Verifying conditions in Discrete Valuation Ring [on hold]

The name of the pictureThe name of the pictureThe name of the pictureClash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP











up vote
-2
down vote

favorite












Discrete Valuation
of a field $K$ is a function $nu: K^timesto mathbbZ$ that
satisfies the following properties.



(i) $nu$ is surjective.



(ii) $nu(xy) = nu(x) + nu(y)$.



(iii) $nu(x + y) ≥$ min $nu(x), nu(y)$,



(iv) $nu(1)=0$.



How can I prove that in a Discrete Valuation Ring, $$v(x)=infty ~textif and only if~x=0.$$ Using those conditions?










share|cite|improve this question















put on hold as off-topic by user21820, Jendrik Stelzner, user91500, Jyrki Lahtonen, Wouter Sep 13 at 19:22


This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:


  • "This question is missing context or other details: Please improve the question by providing additional context, which ideally includes your thoughts on the problem and any attempts you have made to solve it. This information helps others identify where you have difficulties and helps them write answers appropriate to your experience level." – user21820, Jendrik Stelzner, user91500, Jyrki Lahtonen, Wouter
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.








  • 1




    But $nu(0)$ is not defined : $nu$ is defined only on invertible elements, so clearly one direction does not hold.You need a more precise statement to prove.
    – Ð°ÑÑ‚он вілла олоф мэллбэрг
    Sep 3 at 10:54







  • 1




    $infty$ is not an element of $mathbb Z$.
    – lisyarus
    Sep 3 at 11:09










  • I have added on one more condition
    – Sulayman
    Sep 3 at 11:23






  • 1




    Add also rules for computing in $Bbb Zcupinfty$.
    – Wuestenfux
    Sep 3 at 13:18














up vote
-2
down vote

favorite












Discrete Valuation
of a field $K$ is a function $nu: K^timesto mathbbZ$ that
satisfies the following properties.



(i) $nu$ is surjective.



(ii) $nu(xy) = nu(x) + nu(y)$.



(iii) $nu(x + y) ≥$ min $nu(x), nu(y)$,



(iv) $nu(1)=0$.



How can I prove that in a Discrete Valuation Ring, $$v(x)=infty ~textif and only if~x=0.$$ Using those conditions?










share|cite|improve this question















put on hold as off-topic by user21820, Jendrik Stelzner, user91500, Jyrki Lahtonen, Wouter Sep 13 at 19:22


This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:


  • "This question is missing context or other details: Please improve the question by providing additional context, which ideally includes your thoughts on the problem and any attempts you have made to solve it. This information helps others identify where you have difficulties and helps them write answers appropriate to your experience level." – user21820, Jendrik Stelzner, user91500, Jyrki Lahtonen, Wouter
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.








  • 1




    But $nu(0)$ is not defined : $nu$ is defined only on invertible elements, so clearly one direction does not hold.You need a more precise statement to prove.
    – Ð°ÑÑ‚он вілла олоф мэллбэрг
    Sep 3 at 10:54







  • 1




    $infty$ is not an element of $mathbb Z$.
    – lisyarus
    Sep 3 at 11:09










  • I have added on one more condition
    – Sulayman
    Sep 3 at 11:23






  • 1




    Add also rules for computing in $Bbb Zcupinfty$.
    – Wuestenfux
    Sep 3 at 13:18












up vote
-2
down vote

favorite









up vote
-2
down vote

favorite











Discrete Valuation
of a field $K$ is a function $nu: K^timesto mathbbZ$ that
satisfies the following properties.



(i) $nu$ is surjective.



(ii) $nu(xy) = nu(x) + nu(y)$.



(iii) $nu(x + y) ≥$ min $nu(x), nu(y)$,



(iv) $nu(1)=0$.



How can I prove that in a Discrete Valuation Ring, $$v(x)=infty ~textif and only if~x=0.$$ Using those conditions?










share|cite|improve this question















Discrete Valuation
of a field $K$ is a function $nu: K^timesto mathbbZ$ that
satisfies the following properties.



(i) $nu$ is surjective.



(ii) $nu(xy) = nu(x) + nu(y)$.



(iii) $nu(x + y) ≥$ min $nu(x), nu(y)$,



(iv) $nu(1)=0$.



