Difficulty Understanding Tom Apostol's Method of Exhaustion Proof

Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
In Tom Apostol's Calculus Vol 1 book, Apostol presents the following equation:
$$3[1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2]+ 3[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)] + (n - 1)=n^3-1^3$$
He then states that the second sum on the left, which is $[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)]$, is a sum of terms in an arithmetic progression, so that part will simplify to $fracn(n-1)2$, thus the final equation becomes this:
$$1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2=fracn^33-fracn^22+fracn6$$
What I cannot understand is how Apostol simplified $[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)]$ to $fracn(n-1)2$. As far as I understand, a sum of terms of an arithmetic progression has the following format: $fracn(a+b)2$, with $a$ and $b$ representing the initial and $b$th term of the sequence, respectively. Where does he get $n-1$? Furthermore, how does he simplify the final formula to $1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2=fracn^33-fracn^22+fracn6$?
calculus sequences-and-series
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
In Tom Apostol's Calculus Vol 1 book, Apostol presents the following equation:
$$3[1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2]+ 3[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)] + (n - 1)=n^3-1^3$$
He then states that the second sum on the left, which is $[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)]$, is a sum of terms in an arithmetic progression, so that part will simplify to $fracn(n-1)2$, thus the final equation becomes this:
$$1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2=fracn^33-fracn^22+fracn6$$
What I cannot understand is how Apostol simplified $[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)]$ to $fracn(n-1)2$. As far as I understand, a sum of terms of an arithmetic progression has the following format: $fracn(a+b)2$, with $a$ and $b$ representing the initial and $b$th term of the sequence, respectively. Where does he get $n-1$? Furthermore, how does he simplify the final formula to $1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2=fracn^33-fracn^22+fracn6$?
calculus sequences-and-series
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
In Tom Apostol's Calculus Vol 1 book, Apostol presents the following equation:
$$3[1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2]+ 3[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)] + (n - 1)=n^3-1^3$$
He then states that the second sum on the left, which is $[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)]$, is a sum of terms in an arithmetic progression, so that part will simplify to $fracn(n-1)2$, thus the final equation becomes this:
$$1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2=fracn^33-fracn^22+fracn6$$
What I cannot understand is how Apostol simplified $[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)]$ to $fracn(n-1)2$. As far as I understand, a sum of terms of an arithmetic progression has the following format: $fracn(a+b)2$, with $a$ and $b$ representing the initial and $b$th term of the sequence, respectively. Where does he get $n-1$? Furthermore, how does he simplify the final formula to $1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2=fracn^33-fracn^22+fracn6$?
calculus sequences-and-series
In Tom Apostol's Calculus Vol 1 book, Apostol presents the following equation:
$$3[1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2]+ 3[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)] + (n - 1)=n^3-1^3$$
He then states that the second sum on the left, which is $[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)]$, is a sum of terms in an arithmetic progression, so that part will simplify to $fracn(n-1)2$, thus the final equation becomes this:
$$1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2=fracn^33-fracn^22+fracn6$$
What I cannot understand is how Apostol simplified $[1 + 2+ . . . + (n - 1)]$ to $fracn(n-1)2$. As far as I understand, a sum of terms of an arithmetic progression has the following format: $fracn(a+b)2$, with $a$ and $b$ representing the initial and $b$th term of the sequence, respectively. Where does he get $n-1$? Furthermore, how does he simplify the final formula to $1^2+2^2+...+(n-1)^2=fracn^33-fracn^22+fracn6$?
calculus sequences-and-series
calculus sequences-and-series
edited Sep 1 at 0:24
Ethan Bolker
36.4k54299
36.4k54299
asked Sep 1 at 0:20
user22333
161
161
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
0
down vote
Note that you have $n-1$ terms, not $n$. Thus the sum will be of the form $frac(n-1)(a+b)2$. Now it makes sense.
After substituting this in the equation you get:
$$3sum_k=1^n-1 k^2 = n^3 - 1 - (n-1) - 3fracn(n-1)2 = n^3 - n - frac3n^22 + frac3n2 = n^3 - frac3n^22 + fracn2$$
$$sum_k=1^n-1 k^2 = fracn^33 - fracn^22 + frac n6$$
Thank you, but you how does he get the final equation? He is actually trying to do a proof for the sum of squares
â user22333
Sep 1 at 0:32
@user22333 I just updated my answer
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:01
@Stefan4042 Could you elaborate more on what exactly combines and what cancels out etc? Sorry, I'm quite new to this.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:10
@user22333 I guess I couldn't make it more simple than this.
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:28
@Stefan4042 I understand it now after your edit. Thank you.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:36
add a comment |Â
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
0
down vote
Note that you have $n-1$ terms, not $n$. Thus the sum will be of the form $frac(n-1)(a+b)2$. Now it makes sense.
