inquality $sum_i=1^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_ilesum_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12$
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
8
down vote
favorite
let $x_iin N^+$,and such $1=x_0le x_1le x_2lecdotsle x_n$ show that
$$sum_i=1^ndfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_ilesum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i-dfrac12$$
maybe can use C-S,But I can't it
sequences-and-series inequality summation contest-math radicals
add a comment |Â
up vote
8
down vote
favorite
let $x_iin N^+$,and such $1=x_0le x_1le x_2lecdotsle x_n$ show that
$$sum_i=1^ndfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_ilesum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i-dfrac12$$
maybe can use C-S,But I can't it
sequences-and-series inequality summation contest-math radicals
What is wrong with my answer?
â Francisco Abusleme
Sep 6 at 18:49
add a comment |Â
up vote
8
down vote
favorite
up vote
8
down vote
favorite
let $x_iin N^+$,and such $1=x_0le x_1le x_2lecdotsle x_n$ show that
$$sum_i=1^ndfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_ilesum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i-dfrac12$$
maybe can use C-S,But I can't it
sequences-and-series inequality summation contest-math radicals
let $x_iin N^+$,and such $1=x_0le x_1le x_2lecdotsle x_n$ show that
$$sum_i=1^ndfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_ilesum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i-dfrac12$$
maybe can use C-S,But I can't it
sequences-and-series inequality summation contest-math radicals
sequences-and-series inequality summation contest-math radicals
edited Sep 1 at 23:26
Arjang
5,48962162
5,48962162
asked Sep 1 at 4:15
communnites
1,2581431
1,2581431
What is wrong with my answer?
â Francisco Abusleme
Sep 6 at 18:49
add a comment |Â
What is wrong with my answer?
â Francisco Abusleme
Sep 6 at 18:49
What is wrong with my answer?
â Francisco Abusleme
Sep 6 at 18:49
What is wrong with my answer?
â Francisco Abusleme
Sep 6 at 18:49
add a comment |Â
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
I think the following can help.
Let for $n>1$ we have $x_nleq n^2$.
Thus, $$sum_i=1^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_ileqsum_i=1^nfracx_i-x_i-1x_i=sum_i=1^nsum_j=1^x_i-x_i-1frac1x_ileq$$
$$leqsum_i=1^nsum_j=1^x_i-x_i-1frac1x_i-1+j=sum_i=x_0+1^x_nfrac1ileqsum_i=2^n^2frac1i<sum_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$$
If first $x_k>n^2$.
Thus, $$sum_i=k^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i<sum_i=k^nfrac1sqrtx_i<sum_i=k^nfrac1n<1$$ and
$$sum_i=1^k-1fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i<sum_i=2^n^2frac1i.$$
then How to do it?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:35
@communnites For $x_nleq n^2$ it's proven. Try to end the proof if $x_k>n^2$ for some $k<n$, where $x_k-1leq n^2.$ The biggest part of the work I made already.
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 8:51
why $sqrtx_i-x_i-1le x_i-x_i-1$? if $x_i=x_i-1$ then?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:57
and My question right is $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2-frac12$,not $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2$
â communnites
Sep 1 at 9:02
@communnites Because for all natural $m$ we have $sqrtmleq m.$ Also, for $x_nleq n^2$ I proved that $LHSleqsumlimits_i=2^n^2frac1i<sumlimits_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 9:39
 |Â
show 1 more comment
up vote
-1
down vote
I am going to treat $x_i$ as a real variable. Then, we can differentiate the terms with respect to $x_i$:
$$fracddx_ifracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i$$
It is easy to show that the derivative is $ 0$ when $x_i=2x_i-1$, and it is also easy to show that it is a maximum (take the 2nd derivave, or just look at the cases $x_i=x_i-1$ and $x_irightarrowinfty $ .
So replacing $x_i=2x_i-1$ we get that each term becomes $frac12sqrtx_i-1$.
