessary and sufficient condition for the integrability is $k=1$. In such a case
$$begineqnarray* int_0^+inftyleft[frac1sqrtx^2+4-frac1x+2right],dx &stackrelxmapsto 2z=& int_0^+inftyleft[frac1sqrtz^2+1-frac1z+1right],dz\[0.3cm]&=&left[textarcsinh(z)-log(z+1)right]_0^+infty\[0.3cm]&=&lim_zto +inftytextarcsinh(z)-log(z+1)\&stackrelzmapstosinh t=&lim_tto +infty logleft(frace^tsinh t+1right)=colorredlog 2.endeqnarray*$$
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
0
down vote
accepted
We have that for $xto infty$
$$frac1sqrtx^2+4=frac1x(1+4/x^2)^-1/2sim frac1x-frac2x^3$$
and
$$frac k x+2sim frac k x$$
therefore in order to have convergence we need $k=1$ in such way that the $frac1x$ term cancels out.
Then we need to solve and evaluate
$$int_0^inftyleft (frac1sqrtx^2+4-frac1x+2right)dx=left[sinh^-1frac x 2 -log (x+2)right]_0^infty$$
and to evaluate the value at $infty$ recall that
$$sinh^-1frac x 2=log left(frac x 2 + sqrtfracx^24+1right) sim log x$$
Thanks! the last calculation part still bothers me. I'll give it a try.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:53
You're still writing it. Awsome.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:54
@nik If you use the log expression for arcsinh it becomes trivial
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 8:54
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
accepted
We have that for $xto infty$
$$frac1sqrtx^2+4=frac1x(1+4/x^2)^-1/2sim frac1x-frac2x^3$$
and
$$frac k x+2sim frac k x$$
therefore in order to have convergence we need $k=1$ in such way that the $frac1x$ term cancels out.
Then we need to solve and evaluate
$$int_0^inftyleft (frac1sqrtx^2+4-frac1x+2right)dx=left[sinh^-1frac x 2 -log (x+2)right]_0^infty$$
and to evaluate the value at $infty$ recall that
$$sinh^-1frac x 2=log left(frac x 2 + sqrtfracx^24+1right) sim log x$$
Thanks! the last calculation part still bothers me. I'll give it a try.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:53
You're still writing it. Awsome.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:54
@nik If you use the log expression for arcsinh it becomes trivial
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 8:54
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
accepted
up vote
0
down vote
accepted
We have that for $xto infty$
$$frac1sqrtx^2+4=frac1x(1+4/x^2)^-1/2sim frac1x-frac2x^3$$
and
$$frac k x+2sim frac k x$$
therefore in order to have convergence we need $k=1$ in such way that the $frac1x$ term cancels out.
Then we need to solve and evaluate
$$int_0^inftyleft (frac1sqrtx^2+4-frac1x+2right)dx=left[sinh^-1frac x 2 -log (x+2)right]_0^infty$$
and to evaluate the value at $infty$ recall that
$$sinh^-1frac x 2=log left(frac x 2 + sqrtfracx^24+1right) sim log x$$
We have that for $xto infty$
$$frac1sqrtx^2+4=frac1x(1+4/x^2)^-1/2sim frac1x-frac2x^3$$
and
$$frac k x+2sim frac k x$$
therefore in order to have convergence we need $k=1$ in such way that the $frac1x$ term cancels out.
Then we need to solve and evaluate
$$int_0^inftyleft (frac1sqrtx^2+4-frac1x+2right)dx=left[sinh^-1frac x 2 -log (x+2)right]_0^infty$$
and to evaluate the value at $infty$ recall that
$$sinh^-1frac x 2=log left(frac x 2 + sqrtfracx^24+1right) sim log x$$
edited Aug 24 at 8:56
answered Aug 24 at 8:38
gimusi
69.7k73686
69.7k73686
Thanks! the last calculation part still bothers me. I'll give it a try.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:53
You're still writing it. Awsome.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:54
@nik If you use the log expression for arcsinh it becomes trivial
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 8:54
add a comment |Â
Thanks! the last calculation part still bothers me. I'll give it a try.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:53
You're still writing it. Awsome.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:54
@nik If you use the log expression for arcsinh it becomes trivial
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 8:54
Thanks! the last calculation part still bothers me. I'll give it a try.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:53
Thanks! the last calculation part still bothers me. I'll give it a try.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:53
You're still writing it. Awsome.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:54
You're still writing it. Awsome.
â nik
Aug 24 at 8:54
@nik If you use the log expression for arcsinh it becomes trivial
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 8:54
@nik If you use the log expression for arcsinh it becomes trivial
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 8:54
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
As shown in gimusi's answer, you do not need to compute the integral.
However, if you want to integrate, consider
$$I=int_0^pleft(frac1sqrtx^2+4-frackx+2right),dx=sinh ^-1left(fracp2right)-k log (p+2)+k log (2)$$ and use series expansion for large $p$. This should give
$$I=(1-k) log left(pright)+k log (2)-frac2 kp+frac2
k+1p^2+Oleft(frac1p^3right)$$ and look at the limit when $pto infty$.
ThatâÂÂs really a very nice way!
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 9:03
Still there is another great answer. Thank you.
â nik
Aug 24 at 9:06
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
As shown in gimusi's answer, you do not need to compute the integral.
However, if you want to integrate, consider
$$I=int_0^pleft(frac1sqrtx^2+4-frackx+2right),dx=sinh ^-1left(fracp2right)-k log (p+2)+k log (2)$$ and use series expansion for large $p$. This should give
$$I=(1-k) log left(pright)+k log (2)-frac2 kp+frac2
k+1p^2+Oleft(frac1p^3right)$$ and look at the limit when $pto infty$.
