Calculating the fundamental group of Möbius bend using covering space

Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
I wish for proof verification, and would like to get other ideas without using van Kampen theorem.
Using $mathbbR^2$ as a covering space, with the quotient map as a covering maps when defining the the quotient space: $mathbbR^2 / (x,y)sim(x+2,y) ,(x,y)sim(-x,y) ,(x,y)sim (x,y+2), (x,y)sim(x,-y) $
A sketch:
so $p([(x,y)]) = (x,y)$ is the covering map.
For the fundamental group, denote $pt$ the bottom-left point of the polygonal representation of $M$ (red point), $gamma : (I,partial I) rightarrow (M,pt)$, is lifted to $mathbbR^2$ by $p$ to $tildegamma : Irightarrow mathbbR^2$ such that $tildegamma(0) , tildegamma(1) in p^-1(pt)$, So $tildegamma$ is a path between two "red points" in the demonstrated grid. Now I claim that $tildegamma$ is homotopic to a finite concatenation of $"red - purple -red"$ paths in $mathbbR^2 $ cause one might continuously stretch $gamma$ to the grid.
Denoting $"red-purple-red"$ paths in $mathbbR^2$ as $rpr_i$, and $p(rpr_i) = rpr_M$ when $rpr_M$ is the loop formed from the left and the top edges of $M's$ polygonal representation.
by the induced p: $p_*([tildegamma]) = p_*([rpr_1]) * [rpr_2]) * ... * [rpr_n]) Rightarrow [gamma] = [rpr_M]^n $ ($p_*$ is one to one)
We learn that $pi_1(M,pt)$ is generated by one element and is infinite, so $pi_1(M,pt)$ is isomorphic to $(mathbbZ,+)$.
proof-verification algebraic-topology covering-spaces
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
I wish for proof verification, and would like to get other ideas without using van Kampen theorem.
Using $mathbbR^2$ as a covering space, with the quotient map as a covering maps when defining the the quotient space: $mathbbR^2 / (x,y)sim(x+2,y) ,(x,y)sim(-x,y) ,(x,y)sim (x,y+2), (x,y)sim(x,-y) $
A sketch:
so $p([(x,y)]) = (x,y)$ is the covering map.
For the fundamental group, denote $pt$ the bottom-left point of the polygonal representation of $M$ (red point), $gamma : (I,partial I) rightarrow (M,pt)$, is lifted to $mathbbR^2$ by $p$ to $tildegamma : Irightarrow mathbbR^2$ such that $tildegamma(0) , tildegamma(1) in p^-1(pt)$, So $tildegamma$ is a path between two "red points" in the demonstrated grid. Now I claim that $tildegamma$ is homotopic to a finite concatenation of $"red - purple -red"$ paths in $mathbbR^2 $ cause one might continuously stretch $gamma$ to the grid.
Denoting $"red-purple-red"$ paths in $mathbbR^2$ as $rpr_i$, and $p(rpr_i) = rpr_M$ when $rpr_M$ is the loop formed from the left and the top edges of $M's$ polygonal representation.
by the induced p: $p_*([tildegamma]) = p_*([rpr_1]) * [rpr_2]) * ... * [rpr_n]) Rightarrow [gamma] = [rpr_M]^n $ ($p_*$ is one to one)
We learn that $pi_1(M,pt)$ is generated by one element and is infinite, so $pi_1(M,pt)$ is isomorphic to $(mathbbZ,+)$.
proof-verification algebraic-topology covering-spaces
Another proof: the band deformation retracts to its central circle, so its fundamental group is $mathbb Z$ too.
â Pedro Tamaroffâ¦
Aug 26 at 13:19
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
I wish for proof verification, and would like to get other ideas without using van Kampen theorem.
Using $mathbbR^2$ as a covering space, with the quotient map as a covering maps when defining the the quotient space: $mathbbR^2 / (x,y)sim(x+2,y) ,(x,y)sim(-x,y) ,(x,y)sim (x,y+2), (x,y)sim(x,-y) $
A sketch:
so $p([(x,y)]) = (x,y)$ is the covering map.