Note too, that when using this values for $x_i$, the smaller the values we choose, the term becomes bigger, so there is no doubt that the sum is maxed when we use $x_i=2^i$, therefore:
$$sum_i=1^n fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i leqsum_i=0^n frac12sqrt2^i $$
So if show the worst case we are done. This last series can be easily solved as a geometric one, so the problem is now reduced to showing that:
$$(1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+1) leq sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 quad mathbf(1) $$
I will do it by induction. The case $n=1$ is easy. Now we take $(1)$ as our hypothesis, and we want to prove that if the case for $n$ is true, then the case for $n+1$ is true. Starting by the $n+1$ case in the right hand side, we have that:
$$sum_i=1^(n+1)^2 frac 1i - frac12 = sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 +sum_i=n^2+1^(n+1)^2 frac 1i $$
Now we use $(1)$ with the sum up to $n^2$ (and the negative one half), and since we can replace any quantity with a smaller one and the inequality will still be valid, I will replace the latter sum by the number of terms of the sum (expand $(n+1)^2$ to see that the number of terms is $2n+1$ ) multiplied by the smallest term, so now we have to show that:
$$ (1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+1)+ frac2n+1(n+1)^2geq (1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+2) $$
Rearranging:
$$frac2n+1(n+1)^2geq frac 12 (frac1sqrt2)^n+1 quad mathbf(2)$$
And here I will use a second induction. First, you show that the inequality holds for $n in text1,2,3,4,5$, and using $(2)$ as the hypothesis, we work the left hand side for the case $n+1$ as follows:
$$frac2n+3(n+2)^2 gt frac2n+3sqrt2(n+1)^2 $$
This last inequality, holds for $n gt 5$, because for these values of n, we have that $sqrt[4]2(n+1) gt n+2 $ (That's why I trated the other 5 cases separately). So now we can replace the hypothesis to get:
$$frac2n+3sqrt2(n+1)^2 = frac 12sqrt2 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+1 + frac22sqrt2(n+1)^2 gt frac 12 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+2 $$
Therefore,
$$frac2n+3(n+2)^2 gt frac 12 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+2 $$
This means the $n+1$ case is true, then the hypothesis $(2)$ is true for all natural $n$, and the same goes to the hypothesis $(1)$ and the proof is completed:
$$sum_i=1^n fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i leqsum_i=0^n frac12sqrt2^i leq sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 $$
it's right? Thanks
â communnites
Sep 2 at 2:01
add a comment |Â
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
I think the following can help.
Let for $n>1$ we have $x_nleq n^2$.
Thus, $$sum_i=1^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_ileqsum_i=1^nfracx_i-x_i-1x_i=sum_i=1^nsum_j=1^x_i-x_i-1frac1x_ileq$$
$$leqsum_i=1^nsum_j=1^x_i-x_i-1frac1x_i-1+j=sum_i=x_0+1^x_nfrac1ileqsum_i=2^n^2frac1i<sum_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$$
If first $x_k>n^2$.
Thus, $$sum_i=k^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i<sum_i=k^nfrac1sqrtx_i<sum_i=k^nfrac1n<1$$ and
$$sum_i=1^k-1fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i<sum_i=2^n^2frac1i.$$
then How to do it?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:35
@communnites For $x_nleq n^2$ it's proven. Try to end the proof if $x_k>n^2$ for some $k<n$, where $x_k-1leq n^2.$ The biggest part of the work I made already.
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 8:51
why $sqrtx_i-x_i-1le x_i-x_i-1$? if $x_i=x_i-1$ then?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:57
and My question right is $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2-frac12$,not $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2$
â communnites
Sep 1 at 9:02
@communnites Because for all natural $m$ we have $sqrtmleq m.$ Also, for $x_nleq n^2$ I proved that $LHSleqsumlimits_i=2^n^2frac1i<sumlimits_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 9:39
 |Â
show 1 more comment
up vote
2
down vote
I think the following can help.
Let for $n>1$ we have $x_nleq n^2$.
Thus, $$sum_i=1^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_ileqsum_i=1^nfracx_i-x_i-1x_i=sum_i=1^nsum_j=1^x_i-x_i-1frac1x_ileq$$
$$leqsum_i=1^nsum_j=1^x_i-x_i-1frac1x_i-1+j=sum_i=x_0+1^x_nfrac1ileqsum_i=2^n^2frac1i<sum_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$$
If first $x_k>n^2$.
Thus, $$sum_i=k^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i<sum_i=k^nfrac1sqrtx_i<sum_i=k^nfrac1n<1$$ and
$$sum_i=1^k-1fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i<sum_i=2^n^2frac1i.$$
then How to do it?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:35
@communnites For $x_nleq n^2$ it's proven. Try to end the proof if $x_k>n^2$ for some $k<n$, where $x_k-1leq n^2.$ The biggest part of the work I made already.