How can I prove that in a Discrete Valuation Ring, $$v(x)=infty ~textif and only if~x=0.$$ Using those conditions?







commutative-algebra principal-ideal-domains






share|cite|improve this question















share|cite|improve this question













share|cite|improve this question




share|cite|improve this question








edited Sep 3 at 11:06

























asked Sep 3 at 10:52









Sulayman

20127




20127




put on hold as off-topic by user21820, Jendrik Stelzner, user91500, Jyrki Lahtonen, Wouter Sep 13 at 19:22


This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:


  • "This question is missing context or other details: Please improve the question by providing additional context, which ideally includes your thoughts on the problem and any attempts you have made to solve it. This information helps others identify where you have difficulties and helps them write answers appropriate to your experience level." – user21820, Jendrik Stelzner, user91500, Jyrki Lahtonen, Wouter
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.




put on hold as off-topic by user21820, Jendrik Stelzner, user91500, Jyrki Lahtonen, Wouter Sep 13 at 19:22


This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:


  • "This question is missing context or other details: Please improve the question by providing additional context, which ideally includes your thoughts on the problem and any attempts you have made to solve it. This information helps others identify where you have difficulties and helps them write answers appropriate to your experience level." – user21820, Jendrik Stelzner, user91500, Jyrki Lahtonen, Wouter
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.







  • 1




    But $nu(0)$ is not defined : $nu$ is defined only on invertible elements, so clearly one direction does not hold.You need a more precise statement to prove.
    – Ð°ÑÑ‚он вілла олоф мэллбэрг
    Sep 3 at 10:54







  • 1




    $infty$ is not an element of $mathbb Z$.
    – lisyarus
    Sep 3 at 11:09










  • I have added on one more condition
    – Sulayman
    Sep 3 at 11:23






  • 1




    Add also rules for computing in $Bbb Zcupinfty$.
    – Wuestenfux
    Sep 3 at 13:18












  • 1




    But $nu(0)$ is not defined : $nu$ is defined only on invertible elements, so clearly one direction does not hold.You need a more precise statement to prove.
    – Ð°ÑÑ‚он вілла олоф мэллбэрг
    Sep 3 at 10:54







  • 1




    $infty$ is not an element of $mathbb Z$.
    – lisyarus
    Sep 3 at 11:09










  • I have added on one more condition
    – Sulayman
    Sep 3 at 11:23






  • 1




    Add also rules for computing in $Bbb Zcupinfty$.
    – Wuestenfux
    Sep 3 at 13:18







1




1




But $nu(0)$ is not defined : $nu$ is defined only on invertible elements, so clearly one direction does not hold.You need a more precise statement to prove.
– Ð°ÑÑ‚он вілла олоф мэллбэрг
Sep 3 at 10:54





But $nu(0)$ is not defined : $nu$ is defined only on invertible elements, so clearly one direction does not hold.You need a more precise statement to prove.
– Ð°ÑÑ‚он вілла олоф мэллбэрг
Sep 3 at 10:54





1




1




$infty$ is not an element of $mathbb Z$.
– lisyarus
Sep 3 at 11:09




$infty$ is not an element of $mathbb Z$.
– lisyarus
Sep 3 at 11:09












I have added on one more condition
– Sulayman
Sep 3 at 11:23




I have added on one more condition
– Sulayman
Sep 3 at 11:23




1




1




Add also rules for computing in $Bbb Zcupinfty$.
– Wuestenfux
Sep 3 at 13:18




Add also rules for computing in $Bbb Zcupinfty$.
– Wuestenfux
Sep 3 at 13:18










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
0
down vote













As stated, the question does not make sense: $v$ is not defined on $0,$ and $infty$ is not an element of the codomain of $v.$ To make sense of it, we must first set some notations. Let $Gamma = Bbb Zcupinfty$ be the ordered monoid under addition defined by addition on $Bbb Z$ with the additional rules that $inftygeq a$ for all $ainGamma$ and $infty + a = infty$ for any $ainGamma.$



Suppose $v : K^timestoBbb Z$ is a discrete valuation in the sense of the question. Suppose that $v' : KtoGamma$ is a function such that:



  1. $left.v'right|_K^times = v,$

  2. $v'(xy) = v'(x) + v'(y),$ and

  3. $v'(x + y)geqminv'(x),v'(y).$

I claim that a unique such $v'$ exists, and that $v'(0) = infty.$



Defining a $v'$ satisfying these conditions is easy: we already know what $v'$ must do on $K^times,$ so we simply set $v'(0)=infty.$ Then we only need to check conditions 2 and 3. To check 2, note that if $x$ and $y$ are both nonzero, then the relationship holds because $v'(xy) = v(xy).$ Suppose then that $x = 0.$ Then
$$
v'(0cdot y) = v'(0) = infty = infty + v'(y) = v'(0) + v'(y),
$$
so that 2 holds. To check 3, again note that if $xneq -y$ and $xneq 0,$ we already know this to be true. If $x = 0,$ we have
$$
v'(0 + y) = v'(y)geqmininfty, v'(y) = v'(y)quadcheckmark
$$
If $y = -x,$ we have
$$
infty = v'(0) = v'(x + (-x))geq minv'(x),v'(-x)quadcheckmark
$$
by the properties of $infty$ in the ordered monoid $Gamma.$



To check that $v'$ is unique, suppose $v'$ is some function satisfying the given conditions, with $v'(0) = gammainGamma.$ Then we must have
$$
gamma = v'(0) = v'(0cdot x) = v'(0) + v'(x) = gamma + v'(x)
$$
for all $xin K.$ Taking $x$ to be any element of $K^times$ such that $v'(x) = 1$ implies that we must have $gamma = gamma + 1,$ and the only element of $Gamma$ satisfying this property is $infty,$ so that $v'(0) = infty,$ as desired.



By the definition and uniqueness of $v',$ it then follows that $v'(x) = infty$ if and only if $x = 0,$ because $v'(x)inBbb Z$ for any $xin K^times,$ and we have already seen that any $v'$ as above must have $v'(0) = infty.$






share|cite|improve this answer



























    1 Answer
    1






    active

    oldest

    votes








    1 Answer
    1






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes








    up vote
    0
    down vote













    As stated, the question does not make sense: $v$ is not defined on $0,$ and $infty$ is not an element of the codomain of $v.$ To make sense of it, we must first set some notations. Let $Gamma = Bbb Zcupinfty$ be the ordered monoid under addition defined by addition on $Bbb Z$ with the additional rules that $inftygeq a$ for all $ainGamma$ and $infty + a = infty$ for any $ainGamma.$



    Suppose $v : K^timestoBbb Z$ is a discrete valuation in the sense of the question. Suppose that $v' : KtoGamma$ is a function such that:



    1. $left.v'right|_K^times = v,$

    2. $v'(xy) = v'(x) + v'(y),$ and

    3. $v'(x + y)geqminv'(x),v'(y).$

    I claim that a unique such $v'$ exists, and that $v'(0) = infty.$



    Defining a $v'$ satisfying these conditions is easy: we already know what $v'$ must do on $K^times,$ so we simply set $v'(0)=infty.$ Then we only need to check conditions 2 and 3. To check 2, note that if $x$ and $y$ are both nonzero, then the relationship holds because $v'(xy) = v(xy).$ Suppose then that $x = 0.$ Then
    $$
    v'(0cdot y) = v'(0) = infty = infty + v'(y) = v'(0) + v'(y),
    $$
    so that 2 holds. To check 3, again note that if $xneq -y$ and $xneq 0,$ we already know this to be true. If $x = 0,$ we have
    $$
    v'(0 + y) = v'(y)geqmininfty, v'(y) = v'(y)quadcheckmark
    $$
    If $y = -x,$ we have
    $$
    infty = v'(0) = v'(x + (-x))geq minv'(x),v'(-x)quadcheckmark
    $$
    by the properties of $infty$ in the ordered monoid $Gamma.$



    To check that $v'$ is unique, suppose $v'$ is some function satisfying the given conditions, with $v'(0) = gammainGamma.$ Then we must have
    $$
    gamma = v'(0) = v'(0cdot x) = v'(0) + v'(x) = gamma + v'(x)
    $$
    for all $xin K.$ Taking $x$ to be any element of $K^times$ such that $v'(x) = 1$ implies that we must have $gamma = gamma + 1,$ and the only element of $Gamma$ satisfying this property is $infty,$ so that $v'(0) = infty,$ as desired.