After substituting this in the equation you get:
$$3sum_k=1^n-1 k^2 = n^3 - 1 - (n-1) - 3fracn(n-1)2 = n^3 - n - frac3n^22 + frac3n2 = n^3 - frac3n^22 + fracn2$$
$$sum_k=1^n-1 k^2 = fracn^33 - fracn^22 + frac n6$$
Thank you, but you how does he get the final equation? He is actually trying to do a proof for the sum of squares
â user22333
Sep 1 at 0:32
@user22333 I just updated my answer
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:01
@Stefan4042 Could you elaborate more on what exactly combines and what cancels out etc? Sorry, I'm quite new to this.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:10
@user22333 I guess I couldn't make it more simple than this.
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:28
@Stefan4042 I understand it now after your edit. Thank you.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:36
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
Note that you have $n-1$ terms, not $n$. Thus the sum will be of the form $frac(n-1)(a+b)2$. Now it makes sense.
After substituting this in the equation you get:
$$3sum_k=1^n-1 k^2 = n^3 - 1 - (n-1) - 3fracn(n-1)2 = n^3 - n - frac3n^22 + frac3n2 = n^3 - frac3n^22 + fracn2$$
$$sum_k=1^n-1 k^2 = fracn^33 - fracn^22 + frac n6$$
Thank you, but you how does he get the final equation? He is actually trying to do a proof for the sum of squares
â user22333
Sep 1 at 0:32
@user22333 I just updated my answer
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:01
@Stefan4042 Could you elaborate more on what exactly combines and what cancels out etc? Sorry, I'm quite new to this.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:10
@user22333 I guess I couldn't make it more simple than this.
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:28
@Stefan4042 I understand it now after your edit. Thank you.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:36
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
Note that you have $n-1$ terms, not $n$. Thus the sum will be of the form $frac(n-1)(a+b)2$. Now it makes sense.
After substituting this in the equation you get:
$$3sum_k=1^n-1 k^2 = n^3 - 1 - (n-1) - 3fracn(n-1)2 = n^3 - n - frac3n^22 + frac3n2 = n^3 - frac3n^22 + fracn2$$
$$sum_k=1^n-1 k^2 = fracn^33 - fracn^22 + frac n6$$
Note that you have $n-1$ terms, not $n$. Thus the sum will be of the form $frac(n-1)(a+b)2$. Now it makes sense.
After substituting this in the equation you get:
$$3sum_k=1^n-1 k^2 = n^3 - 1 - (n-1) - 3fracn(n-1)2 = n^3 - n - frac3n^22 + frac3n2 = n^3 - frac3n^22 + fracn2$$
$$sum_k=1^n-1 k^2 = fracn^33 - fracn^22 + frac n6$$
edited Sep 1 at 1:28
answered Sep 1 at 0:24
Stefan4024
29.8k53377
29.8k53377
Thank you, but you how does he get the final equation? He is actually trying to do a proof for the sum of squares
â user22333
Sep 1 at 0:32
@user22333 I just updated my answer
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:01
@Stefan4042 Could you elaborate more on what exactly combines and what cancels out etc? Sorry, I'm quite new to this.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:10
@user22333 I guess I couldn't make it more simple than this.
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:28
@Stefan4042 I understand it now after your edit. Thank you.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:36
add a comment |Â
Thank you, but you how does he get the final equation? He is actually trying to do a proof for the sum of squares
â user22333
Sep 1 at 0:32
@user22333 I just updated my answer
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:01
@Stefan4042 Could you elaborate more on what exactly combines and what cancels out etc? Sorry, I'm quite new to this.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:10
@user22333 I guess I couldn't make it more simple than this.
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:28
@Stefan4042 I understand it now after your edit. Thank you.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:36
Thank you, but you how does he get the final equation? He is actually trying to do a proof for the sum of squares
â user22333
Sep 1 at 0:32
Thank you, but you how does he get the final equation? He is actually trying to do a proof for the sum of squares
â user22333
Sep 1 at 0:32
@user22333 I just updated my answer
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:01
@user22333 I just updated my answer
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:01
@Stefan4042 Could you elaborate more on what exactly combines and what cancels out etc? Sorry, I'm quite new to this.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:10
@Stefan4042 Could you elaborate more on what exactly combines and what cancels out etc? Sorry, I'm quite new to this.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:10
@user22333 I guess I couldn't make it more simple than this.
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:28
@user22333 I guess I couldn't make it more simple than this.
â Stefan4024
Sep 1 at 1:28
@Stefan4042 I understand it now after your edit. Thank you.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:36
@Stefan4042 I understand it now after your edit. Thank you.
â user22333
Sep 1 at 1:36
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2901243%2fdifficulty-understanding-tom-apostols-method-of-exhaustion-proof%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password