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 8:51
why $sqrtx_i-x_i-1le x_i-x_i-1$? if $x_i=x_i-1$ then?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:57
and My question right is $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2-frac12$,not $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2$
â communnites
Sep 1 at 9:02
@communnites Because for all natural $m$ we have $sqrtmleq m.$ Also, for $x_nleq n^2$ I proved that $LHSleqsumlimits_i=2^n^2frac1i<sumlimits_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 9:39
 |Â
show 1 more comment
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
I think the following can help.
Let for $n>1$ we have $x_nleq n^2$.
Thus, $$sum_i=1^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_ileqsum_i=1^nfracx_i-x_i-1x_i=sum_i=1^nsum_j=1^x_i-x_i-1frac1x_ileq$$
$$leqsum_i=1^nsum_j=1^x_i-x_i-1frac1x_i-1+j=sum_i=x_0+1^x_nfrac1ileqsum_i=2^n^2frac1i<sum_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$$
If first $x_k>n^2$.
Thus, $$sum_i=k^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i<sum_i=k^nfrac1sqrtx_i<sum_i=k^nfrac1n<1$$ and
$$sum_i=1^k-1fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i<sum_i=2^n^2frac1i.$$
I think the following can help.
Let for $n>1$ we have $x_nleq n^2$.
Thus, $$sum_i=1^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_ileqsum_i=1^nfracx_i-x_i-1x_i=sum_i=1^nsum_j=1^x_i-x_i-1frac1x_ileq$$
$$leqsum_i=1^nsum_j=1^x_i-x_i-1frac1x_i-1+j=sum_i=x_0+1^x_nfrac1ileqsum_i=2^n^2frac1i<sum_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$$
If first $x_k>n^2$.
Thus, $$sum_i=k^nfracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i<sum_i=k^nfrac1sqrtx_i<sum_i=k^nfrac1n<1$$ and
$$sum_i=1^k-1fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i<sum_i=2^n^2frac1i.$$
edited Sep 1 at 20:25
answered Sep 1 at 6:21
Michael Rozenberg
89.1k1582179
89.1k1582179
then How to do it?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:35
@communnites For $x_nleq n^2$ it's proven. Try to end the proof if $x_k>n^2$ for some $k<n$, where $x_k-1leq n^2.$ The biggest part of the work I made already.
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 8:51
why $sqrtx_i-x_i-1le x_i-x_i-1$? if $x_i=x_i-1$ then?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:57
and My question right is $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2-frac12$,not $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2$
â communnites
Sep 1 at 9:02
@communnites Because for all natural $m$ we have $sqrtmleq m.$ Also, for $x_nleq n^2$ I proved that $LHSleqsumlimits_i=2^n^2frac1i<sumlimits_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 9:39
 |Â
show 1 more comment
then How to do it?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:35
@communnites For $x_nleq n^2$ it's proven. Try to end the proof if $x_k>n^2$ for some $k<n$, where $x_k-1leq n^2.$ The biggest part of the work I made already.
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 8:51
why $sqrtx_i-x_i-1le x_i-x_i-1$? if $x_i=x_i-1$ then?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:57
and My question right is $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2-frac12$,not $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2$
â communnites
Sep 1 at 9:02
@communnites Because for all natural $m$ we have $sqrtmleq m.$ Also, for $x_nleq n^2$ I proved that $LHSleqsumlimits_i=2^n^2frac1i<sumlimits_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 9:39
then How to do it?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:35
then How to do it?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:35
@communnites For $x_nleq n^2$ it's proven. Try to end the proof if $x_k>n^2$ for some $k<n$, where $x_k-1leq n^2.$ The biggest part of the work I made already.
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 8:51
@communnites For $x_nleq n^2$ it's proven. Try to end the proof if $x_k>n^2$ for some $k<n$, where $x_k-1leq n^2.$ The biggest part of the work I made already.
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 8:51
why $sqrtx_i-x_i-1le x_i-x_i-1$? if $x_i=x_i-1$ then?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:57
why $sqrtx_i-x_i-1le x_i-x_i-1$? if $x_i=x_i-1$ then?