    By the definition and uniqueness of $v',$ it then follows that $v'(x) = infty$ if and only if $x = 0,$ because $v'(x)inBbb Z$ for any $xin K^times,$ and we have already seen that any $v'$ as above must have $v'(0) = infty.$






    share|cite|improve this answer
























      up vote
      0
      down vote













      As stated, the question does not make sense: $v$ is not defined on $0,$ and $infty$ is not an element of the codomain of $v.$ To make sense of it, we must first set some notations. Let $Gamma = Bbb Zcupinfty$ be the ordered monoid under addition defined by addition on $Bbb Z$ with the additional rules that $inftygeq a$ for all $ainGamma$ and $infty + a = infty$ for any $ainGamma.$



      Suppose $v : K^timestoBbb Z$ is a discrete valuation in the sense of the question. Suppose that $v' : KtoGamma$ is a function such that:



      1. $left.v'right|_K^times = v,$

      2. $v'(xy) = v'(x) + v'(y),$ and

      3. $v'(x + y)geqminv'(x),v'(y).$

      I claim that a unique such $v'$ exists, and that $v'(0) = infty.$



      Defining a $v'$ satisfying these conditions is easy: we already know what $v'$ must do on $K^times,$ so we simply set $v'(0)=infty.$ Then we only need to check conditions 2 and 3. To check 2, note that if $x$ and $y$ are both nonzero, then the relationship holds because $v'(xy) = v(xy).$ Suppose then that $x = 0.$ Then
      $$
      v'(0cdot y) = v'(0) = infty = infty + v'(y) = v'(0) + v'(y),
      $$
      so that 2 holds. To check 3, again note that if $xneq -y$ and $xneq 0,$ we already know this to be true. If $x = 0,$ we have
      $$
      v'(0 + y) = v'(y)geqmininfty, v'(y) = v'(y)quadcheckmark
      $$
      If $y = -x,$ we have
      $$
      infty = v'(0) = v'(x + (-x))geq minv'(x),v'(-x)quadcheckmark
      $$
      by the properties of $infty$ in the ordered monoid $Gamma.$



      To check that $v'$ is unique, suppose $v'$ is some function satisfying the given conditions, with $v'(0) = gammainGamma.$ Then we must have
      $$
      gamma = v'(0) = v'(0cdot x) = v'(0) + v'(x) = gamma + v'(x)
      $$
      for all $xin K.$ Taking $x$ to be any element of $K^times$ such that $v'(x) = 1$ implies that we must have $gamma = gamma + 1,$ and the only element of $Gamma$ satisfying this property is $infty,$ so that $v'(0) = infty,$ as desired.



      By the definition and uniqueness of $v',$ it then follows that $v'(x) = infty$ if and only if $x = 0,$ because $v'(x)inBbb Z$ for any $xin K^times,$ and we have already seen that any $v'$ as above must have $v'(0) = infty.$






      share|cite|improve this answer






















        up vote
        0
        down vote










        up vote
        0
        down vote









        As stated, the question does not make sense: $v$ is not defined on $0,$ and $infty$ is not an element of the codomain of $v.$ To make sense of it, we must first set some notations. Let $Gamma = Bbb Zcupinfty$ be the ordered monoid under addition defined by addition on $Bbb Z$ with the additional rules that $inftygeq a$ for all $ainGamma$ and $infty + a = infty$ for any $ainGamma.$



        Suppose $v : K^timestoBbb Z$ is a discrete valuation in the sense of the question. Suppose that $v' : KtoGamma$ is a function such that:



        1. $left.v'right|_K^times = v,$

        2. $v'(xy) = v'(x) + v'(y),$ and

        3. $v'(x + y)geqminv'(x),v'(y).$

        I claim that a unique such $v'$ exists, and that $v'(0) = infty.$



        Defining a $v'$ satisfying these conditions is easy: we already know what $v'$ must do on $K^times,$ so we simply set $v'(0)=infty.$ Then we only need to check conditions 2 and 3. To check 2, note that if $x$ and $y$ are both nonzero, then the relationship holds because $v'(xy) = v(xy).$ Suppose then that $x = 0.$ Then
        $$
        v'(0cdot y) = v'(0) = infty = infty + v'(y) = v'(0) + v'(y),
        $$
        so that 2 holds. To check 3, again note that if $xneq -y$ and $xneq 0,$ we already know this to be true. If $x = 0,$ we have
        $$
        v'(0 + y) = v'(y)geqmininfty, v'(y) = v'(y)quadcheckmark
        $$
        If $y = -x,$ we have
        $$
        infty = v'(0) = v'(x + (-x))geq minv'(x),v'(-x)quadcheckmark
        $$
        by the properties of $infty$ in the ordered monoid $Gamma.$