ThatâÂÂs really a very nice way!
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 9:03
Still there is another great answer. Thank you.
â nik
Aug 24 at 9:06
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
As shown in gimusi's answer, you do not need to compute the integral.
However, if you want to integrate, consider
$$I=int_0^pleft(frac1sqrtx^2+4-frackx+2right),dx=sinh ^-1left(fracp2right)-k log (p+2)+k log (2)$$ and use series expansion for large $p$. This should give
$$I=(1-k) log left(pright)+k log (2)-frac2 kp+frac2
k+1p^2+Oleft(frac1p^3right)$$ and look at the limit when $pto infty$.
As shown in gimusi's answer, you do not need to compute the integral.
However, if you want to integrate, consider
$$I=int_0^pleft(frac1sqrtx^2+4-frackx+2right),dx=sinh ^-1left(fracp2right)-k log (p+2)+k log (2)$$ and use series expansion for large $p$. This should give
$$I=(1-k) log left(pright)+k log (2)-frac2 kp+frac2
k+1p^2+Oleft(frac1p^3right)$$ and look at the limit when $pto infty$.
answered Aug 24 at 8:59
Claude Leibovici
113k1155127
113k1155127
ThatâÂÂs really a very nice way!
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 9:03
Still there is another great answer. Thank you.
â nik
Aug 24 at 9:06
add a comment |Â
ThatâÂÂs really a very nice way!
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 9:03
Still there is another great answer. Thank you.
â nik
Aug 24 at 9:06
ThatâÂÂs really a very nice way!
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 9:03
ThatâÂÂs really a very nice way!
â gimusi
Aug 24 at 9:03
Still there is another great answer. Thank you.
â nik
Aug 24 at 9:06
Still there is another great answer. Thank you.
â nik
Aug 24 at 9:06
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
There are no integration issue in a right neighbourhood of the origin, but when $xto +infty$ we have that the integrand function behaves like $frac1-kx+Oleft(frac1x^2right)$, so a necessary and sufficient condition for the integrability is $k=1$. In such a case
$$begineqnarray* int_0^+inftyleft[frac1sqrtx^2+4-frac1x+2right],dx &stackrelxmapsto 2z=& int_0^+inftyleft[frac1sqrtz^2+1-frac1z+1right],dz\[0.3cm]&=&left[textarcsinh(z)-log(z+1)right]_0^+infty\[0.3cm]&=&lim_zto +inftytextarcsinh(z)-log(z+1)\&stackrelzmapstosinh t=&lim_tto +infty logleft(frace^tsinh t+1right)=colorredlog 2.endeqnarray*$$
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
There are no integration issue in a right neighbourhood of the origin, but when $xto +infty$ we have that the integrand function behaves like $frac1-kx+Oleft(frac1x^2right)$, so a necessary and sufficient condition for the integrability is $k=1$. In such a case
$$begineqnarray* int_0^+inftyleft[frac1sqrtx^2+4-frac1x+2right],dx &stackrelxmapsto 2z=& int_0^+inftyleft[frac1sqrtz^2+1-frac1z+1right],dz\[0.3cm]&=&left[textarcsinh(z)-log(z+1)right]_0^+infty\[0.3cm]&=&lim_zto +inftytextarcsinh(z)-log(z+1)\&stackrelzmapstosinh t=&lim_tto +infty logleft(frace^tsinh t+1right)=colorredlog 2.endeqnarray*$$
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
There are no integration issue in a right neighbourhood of the origin, but when $xto +infty$ we have that the integrand function behaves like $frac1-kx+Oleft(frac1x^2right)$, so a necessary and sufficient condition for the integrability is $k=1$. In such a case
$$begineqnarray* int_0^+inftyleft[frac1sqrtx^2+4-frac1x+2right],dx &stackrelxmapsto 2z=& int_0^+inftyleft[frac1sqrtz^2+1-frac1z+1right],dz\[0.3cm]&=&left[textarcsinh(z)-log(z+1)right]_0^+infty\[0.3cm]&=&lim_zto +inftytextarcsinh(z)-log(z+1)\&stackrelzmapstosinh t=&lim_tto +infty logleft(frace^tsinh t+1right)=colorredlog 2.endeqnarray*$$
There are no integration issue in a right neighbourhood of the origin, but when $xto +infty$ we have that the integrand function behaves like $frac1-kx+Oleft(frac1x^2right)$, so a necessary and sufficient condition for the integrability is $k=1$. In such a case
$$begineqnarray* int_0^+inftyleft[frac1sqrtx^2+4-frac1x+2right],dx &stackrelxmapsto 2z=& int_0^+inftyleft[frac1sqrtz^2+1-frac1z+1right],dz\[0.3cm]&=&left[textarcsinh(z)-log(z+1)right]_0^+infty\[0.3cm]&=&lim_zto +inftytextarcsinh(z)-log(z+1)\&stackrelzmapstosinh t=&lim_tto +infty logleft(frace^tsinh t+1right)=colorredlog 2.endeqnarray*$$
answered Aug 24 at 17:37
Jack D'Aurizioâ¦
273k32268636
273k32268636
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2892899%2fimproper-integral-int-0-infty-left-frac1-sqrtx24-frackx2-r%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
They don't let you say "none of the above"?
â Lord Shark the Unknown
Aug 24 at 8:34