â communnites
Sep 1 at 8:57
and My question right is $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2-frac12$,not $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2$
â communnites
Sep 1 at 9:02
and My question right is $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2-frac12$,not $sum_i=1^n^2dfrac1i^2$
â communnites
Sep 1 at 9:02
@communnites Because for all natural $m$ we have $sqrtmleq m.$ Also, for $x_nleq n^2$ I proved that $LHSleqsumlimits_i=2^n^2frac1i<sumlimits_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 9:39
@communnites Because for all natural $m$ we have $sqrtmleq m.$ Also, for $x_nleq n^2$ I proved that $LHSleqsumlimits_i=2^n^2frac1i<sumlimits_i=1^n^2frac1i-frac12.$
â Michael Rozenberg
Sep 1 at 9:39
 |Â
show 1 more comment
up vote
-1
down vote
I am going to treat $x_i$ as a real variable. Then, we can differentiate the terms with respect to $x_i$:
$$fracddx_ifracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i$$
It is easy to show that the derivative is $ 0$ when $x_i=2x_i-1$, and it is also easy to show that it is a maximum (take the 2nd derivave, or just look at the cases $x_i=x_i-1$ and $x_irightarrowinfty $ .
So replacing $x_i=2x_i-1$ we get that each term becomes $frac12sqrtx_i-1$.
Note too, that when using this values for $x_i$, the smaller the values we choose, the term becomes bigger, so there is no doubt that the sum is maxed when we use $x_i=2^i$, therefore:
$$sum_i=1^n fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i leqsum_i=0^n frac12sqrt2^i $$
So if show the worst case we are done. This last series can be easily solved as a geometric one, so the problem is now reduced to showing that:
$$(1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+1) leq sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 quad mathbf(1) $$
I will do it by induction. The case $n=1$ is easy. Now we take $(1)$ as our hypothesis, and we want to prove that if the case for $n$ is true, then the case for $n+1$ is true. Starting by the $n+1$ case in the right hand side, we have that:
$$sum_i=1^(n+1)^2 frac 1i - frac12 = sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 +sum_i=n^2+1^(n+1)^2 frac 1i $$
Now we use $(1)$ with the sum up to $n^2$ (and the negative one half), and since we can replace any quantity with a smaller one and the inequality will still be valid, I will replace the latter sum by the number of terms of the sum (expand $(n+1)^2$ to see that the number of terms is $2n+1$ ) multiplied by the smallest term, so now we have to show that:
$$ (1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+1)+ frac2n+1(n+1)^2geq (1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+2) $$
Rearranging:
$$frac2n+1(n+1)^2geq frac 12 (frac1sqrt2)^n+1 quad mathbf(2)$$
And here I will use a second induction. First, you show that the inequality holds for $n in text1,2,3,4,5$, and using $(2)$ as the hypothesis, we work the left hand side for the case $n+1$ as follows:
$$frac2n+3(n+2)^2 gt frac2n+3sqrt2(n+1)^2 $$
This last inequality, holds for $n gt 5$, because for these values of n, we have that $sqrt[4]2(n+1) gt n+2 $ (That's why I trated the other 5 cases separately). So now we can replace the hypothesis to get:
$$frac2n+3sqrt2(n+1)^2 = frac 12sqrt2 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+1 + frac22sqrt2(n+1)^2 gt frac 12 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+2 $$
Therefore,
$$frac2n+3(n+2)^2 gt frac 12 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+2 $$
This means the $n+1$ case is true, then the hypothesis $(2)$ is true for all natural $n$, and the same goes to the hypothesis $(1)$ and the proof is completed:
$$sum_i=1^n fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i leqsum_i=0^n frac12sqrt2^i leq sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 $$
it's right? Thanks
â communnites
Sep 2 at 2:01
add a comment |Â
up vote
-1
down vote
I am going to treat $x_i$ as a real variable. Then, we can differentiate the terms with respect to $x_i$:
$$fracddx_ifracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i$$
It is easy to show that the derivative is $ 0$ when $x_i=2x_i-1$, and it is also easy to show that it is a maximum (take the 2nd derivave, or just look at the cases $x_i=x_i-1$ and $x_irightarrowinfty $ .
So replacing $x_i=2x_i-1$ we get that each term becomes $frac12sqrtx_i-1$.