For the fundamental group, denote $pt$ the bottom-left point of the polygonal representation of $M$ (red point), $gamma : (I,partial I) rightarrow (M,pt)$, is lifted to $mathbbR^2$ by $p$ to $tildegamma : Irightarrow mathbbR^2$ such that $tildegamma(0) , tildegamma(1) in p^-1(pt)$, So $tildegamma$ is a path between two "red points" in the demonstrated grid. Now I claim that $tildegamma$ is homotopic to a finite concatenation of $"red - purple -red"$ paths in $mathbbR^2 $ cause one might continuously stretch $gamma$ to the grid.
Denoting $"red-purple-red"$ paths in $mathbbR^2$ as $rpr_i$, and $p(rpr_i) = rpr_M$ when $rpr_M$ is the loop formed from the left and the top edges of $M's$ polygonal representation.
by the induced p: $p_*([tildegamma]) = p_*([rpr_1]) * [rpr_2]) * ... * [rpr_n]) Rightarrow [gamma] = [rpr_M]^n $ ($p_*$ is one to one)
We learn that $pi_1(M,pt)$ is generated by one element and is infinite, so $pi_1(M,pt)$ is isomorphic to $(mathbbZ,+)$.
proof-verification algebraic-topology covering-spaces
I wish for proof verification, and would like to get other ideas without using van Kampen theorem.
Using $mathbbR^2$ as a covering space, with the quotient map as a covering maps when defining the the quotient space: $mathbbR^2 / (x,y)sim(x+2,y) ,(x,y)sim(-x,y) ,(x,y)sim (x,y+2), (x,y)sim(x,-y) $
A sketch:
so $p([(x,y)]) = (x,y)$ is the covering map.
For the fundamental group, denote $pt$ the bottom-left point of the polygonal representation of $M$ (red point), $gamma : (I,partial I) rightarrow (M,pt)$, is lifted to $mathbbR^2$ by $p$ to $tildegamma : Irightarrow mathbbR^2$ such that $tildegamma(0) , tildegamma(1) in p^-1(pt)$, So $tildegamma$ is a path between two "red points" in the demonstrated grid. Now I claim that $tildegamma$ is homotopic to a finite concatenation of $"red - purple -red"$ paths in $mathbbR^2 $ cause one might continuously stretch $gamma$ to the grid.
Denoting $"red-purple-red"$ paths in $mathbbR^2$ as $rpr_i$, and $p(rpr_i) = rpr_M$ when $rpr_M$ is the loop formed from the left and the top edges of $M's$ polygonal representation.
by the induced p: $p_*([tildegamma]) = p_*([rpr_1]) * [rpr_2]) * ... * [rpr_n]) Rightarrow [gamma] = [rpr_M]^n $ ($p_*$ is one to one)
We learn that $pi_1(M,pt)$ is generated by one element and is infinite, so $pi_1(M,pt)$ is isomorphic to $(mathbbZ,+)$.
proof-verification algebraic-topology covering-spaces
edited Aug 26 at 9:22
Bernard
111k635103
111k635103
asked Aug 26 at 6:37
dan
329211
329211
Another proof: the band deformation retracts to its central circle, so its fundamental group is $mathbb Z$ too.
â Pedro Tamaroffâ¦
Aug 26 at 13:19
add a comment |Â
Another proof: the band deformation retracts to its central circle, so its fundamental group is $mathbb Z$ too.
â Pedro Tamaroffâ¦
Aug 26 at 13:19
Another proof: the band deformation retracts to its central circle, so its fundamental group is $mathbb Z$ too.
â Pedro Tamaroffâ¦
Aug 26 at 13:19
Another proof: the band deformation retracts to its central circle, so its fundamental group is $mathbb Z$ too.
â Pedro Tamaroffâ¦
Aug 26 at 13:19
add a comment |Â
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2894770%2fcalculating-the-fundamental-group-of-m%25c3%25b6bius-bend-using-covering-space%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Another proof: the band deformation retracts to its central circle, so its fundamental group is $mathbb Z$ too.
â Pedro Tamaroffâ¦
Aug 26 at 13:19