        To check that $v'$ is unique, suppose $v'$ is some function satisfying the given conditions, with $v'(0) = gammainGamma.$ Then we must have
        $$
        gamma = v'(0) = v'(0cdot x) = v'(0) + v'(x) = gamma + v'(x)
        $$
        for all $xin K.$ Taking $x$ to be any element of $K^times$ such that $v'(x) = 1$ implies that we must have $gamma = gamma + 1,$ and the only element of $Gamma$ satisfying this property is $infty,$ so that $v'(0) = infty,$ as desired.



        By the definition and uniqueness of $v',$ it then follows that $v'(x) = infty$ if and only if $x = 0,$ because $v'(x)inBbb Z$ for any $xin K^times,$ and we have already seen that any $v'$ as above must have $v'(0) = infty.$






        share|cite|improve this answer












        As stated, the question does not make sense: $v$ is not defined on $0,$ and $infty$ is not an element of the codomain of $v.$ To make sense of it, we must first set some notations. Let $Gamma = Bbb Zcupinfty$ be the ordered monoid under addition defined by addition on $Bbb Z$ with the additional rules that $inftygeq a$ for all $ainGamma$ and $infty + a = infty$ for any $ainGamma.$



        Suppose $v : K^timestoBbb Z$ is a discrete valuation in the sense of the question. Suppose that $v' : KtoGamma$ is a function such that:



        1. $left.v'right|_K^times = v,$

        2. $v'(xy) = v'(x) + v'(y),$ and

        3. $v'(x + y)geqminv'(x),v'(y).$

        I claim that a unique such $v'$ exists, and that $v'(0) = infty.$



        Defining a $v'$ satisfying these conditions is easy: we already know what $v'$ must do on $K^times,$ so we simply set $v'(0)=infty.$ Then we only need to check conditions 2 and 3. To check 2, note that if $x$ and $y$ are both nonzero, then the relationship holds because $v'(xy) = v(xy).$ Suppose then that $x = 0.$ Then
        $$
        v'(0cdot y) = v'(0) = infty = infty + v'(y) = v'(0) + v'(y),
        $$
        so that 2 holds. To check 3, again note that if $xneq -y$ and $xneq 0,$ we already know this to be true. If $x = 0,$ we have
        $$
        v'(0 + y) = v'(y)geqmininfty, v'(y) = v'(y)quadcheckmark
        $$
        If $y = -x,$ we have
        $$
        infty = v'(0) = v'(x + (-x))geq minv'(x),v'(-x)quadcheckmark
        $$
        by the properties of $infty$ in the ordered monoid $Gamma.$



        To check that $v'$ is unique, suppose $v'$ is some function satisfying the given conditions, with $v'(0) = gammainGamma.$ Then we must have
        $$
        gamma = v'(0) = v'(0cdot x) = v'(0) + v'(x) = gamma + v'(x)
        $$
        for all $xin K.$ Taking $x$ to be any element of $K^times$ such that $v'(x) = 1$ implies that we must have $gamma = gamma + 1,$ and the only element of $Gamma$ satisfying this property is $infty,$ so that $v'(0) = infty,$ as desired.



        By the definition and uniqueness of $v',$ it then follows that $v'(x) = infty$ if and only if $x = 0,$ because $v'(x)inBbb Z$ for any $xin K^times,$ and we have already seen that any $v'$ as above must have $v'(0) = infty.$







        share|cite|improve this answer












        share|cite|improve this answer



        share|cite|improve this answer










        answered Sep 3 at 23:45









        Stahl

        15.7k43351




        15.7k43351












            這個網誌中的熱門文章

            How to combine Bézier curves to a surface?

            Mutual Information Always Non-negative

            Why am i infinitely getting the same tweet with the Twitter Search API?