Note too, that when using this values for $x_i$, the smaller the values we choose, the term becomes bigger, so there is no doubt that the sum is maxed when we use $x_i=2^i$, therefore:
$$sum_i=1^n fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i leqsum_i=0^n frac12sqrt2^i $$
So if show the worst case we are done. This last series can be easily solved as a geometric one, so the problem is now reduced to showing that:
$$(1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+1) leq sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 quad mathbf(1) $$
I will do it by induction. The case $n=1$ is easy. Now we take $(1)$ as our hypothesis, and we want to prove that if the case for $n$ is true, then the case for $n+1$ is true. Starting by the $n+1$ case in the right hand side, we have that:
$$sum_i=1^(n+1)^2 frac 1i - frac12 = sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 +sum_i=n^2+1^(n+1)^2 frac 1i $$
Now we use $(1)$ with the sum up to $n^2$ (and the negative one half), and since we can replace any quantity with a smaller one and the inequality will still be valid, I will replace the latter sum by the number of terms of the sum (expand $(n+1)^2$ to see that the number of terms is $2n+1$ ) multiplied by the smallest term, so now we have to show that:
$$ (1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+1)+ frac2n+1(n+1)^2geq (1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+2) $$
Rearranging:
$$frac2n+1(n+1)^2geq frac 12 (frac1sqrt2)^n+1 quad mathbf(2)$$
And here I will use a second induction. First, you show that the inequality holds for $n in text1,2,3,4,5$, and using $(2)$ as the hypothesis, we work the left hand side for the case $n+1$ as follows:
$$frac2n+3(n+2)^2 gt frac2n+3sqrt2(n+1)^2 $$
This last inequality, holds for $n gt 5$, because for these values of n, we have that $sqrt[4]2(n+1) gt n+2 $ (That's why I trated the other 5 cases separately). So now we can replace the hypothesis to get:
$$frac2n+3sqrt2(n+1)^2 = frac 12sqrt2 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+1 + frac22sqrt2(n+1)^2 gt frac 12 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+2 $$
Therefore,
$$frac2n+3(n+2)^2 gt frac 12 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+2 $$
This means the $n+1$ case is true, then the hypothesis $(2)$ is true for all natural $n$, and the same goes to the hypothesis $(1)$ and the proof is completed:
$$sum_i=1^n fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i leqsum_i=0^n frac12sqrt2^i leq sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 $$
it's right? Thanks
â communnites
Sep 2 at 2:01
add a comment |Â
up vote
-1
down vote
up vote
-1
down vote
I am going to treat $x_i$ as a real variable. Then, we can differentiate the terms with respect to $x_i$:
$$fracddx_ifracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i$$
It is easy to show that the derivative is $ 0$ when $x_i=2x_i-1$, and it is also easy to show that it is a maximum (take the 2nd derivave, or just look at the cases $x_i=x_i-1$ and $x_irightarrowinfty $ .
So replacing $x_i=2x_i-1$ we get that each term becomes $frac12sqrtx_i-1$.
Note too, that when using this values for $x_i$, the smaller the values we choose, the term becomes bigger, so there is no doubt that the sum is maxed when we use $x_i=2^i$, therefore:
$$sum_i=1^n fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i leqsum_i=0^n frac12sqrt2^i $$
So if show the worst case we are done. This last series can be easily solved as a geometric one, so the problem is now reduced to showing that:
$$(1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+1) leq sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 quad mathbf(1) $$
I will do it by induction. The case $n=1$ is easy. Now we take $(1)$ as our hypothesis, and we want to prove that if the case for $n$ is true, then the case for $n+1$ is true. Starting by the $n+1$ case in the right hand side, we have that:
$$sum_i=1^(n+1)^2 frac 1i - frac12 = sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 +sum_i=n^2+1^(n+1)^2 frac 1i $$
Now we use $(1)$ with the sum up to $n^2$ (and the negative one half), and since we can replace any quantity with a smaller one and the inequality will still be valid, I will replace the latter sum by the number of terms of the sum (expand $(n+1)^2$ to see that the number of terms is $2n+1$ ) multiplied by the smallest term, so now we have to show that:
$$ (1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+1)+ frac2n+1(n+1)^2geq (1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+2) $$
Rearranging:
$$frac2n+1(n+1)^2geq frac 12 (frac1sqrt2)^n+1 quad mathbf(2)$$
And here I will use a second induction. First, you show that the inequality holds for $n in text1,2,3,4,5$, and using $(2)$ as the hypothesis, we work the left hand side for the case $n+1$ as follows:
$$frac2n+3(n+2)^2 gt frac2n+3sqrt2(n+1)^2 $$
This last inequality, holds for $n gt 5$, because for these values of n, we have that $sqrt[4]2(n+1) gt n+2 $ (That's why I trated the other 5 cases separately). So now we can replace the hypothesis to get:
$$frac2n+3sqrt2(n+1)^2 = frac 12sqrt2 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+1 + frac22sqrt2(n+1)^2 gt frac 12 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+2 $$
Therefore,
$$frac2n+3(n+2)^2 gt frac 12 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+2 $$
This means the $n+1$ case is true, then the hypothesis $(2)$ is true for all natural $n$, and the same goes to the hypothesis $(1)$ and the proof is completed:
$$sum_i=1^n fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i leqsum_i=0^n frac12sqrt2^i leq sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 $$
I am going to treat $x_i$ as a real variable. Then, we can differentiate the terms with respect to $x_i$:
$$fracddx_ifracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i$$
It is easy to show that the derivative is $ 0$ when $x_i=2x_i-1$, and it is also easy to show that it is a maximum (take the 2nd derivave, or just look at the cases $x_i=x_i-1$ and $x_irightarrowinfty $ .
So replacing $x_i=2x_i-1$ we get that each term becomes $frac12sqrtx_i-1$.
Note too, that when using this values for $x_i$, the smaller the values we choose, the term becomes bigger, so there is no doubt that the sum is maxed when we use $x_i=2^i$, therefore:
$$sum_i=1^n fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i leqsum_i=0^n frac12sqrt2^i $$
So if show the worst case we are done. This last series can be easily solved as a geometric one, so the problem is now reduced to showing that:
$$(1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+1) leq sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 quad mathbf(1) $$
I will do it by induction. The case $n=1$ is easy. Now we take $(1)$ as our hypothesis, and we want to prove that if the case for $n$ is true, then the case for $n+1$ is true. Starting by the $n+1$ case in the right hand side, we have that:
$$sum_i=1^(n+1)^2 frac 1i - frac12 = sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 +sum_i=n^2+1^(n+1)^2 frac 1i $$
Now we use $(1)$ with the sum up to $n^2$ (and the negative one half), and since we can replace any quantity with a smaller one and the inequality will still be valid, I will replace the latter sum by the number of terms of the sum (expand $(n+1)^2$ to see that the number of terms is $2n+1$ ) multiplied by the smallest term, so now we have to show that:
$$ (1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+1)+ frac2n+1(n+1)^2geq (1+frac 1sqrt2)(1-(frac 1sqrt2)^n+2) $$
Rearranging:
$$frac2n+1(n+1)^2geq frac 12 (frac1sqrt2)^n+1 quad mathbf(2)$$
And here I will use a second induction. First, you show that the inequality holds for $n in text1,2,3,4,5$, and using $(2)$ as the hypothesis, we work the left hand side for the case $n+1$ as follows:
$$frac2n+3(n+2)^2 gt frac2n+3sqrt2(n+1)^2 $$
This last inequality, holds for $n gt 5$, because for these values of n, we have that $sqrt[4]2(n+1) gt n+2 $ (That's why I trated the other 5 cases separately). So now we can replace the hypothesis to get:
$$frac2n+3sqrt2(n+1)^2 = frac 12sqrt2 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+1 + frac22sqrt2(n+1)^2 gt frac 12 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+2 $$
Therefore,
$$frac2n+3(n+2)^2 gt frac 12 (frac 1sqrt2)^n+2 $$
This means the $n+1$ case is true, then the hypothesis $(2)$ is true for all natural $n$, and the same goes to the hypothesis $(1)$ and the proof is completed:
$$sum_i=1^n fracsqrtx_i-x_i-1x_i leqsum_i=0^n frac12sqrt2^i leq sum_i=1^n^2 frac 1i - frac12 $$
answered Sep 1 at 23:01
Francisco Abusleme
1624
1624
it's right? Thanks
â communnites
Sep 2 at 2:01
add a comment |Â
it's right? Thanks
â communnites
Sep 2 at 2:01
it's right? Thanks
â communnites
Sep 2 at 2:01
it's right? Thanks
â communnites
Sep 2 at 2:01
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2901361%2finquality-sum-i-1n-frac-sqrtx-i-x-i-1x-i-le-sum-i-1n2-f%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
What is wrong with my answer?
â Francisco Abusleme
Sep 6 at 18:49